Madden 2010 or NFL 2k10

[TxHustler512]

Whichone would you buy if both were out for sale next football season.

 

[TxHustler512]

i shoulda added two more options. BOTH or NONE

 

[Vinsane]

I'd go with 2k10 just to say to hell with Madden for a year, devote myself back to the 2k series like I did with my dreamcast and I'd be just fine if it were me versus the Madden world!

 

[ThunderHorse]

They tried this,

first, the question is irrelevant, because it will never happen. EA extended the exclusive license to the players name's, likenesses, and team logos along with likenesses.

2K tried to make All Pro Football 2K8, and while the game was alright, it didn't match up to Madden 08, first of all because of lack in features, but because it didn't even match up to the original ESPN Football 2K5, it was simply a watered down 2K football game with less features then the game previously made before it.

On top of that, 2K was in no rush to get out a yearly title, and had as much time as they wanted to put the game out, even when they had this much time, they put out a sub-par game that the few who took the time to play absolutely despised or simply played to get something different then Madden.

I'd buy Madden 2010 simply because I know what I can expect, right now I wouldn't know what to expect if 2K put out another football game, if it was as pitiful as the last one I'd have invested in nothing more then a waste of money.


for the record ---

All Pro was an "ok" game with great gameplay, the fact that you have to create all your teams according to the rules of the game, the lack of other features such as franchise, and some gameplay glitches really dragged this game into the grave.

even with that said though, All Pro had a better online league system then Madden does today, and their system actually keeps track of statistics of every aspect of the game.

if 2K could get the NFL license back, they could continue making football games, without that license though, it is completely USELESS and an utter waste of cash for Take Two to make any type of football game or for anyone to actually buy one.

 

[stevsta]

the only reason I chose madden is b/c hopefully they will get the online dynasty like ncaa had and if they do whoa it will be amazing

 

[DSpydr84]

100% Madden.

 

[DNEUM]

Madden all the way.

I've never understood people's love for 2k5. I'm all for people playing the games they enjoy, and to each his own, but I just don't see it with 2k football games. When I played it I thought it was horrible. I'm not much of a presentation/franchise type of guy so maybe that's why but I just couldn't play this game.

Madden is just picked apart on a ridiculous scale now-a-days. It's held to a much higher standard than almost any other game because of how big it is. It absolutely has its flaws but so does every single other sports game that has ever come out. And that's never going away.

 

[Aso]

When will 2k be able to make an nfl game again?

I said 2k5

 

[GhostIcon]

Madden

 

[Aso]

I think most of you are judging what 2k10 would be like from allprofootball2k8. That shouldn't be. Madden agrevates me so much. There is so much wrong with it.

 

[dboy_dc]

Madden, Not to mention they've been working on it since Aug 08. 2K was what it was, on a scale it was had major flaws. But the only reason people brought 2K is becuz of the ESPN presentation and it was different from Madden.

All Pro football was weak as hell to me, it seemed so unfootball like.

I'm glad I don't have to go into detail becuz everyone else who picked Madden has valid points that can't really be argued. (Good Job!)