Is Kurt Warner a HOF'er?

[krulmichael]

Welcome to VSN.

And with that out of the way...what kind of question is this? Of course the man deserves to be in HoF and he WILL be.

 

[red33]

3 Super Bowl appearances by teams he's QB'd for, 2 SB wins if Arizona beats Pittsburgh.

QB'd one of the most prolific offenses in the history of the game, and this Arizona offense isn't too shabby either.

Does Kurt Warner deserve a spot in Canton?

Rightttttttt....

palmer
Brees
Cutler

are all better then Warner.

U disagree? prove it.

 

[EmpireWF]

He won 1 Super Bowl.

Yes, he's a HOFer.

 

[SHOGUN]

Hell yes.

 

[Archer]

I would be SHOCKED if he didn't make it.

 

[KNUBB]

***ANTICIPATING NUK'S ARRIVAL INTO THIS THREAD.***

 

[EmpireWF]

LOL, so did Trent Dilfer.

That being said, OF COURSE HE IS A LOCK FOR CANTON!

my bad, I said he won 1, in relation to the OPer saying he won 2 barring the Steelers comeback.


Warner is a surefire HOFer.

 

[Archer]

***ANTICIPATING NUK'S ARRIVAL INTO THIS THREAD.***

His response will be about as predictable as a Drew Brees 4th qtr drive.

 

[bringbackjimmy]

1st ballot without question, but his thank you list should be quite large.

 

[KNUBB]

His response will be about as predictable as a Drew Brees 4th qtr drive.

:ice:

You know I can't co-sign to that statement

 

[Nukleopatra]

Rightttttttt....

palmer
Brees
Cutler

are all better then Warner.

U disagree? prove it.

Lol @ this guy.

Combine all three players total playoff victories, and you get - 1.

 

[red33]

cutler better than warner?

:1star:

All have better mobility then old man warner. They all could literally throw while running compared to warner.

How many Superbowls have they gotten to or won? How many MVP's have they won?

You could add up for all three of them and get the same number. 0

You dumb fuck.

They all have better field presence. Brees is like Patton and Warner is like Private Pyle

Lol @ this guy.

Combine all three players total playoff victories, and you get - 1.

But did you think about the most important factor in this all?

 

[Nukleopatra]

But did you think about the most important factor in this all?

What's that?

The failed attempt at sarcasm? Yeah, I caught on.

Choosing Larry, Moe and Curly was a nice touch, though.

 

[red33]

What's that?

The failed attempt at sarcasm? Yeah, I caught on.

Choosing Larry, Moe and Curly was a nice touch, though.

you say fail but i say win. my proof are the 3 groans i got, 2 more wins then Warner has SBs.

 

[steeljake]

so, is geez the newest name for the many faces of nuk?

 

[bucky]

Archie Manning >>>> Kurt Warner.


Very recently, after looking at Warner's career stats, I considered Warner to be a bubble HOF guy (before last years playoff run). After last year's playoff run (and especially w/ a good playoff run this year) I change my mind to a definite HOF guy.

 

[FirstTimer]

Maybe. I wouldn't put him in on the first ballot though.

Great playoff QB, and great "story" but only has had 5-6 really good seasons.

His case is an interesting one. Had two great seasons early on...hits a pretty good down slide for a few years now has come back with 3 more good/very good years.

I'm betting he gets in at some point but I wouldn't put him in on the 1st ballot.

 

[MrBill]

Warner is definitely HoF and should be first ballot.

 

[Tailback U]

He will make it not only as a football player but because of who he is as a person.

His story is nothing short of amazing and his charity work outside of football makes him one of the most admirable professional athletes today.

 

[jeffx]

He will make it not only as a football player but because of who he is as a person.

His story is nothing short of amazing and his charity work outside of football makes him one of the most admirable professional athletes today.

His only negative is his taste in women.