So... What's wrong with Jason Campbell?

[FirstTimer]

Why isn't Rex Grossman a starting NFL QB & Jason Campbell is then? If he was that dynamic why didn't he take Jason's job in Washington or Russell, Deholmme, or Buffalo? Cause he is not dynamic at all.

You're a retard. Just settle down and STFU. I never said Grossman was a better QB than Campbell. I just said Rex had the ability to make the big play down the field in the passing game so comparing Grossman to Campbell in their ability to take a team to a Super Bowl doesn't hold water. Which is why I bolded the part of the statement that I did. Some of Rex's big plays during that 2006 season and playoff run helped that team get to the Super Bowl. Campbell hasn't shown the ability to have those explosive plays. That's the point. Campbell would have to make the Super Bowl on a team with a great running game and a dominant D where he has to make no plays down the field. More like a Trent Dilfer during that Ravens run.

[killgod]

Why isn't Rex Grossman a starting NFL QB & Jason Campbell is then? If he was that dynamic why didn't he take Jason's job in Washington or Russell, Deholmme, or Buffalo? Cause he is not dynamic at all.

Because the real world isn't Madden. You just plug in the highest OVR rated guy and get success.

Many other factors exist which you are neglecting in your comment.

[Argath]

Do you even watch Jason Campbell play?


The redskins typically win a football game whenever Campbell throws the ball less than 20 times in a game. Coincidence? I think not

[FirstTimer]

Do you even watch Jason Campbell play?


The redskins typically win a football game whenever Campbell throws the ball less than 20 times in a game. Coincidence? I think not

Kind of Like Jamarcus Russell at LSU

[Argath]

1. The difference is Aaron has IMO the best receiving corp in the NFL. Jennings, Jones, Finlay, Driver, Nelson & etc. You can't compare the two receiving corps Randle El, Moss, Thomas Kelly, Cooley & Davis. Like you said the run game has helped the Packers.

2. A lot of games were close games Dallas won by 1, Philly by 3, Chiefs by 3, Saints by 3, Lions by 6. Those games were close field goals would have most of them they couldn't afford to play prevent dfense like that.

I am convinced you are just looking at some stats on a website and making statements rather than views from actually watching games.


No one in their right mind after watching all 16 redskin games would say Campbell is anywhere near top 25 in the league, much less top half.

[Deviant]

Jason Campbell is garbage. This is what usually happened when I watch the Redskins:

- Campbell can't throw down field.
- Campbell holds on to the ball too much.
- Campbell gets sacked AND fumbles.
- Campbell makes terrible decisions, even when they're 5-yard passes.
- Redskins lose.

Can someone get Santana Moss away from there so that he can be useful to the NFL again?

[FirstTimer]

No one in their right mind after watching all 16 redskin games would say Campbell is anywhere near top 25 in the league, much less top half.

But he's better than Rex Grossman!

[Argath]

Jason Campbell is garbage. This is what usually happened when I watch the Redskins:

- Campbell can't throw down field.
- Campbell holds on to the ball too much.
- Campbell gets sacked AND fumbles.
- Campbell makes terrible decisions, even when they're 5-yard passes.
- Redskins lose.

Can someone get Santana Moss away from there so that he can be useful to the NFL again?

Santana Moss is a bigger piece of shit than Campbell. Atleast Campbell tries.


A ball will be thrown to moss.. You'll see him run for it, then then instant he realize he might have to reach out to get it or dive for it, he just gives up and starts walking. What a fucking usless cunt. I like Malcom Kelly and Devin Thomas more than Moss.

[Deviant]

1. The difference is Aaron has IMO the best receiving corp in the NFL. Jennings, Jones, Finlay, Driver, Nelson & etc. You can't compare the two receiving corps Randle El, Moss, Thomas Kelly, Cooley & Davis. Like you said the run game has helped the Packers.

2. A lot of games were close games Dallas won by 1, Philly by 3, Chiefs by 3, Saints by 3, Lions by 6. Those games were close field goals would have most of them they couldn't afford to play prevent dfense like that.

Wow... wow. Ouch. Ahh... ouch. My brain hurts after reading #1.

