After last night's start by James Shields I did some looking around and I honestly feel like he is the unsung hero of this franchise. Obviously, people know of Shields' talent and his ability, but, I still think it is underplayed at times. A couple of things that I think are not realized till you look at the numbers:
- Shields has had 102 starts since the 2008 season. In 60 of those starts, the Rays have scored 3 runs OR LESS and he still holds a winning record of 54-47.
- He has pitched 200+ innings in each of those seasons and a career high of 249.1 last season.
- His FIP has in two of those season left something to be desired (2009 & 2010) as they were over 4 (4.02 & 4.24). However, in both of those seasons his Flyball rate and LOB% were the worst of his career and, coincidentally, he threw his changeup the fewest times of his career in those two years.
At 30 years old, he is heading into options years on his contract in 2013 that will pay him $11m+ and there is talk of the Rays trading him or letting him leave via FA. Based off his start to this season, I think it would be a mistake to let him walk. I believe that the window for a player's peak performance is wider for a pitcher and I think an extension of 3-4 years at around an average of $14-16m annually could keep Shields in a Rays uni. Obviously this amount is currently a tad bit high for our current financial position, but, if the stadium issue gets off the ground here and there is a commitment from the area to help finance a new park, then Sternberg has stated that the purse strings could be loosened.
Shields has completely redefined himself as a pitcher. He has evolved and has become an ace. He uses his changeup more, he challenges hitters more and he expects waaay more of himself than any other pitcher on the staff. Last night, after giving up a hit against the Twins in the 3rd. He K'd the next hitter and was yelling at himself heading back to the dugout in a 0-0 game and after only allowing a single hit through 3 innings of work.
Some will say that you lock-up Price long-term, but, I don't know that Price definitely wants to stay here long-term, he has made a few comments, nothing major, about wanting to get a deal done when other guys have signed long-term deals and he has mentioned only signing if the "numbers are right." Plus, he has not been as effective as he once was when he threw that exploding slider he had. The Rays got him away from that due to possible injury concerns, but, it seems to have had an effect on his BABIP as it has risen each year since he stopped throwing it. He almost completely took it out of his arsenal in 2010 and 2011 only throwing 4.9% and 9.6% of the time. Since then, he has become very reliant upon his fastball and guys are starting to catch up to it.
At this point in time, if I had to choose one to keep and one to trade for a bundle of prospects - it would be to keep Shields and trade Price for a shit-load of talent.