Giants or Eagles

[G-men]

Straight up, who's the better franchise and who will be better in the upcoming season.

And no use of the word almost or if. That's the talk of someone talking out of their ass.

 

[Juggernaut]

Giants will be better, win more games this year due to a solid offensive line and a great running games

Eagles will be more entertaining and will be better in the next couple of years with their beastly draft picks

Giants division winners, Eagles wild card winners

 

[Point Blank]

I really can't call who will have the better season right now. I need to see Eli w/o Plaxico first.

 

[Anthony]

Giants. Hard to argue with Earth, Wind and Fire along with a really good defensive front.

with Wind gone (Ward) - I think we're gonna have to come up with a new nickname. Even though I think Ware is gonna pick up right where Ward left off.

 

[G-men]

with Wind gone (Ward) - I think we're gonna have to come up with a new nickname. Even though I think Ware is gonna pick up right where Ward left off.

yeah i dont think the swich from d to e will make much difference.

(you see what i did there)

 

[Anthony]

yeah i dont think the swich from d to e will make much difference.

(you see what i did there)

I be seeing.

 

[dave]

I think the Giants will suffer because their receiving corps, for the first time in memory, are actually below the Eagles.

Manning is an average QB who relied big time on Burress and Toomer. Now they're gone ... and replaced by average WRs at best.

The Giants will still be a team to be reckoned with, but I just don't think they bring as many weapons as the Eagles.

Of course, the Eagles desperately need Westbrook to play at least 12 games. That's the wildcard in this equation.

 

[BWEISS]

As a Giants fan, I will obviously say that the Giants are gonna be better and I really do believe that. Giants defense is just nasty and I think Eli will do a fine job without Plaxico, Eli has been working with his new WR's this whole off-season, such include Hixon, Smith, Nicks, Moss, Manningham and I believe they will step up.

Osi - Canty - Robbins - Bernard - Cofield - Kiwanuka - Tuck = JUST THE D-LINE...NASTAAYYY!!!

Obviously if we're going to be biased here i'll pick the Eagles...

Say that the Giants D is nasty but the Eagles had the #1 D in the NFC Last year and haven't lost much... people say we lost a lot losing B-Dawk but he was nowhere near his best last year, we're losing more of a leader then a Star at this point. Adding Ellis Hobbs is good and Jaqaui Parker really established himself as a D-Line Threat last year.

And in the draft, all the Eagles needed was one good receiver and we may have something to start with in Jeremy Maclin, Desean Jackson showed he has what it takes to be a good receiver. McNabb is still the best QB in Eagles history so I don't see why people question him on anything he does, he knows what he's doing out there. And as long as we have Westbrook on the field then who knows the possibilites..


But.......its a close matchup sir

 

[CrimsonGhost56]

who ? who ? and who? , stop being a homer man....i think its a close one because every year either Eagles or Giants win the division + it dont really matter who wins da division because last year we won the wildcard and beat the Giants in the 2nd round. big whoop.

the Giants DT's are often overlooked by people cause of the DE's but they are very solid players (not some homer shit) . Robbins had 5.5 sacks which ranks third among DT's in the league (behind K.Williams and Haynesworth who had 8.5 sacks). Theres no doubt the Giants D will be one of the best in the leauge but no one really knows how the offense will be after losing Toomer, Plax, and Ward who where three of the biggest weapons the Giants had. Everyone saw how Plax leaving affected the offense and now you take Toomer and Ward out too and leave it up to some unproven WR's and the oft injured Jacobs ...

 

[dave]

the Giants DT's are often overlooked by people cause of the DE's but they are very solid players (not some homer shit) . Robbins had 5.5 sacks which ranks third among DT's in the league (behind K.Williams and Haynesworth who had 8.5 sacks). Theres no doubt the Giants D will be one of the best in the leauge but no one really knows how the offense will be after losing Toomer, Plax, and Ward who where three of the biggest weapons the Giants had. Everyone saw how Plax leaving affected the offense and now you take Toomer and Ward out too ... thats rough

That's not rough, that's catastrophic.
Manning an ok quarterback, but if they're expecting him to win games on his own, they're in trouble.

