Rate that Madden : VSN Version

[Boss AZ]

Gotta give 05 an 8.5

[MvP]

9.5...the best Madden to date IMO. Spent so much time playing on both Xbox and PS2. I had tournaments multiple times a week for months.

[Miami Flash15]

8.5 or 8. I remember this one a lot because in 05 I went undefeated with the 'Phins and gave one player a career ending injury, I think it was Ray Lewis or something.

[Shwayzed]

Gotta give it a 9.

[FUSE]

9

[Bmore]

6, was playing a franchise, Faluk got hit by Ray Lewis in the 1st game and was out for his career. Ruined the game for me

Faulk would have stayed for what? 1 more year?


Anywho back on topic.

Madden 05 - 9.0

[Dan The Man]

9

This is the last time I played Madden religiously

[Bomberooski]

9.3 absolutely loved this Madden! Hit stick controlled my fall.

[kyhadley]

9, my favorite madden

[Bomberooski]

9, my favorite madden

Favorite Madden gets a 9?!?!?! Come on ky! Although I like the strict rating system.

[Nash]

9

[mobbdeep1122]

9

The most fun I ever had playing Madden.

EDIT: ^^ That was for Madden 04

Madden 05:

8.5 -- Fun, but not as good as 04.

[vamprb]

9. Defensive hot routes and the hit stick made this game better than 04.

[bdub]

I give it a 9, I liked it just as much as 04 but I fell in love with the hit stick.

[Archer]

VSN gives Madden 05 ........ 8.8/10

Madden 06 coming up in 2minutes