First, the difference is that Aaron Rodgers is a better quarterback than Jason Campbell. Aaron Rodgers is an arguable Top Five quarterback. Jason Campbell should be worried that Todd Collins doesn't bench him. You also make it seem as if the two receiving cores are eons apart from each other when that is far from the case. The Skins have one of the best tight ends in the game and a receiver who can be Pro Bowl caliber in Santana Moss. The Skins are sprinkled with decent receivers in a potentially good passing game. The problem is that your quarterback is Charles Barkley turrible and couldn't throw a baseball 20 yards, nevermind a football.

[Argath]

I not going into the name calling argument with i have better class then that. You must have misunderstood my statement homie. He is a servicable QB i never said he was a pro bowl type QB. First of all Rex had a run game and o-line things that Jason does not. Can you agree there or am i lying? To make explosive plays you need explosive playmakers. Could you please name a explosive playmaker on the team other than Moss that received double coverage all season bascially a non-factor when well schemed by d-coordinators? Devin Hester scored 13 TD's that season alone Chicago had more weapons that Washington this year.

Chris Cooley recieved double coverage whenever he played.


When Clinton Portis was in the game, all teams played the run a lot more than they played the pass.


In the redzone, especially near the end of the season, opposing teams were trying to key in on Fred Davis and Moss.



Redskins have the players to makes plays. They need a QB who doesn't overthrow a 5 yard RB screen pass to make those plays happen though.

[Argath]

I really don't see you making any argument why Jason Campbell is a good QB other than posting his skewed stats

[Rayman]

Also, if it's not a go route, Santana Moss is more or less useless.

[FirstTimer]

I not going into the name calling argument with i have better class then that.

No you don't. You're the fan of a team with a racist name.

You must have misunderstood my statement homie.

Nah Bro. I understood you fine. Which is why I called you a retard.

He is a servicable QB i never said he was a pro bowl type QB.

I never stated that you said he was a Pro Bowl QB. So you have no point.

First of all Rex had a run game and o-line things that Jason does not.

LOL at calling the 2004-2007 Bears a "run and gun" team. Do you even watch football?

To make explosive plays you need explosive playmakers. Could you please name a explosive playmaker on the team other than Moss

So you named one for me. Moss. Ever think that maybe they had playmakers on the team...they just need a QB to throw them the ball? Did that thought EVER cross your mind?

Devin Hester scored 13 TD's that season alone Chicago had more weapons that Washington this year.

Devin Hester has never scored 13 TD's in one season. Ever. The most he has ever scored in a season is 8(2007). 6 of those were kick returns and 2 were TD passes.....one of them thrown by Brian Griese and the other thrown by Kyle Orton. Rex Grossman has never thrown Devin Hester a TD pass and in 2006 Hester never even caught a pass.

[Argath]

No I watched i all the games this year. Okay this question is to you Argath since you are a Skins fan like myself. If he is so so bad Ryan Leaf Jr. why doesn't has stats reflect that? If he has done more bad then good why is he still here on the team and ranked #15 among starters. I think he is a servicable QB an average QB not special but not horrendous. You saying his horrendous and on Jamarcus Russell level correct?

I never said he is on Jamarcus Russel and Ryan Leafs level.



Jason Campbell has raw natural talent to be a QB. I don't see how he's developed at all since his rookie year, however. IMO, he looks like a rookie out there every year. Making careless mistakes every single game. He doesn't learn from his mistakes and that's a big problem.


Again though, you are making the argument that stats equal a good QB. I have a few statistics for you.

-As a starting QB, Jason Campbell is 20-32.

-When Jason Campbell throws the ball 30+ times in a game, the redskins are 6-22 including 1-7 this season (only win coming against the STL rams). 5 of those wins came from the 2008 season when the skins went 6-2 to start.



Is this a coincidence? I think not.

[longhornfan]

Aside from all the other stuff mentioned in this thread, didn't Tommy Tuberville basically say he had to run a high school offense for Campbell at Auburn?

Well they did have Ronnie and Caddy in the backfield as well as Brandon Jacobs for a year, so I wouldn't blame Tubberville for that.