 

[Anthony]

That's not rough, that's catastrophic.
Manning an ok quarterback, but if they're expecting him to win games on his own, they're in trouble.

well if that "ok" QB can get us back in the SB - I'm all for it. Both teams are evenly matched up. our OL and DL are both better than that of the Eagles. The Eagles CBs are better than ours, Their unproven receiving core is better than out receiving core, one of their guys just married an ex-Playboy hooker - waahoo! and what not.

This conversation can go on and on - but the bottom line is in the last couple of years the Giants have won 3 Superbowls - Playing in 4, How many have the Eagles won?.

 

[Esjay]

well if that "ok" QB can get us back in the SB - I'm all for it. Both teams are evenly matched up. our OL and DL are both better than that of the Eagles. The Eagles CBs are better than ours, Their unproven receiving core is better than out receiving core, one of their guys just married an ex-Playboy hooker - waahoo! and what not.

This conversation can go on and on - but the bottom line is in the last couple of years the Giants have won 3 Superbowls - Playing in 4, How many have the Eagles won?.

??

I think the Giants will be better. Ridiculous D-Line and great running game = success.

 

[mobbdeep1122]

Very tough. Both teams are good. IMO the Eagles are a better team now than they were last year, and they knocked the Giants out of the playoffs in their own stadium. So I give the slight edge to the Eagles at this point (no homer).

The Giants will be better with getting Osi back, but we'll see if he'll be as effective as he was before the knee injury.

Also, the Giants were noticeably weaker on offense without Plax, and they lost one of their talented RBs, so that will hurt them.

As far as franchises, it all depends on how you measure that. The Eagles have been competitive for the almost the entire decade while always being in control of their salary cap and drafting relatively well under Reid. No Super Bowls and a poor NFCCG record hurts them, though.

The Giants were similar. Competitive for most of the decade with a couple bad seasons mixed in. They have what the Eagles don't, a Super Bowl win, so I'll give them the slight edge. Both are quality franchises.

But back to this year, the Eagles are 1a in this division and the Giants are 1b. It's going to be fun to watch these two play this year.

 

[Rayman]

The Giants' DTs are very underrated.

They're gonna look even better now that they're coming off the bench.

 

[BWEISS]

well if that "ok" QB can get us back in the SB - I'm all for it. Both teams are evenly matched up. our OL and DL are both better than that of the Eagles. The Eagles CBs are better than ours, Their unproven receiving core is better than out receiving core, one of their guys just married an ex-Playboy hooker - waahoo! and what not.

This conversation can go on and on - but the bottom line is in the last couple of years the Giants have won 3 Superbowls - Playing in 4, How many have the Eagles won?.

If your gonna brag about winning that last super bowl, please don't say your QB led you there.

 

[Rayman]

This conversation can go on and on - but the bottom line is in the last couple of years the Giants have won 3 Superbowls - Playing in 4, How many have the Eagles won?.

 

[Rayman]

ya won 1 last couple of years and appeared in 1 last couple of years

That's like me saying the Cowboys have won 3 Super Bowls and numerous playoff games in the last couple of years.

 

[G-men]

Wanna flame him now for stating the truth?

no because he stated facts. you just talked shit and showed you have no idea what you are talking about.

 

[G-men]

who ? who ? and who? , stop being a homer man....i think its a close one because every year either Eagles or Giants win the division + it dont really matter who wins da division because last year we won the wildcard and beat the Giants in the 2nd round. big whoop.


McNabb>Eli
Eagles RB's < Giants RB's
Eagles WR's> Giants WR's
Eagles D-line < Giants D-Line
Eagles O-line > Giants O-line
Eagles LB's < Giants LB's
Eagles CB's > Giants CB's
Eagles S's > Giants S's
idk bout ST's cause idk who giants PR and KR's are.

on paper eagles are better but i still say its a tie.

i agree with all of this except i would say the o-lines are equal.

 

[BWEISS]

That's like me saying the Cowboys have won 3 Super Bowls and numerous playoff games in the last couple of years.

It'd acutally be like saying the Cowboys havent won a playoff game since 1996

What he said was actually pretty accurate, Eagles went to XXXIX and the Giants won XLII... thats pretty recent man...