Most under rated/over rated Player on Your Team

[RyanLeaf16]

Overrated: Sabby Piscitelli - I still think he is a good player, but, I think the fans in Tampa are overvaluing his ability right now. He is not as physical as I would like and he makes some really fucking dumb on-field decisions. His speed and nose for the ball help to make up for it though


Underrated: Jimmy Wilkerson - the guy has staying power and will start over Stylez White this year

[Archer]

Overrated : Joseph Addai

I would probably take him off this bit if he found his testicles but seeing as he hasnt to date he's here.

Underrated : Melvin Bullitt

Stepped in when Sanders got hurt (suprise suprise) and did an awesome job . Chipped in with 58 tackles and four INTs on defense with one of them being against the Steelers to seal a big win in Pittsburgh . Its arguble that he was our defensive MVP last season

Also helps that he is only set to earn around 400,000 dollars next season

[Obst]

Overrated: Brian Williams
Underrated: Derek Landri, great pass rushing defensive tackle who gets over looked because of Henderson, Meier and now Knighton.

[BazookaJoe5]

Over: Probably Terrell Suggs. Not that he's a bad player, he's good, but he's not the elite player most people seem to think he is. (nor is he worth 40million guar...but thats another topic)

Under: Fabian Washington...he doesn't get much attention but he was really good last year.

[Rayman]

Overrated - Andre Gurode

Some refer to him as the best center in the league. Dude needs help making line calls and still has trouble with shotgun snaps.

Underrated - Terence Newman

Gets no love but is as close to being a shutdown corner as anyone in the league.

[SHOGUN]

Overrated - Steve Breaston

Underrated - Gerald Hayes

[Fox1994]

Raiders

Overrated: Darren McFadden. I think he has potential, but I've seen a few sites talking about he needs to have a breakout year or whatever. Like rushing for 1000 yards. And I think that's crap. We run a committee backfield, and all he needs to do is be a part of it.

Underrated: Stanford Routt. Consistent performer who doesn't get a lot of credit because he's not extremely dominant. He didn't move up to the starting job after we got rid of DeAngelo last year, though, as Chris Johnson got the start and he stayed in the slot, but he's a good nickel back, I think.

[Kuzzy Powers]

Overrated: I guess Devin Hester as he hasnt proved anything.. but I cant really throw anyone in this spot.

Underrated: Israel Idonije.. gets overlooked on our D but you can plug him anywhere on the D-Line and not miss a beat.

[T.Dot]

Chargers

Overrated: Philip Rivers. Had one good season last year but still hasn't proved anything.

Underrated: Mike Scifres. Dude is the premier punter in the league now but gets lost in the spotlight thanks to all of SDs stars

[ChemTheThriller]

Cardinals:

Overrated: ehh... Dansby seems to be getting looked at like he is a top 5 LB... def. not at the moment

Underrated: Rogers-Cromartie / Adrian Wilson

[Kia Kaha]

Chargers

Overrated: Philip Rivers. Had one good season last year but still hasn't proved anything.

Underrated: Mike Scifres. Dude is the premier punter in the league now but gets lost in the spotlight thanks to all of SDs stars

[DomePatrol]

underrated- jahri evans, randall gay
overrated-reggie bush jamall brown

[RyanLeaf16]

Interesting - I remember you (at mm) being pissed by his signing last year because he basically had zero sacks all his years in KC. Just goes to show that some times stats don't tell the whole story.

Yeah, I was not too happy at the time. He was a surprise with his pass-rushing ability.