Donovan McNabb: Why he hasn't won he big one

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Fox1994
    Posts too much
    • Dec 2008
    • 5327

    #31
    Originally posted by xPiRGOx
    that play dont matter because we got a td from a westbrook run anyways.

    he sure is a burner
    Sure you did, I just really wanted to see DeSean score on that play. I was like "YA!" and then I was like "OH NO! Don't challenge it!" lol.

    Yes, he's extremely fast. We'll see soon how well he and Maclin work in cohesion.

    And, ya, we probably can assume how things will work with Mr. Owens... It's a shame, I think.

    Comment

    • dell71
      Enter Sandman
      • Mar 2009
      • 23919

      #32
      Why McNabb hasn't won the big one:

      1) His receiving corps is almost always terrible.

      2) Andy Reid is a shitty playcaller with a disdain for running the football.

      3) The star RB can't stay on the field. Even when he does, its no guarantee he'll get the ball enough to matter (see # 2).

      4) He himself has had injury problems.

      5) Teams they've lost to in the post-season were better.

      And you can put those in any order you want.

      Comment

      • Sven Draconian
        Not a Scandanavian
        • Feb 2009
        • 1319

        #33
        LOL @ people calling Reid a shitty play caller.

        Comment

        • steeljake
          6 rings...
          • Oct 2008
          • 8752

          #34
          Originally posted by Sven Draconian
          LOL @ people calling Reid a shitty play caller.
          really? are you fucking dense or soemthing? the last game theyplayed against the redskins last year should have been enough to convince anyone of andy and his mustache's inability to call effective plays. That week he called just 14 running plays in a loss to a beat up redskins team.

          read 'the bad' section here...



          23:33 OnlyOneBeerLeft: jake nobody listens to you aint you supposed to die from cancer or somethin soon?

          Comment

          • Saluki
            Ball So Hard
            • Oct 2008
            • 9445

            #35
            People hate on McNabb too much, Jim kelly didn't win one either, and he went to 4 straight.

            Comment

            • dave
              Go the fuck outside
              • Oct 2008
              • 15492

              #36
              Originally posted by Sven Draconian
              LOL @ people calling Reid a shitty play caller.
              OK Bill Belichick. I'm right and you're all wrong.
              My Twitch video link: http://www.twitch.tv/dave374000

              Twitch archived games link: http://www.twitch.tv/dave374000/profile/past_broadcasts

              Comment

              • steeljake
                6 rings...
                • Oct 2008
                • 8752

                #37
                jim kelly lost to parcells giants, joe gibbs' skins and Jimmy Johnson's cowboys twice. mcnasty hasnt had to play that level of talent and yet here we are.


                23:33 OnlyOneBeerLeft: jake nobody listens to you aint you supposed to die from cancer or somethin soon?

                Comment

                • KINGOFOOTBALL
                  Junior Member
                  • Feb 2009
                  • 10343

                  #38
                  People love blaming the WRs.

                  WCO is the most QB friendly system you can think of. Any half an ounce asshat WR can make a name for himself in that system. You dont need top tier WRs to make it in the WCO. It takes a seriously inconsistent QB to fuck up in a good WCO ((i.e Vick))

                  McNabb has had countless high draft picks to throw to , he gets 65% of offensive plays to make some plays , and a TOP defense giving them great field position.
                  McNabb has terrible accuracy , his only consistent plays are broken ones or lobs to the running backs. Outside of Nov-Dec "with there backs against the walls" hes avg. He can usually catch fire then runs out of steam in the playoffs. Even if he wins won this year how many Fn oppurtunities with really good teams does a QB need to win something ?

                  Bottom line McNabb is only top tier because theres such shitty QBs in the league. Brian Westbrook is where that teams success has begun and ended.
                  Best reason to have a license.

                  Comment

                  • LiquidLarry2GhostWF
                    Highwayman
                    • Feb 2009
                    • 15429

                    #39
                    Originally posted by KINGOFOOTBALL
                    People love blaming the WRs.

                    WCO is the most QB friendly system you can think of. Any half an ounce asshat WR can make a name for himself in that system. You dont need top tier WRs to make it in the WCO. It takes a seriously inconsistent QB to fuck up in a good WCO ((i.e Vick))

                    McNabb has had countless high draft picks to throw to , he gets 65% of offensive plays to make some plays , and a TOP defense giving them great field position.
                    McNabb has terrible accuracy , his only consistent plays are broken ones or lobs to the running backs. Outside of Nov-Dec "with there backs against the walls" hes avg. He can usually catch fire then runs out of steam in the playoffs. Even if he wins won this year how many Fn oppurtunities with really good teams does a QB need to win something ?

                    Bottom line McNabb is only top tier because theres such shitty QBs in the league. Brian Westbrook is where that teams success has begun and ended.
                    Jeremy Maclin
                    LeSean McCoy
                    DeSean Jackson

                    All first or second round picks...and good ones, IMO. That is why I think the Eagles have one more run left in them...However...prior...

                    Reggie Brown
                    LJ Smith
                    Freddie Mitchell
                    Todd Pinkston

                    the only 1st or 2nd round targets McNabb had since he's been there.

                    Comment

                    • Warner2BruceTD
                      2011 Poster Of The Year
                      • Mar 2009
                      • 26142

                      #40
                      Originally posted by steeljake75
                      jim kelly lost to parcells giants, joe gibbs' skins and Jimmy Johnson's cowboys twice. mcnasty hasnt had to play that level of talent and yet here we are.
                      To be fair, the Eagles lost to the Pats in the middle of their great run, and also lost to the 2001 Rams, who probably had the greatest offensive team of all time, and were one year removed from winning a SB.

                      Carolina & TB were nothing special.

                      Comment

                      Working...