NFL Draft 2009 - Rookie Ratings Prediction Game

[Nukleopatra]

75 Throw Power, 52 accuracy.

 

[Aso]

Yea they are. Thats why i like Nukleopatra's prediction.

Donnie Moore said that in Madden '09 there were 81 players with an overall of 95+. In Madden '10 there are only 50 players with the overall of 95+ as of right now.

 

[Aso]

Someone predict a quarterbacks rating with the short, medium, long, play action, throw on the run ratings that are new it would be interesting to see what some would think they should be for some of these quarterbacks.

 

[Aso]

lol, not all them should be 99.

Tom Brady:
Throw Power - 99
Short Accuracy - 99
Medium Accuracy - 94
Deep Accuracy - 97
Play Action - 95
Throw On the Run - 87


Look good?

 

[ThunderHorse]

lol, not all them should be 99.

Tom Brady:
Throw Power - 99
Short Accuracy - 99
Medium Accuracy - 94
Deep Accuracy - 97
Play Action - 95
Throw On the Run - 87


Look good?

even though I completely despise Tom Brady...

I think its retarded to have manning's deep accuracy at 99 but not Brady's.... the guy never had a problem hooking up with moss on those 70+ bombs he threw.

I mean, I fucking hate the SOB... but I can't deny he has skill. he deserves a 99 in every category manning does besides awareness.

 

[Aso]

I think Brady > Manning.

I just don't think all of Mannings ratings should be 99 besides Throw on the Run. I remember a 1 or 2 times he missed moss deep so maybe his deep accuracy should be 98 instead of 97.

 

[kmanharris]

Donald Brown

72 overall
80 speed
83 carry

 

[Archer]

I think Brady > Manning.

I just don't think all of Mannings ratings should be 99 besides Throw on the Run. I remember a 1 or 2 times he missed moss deep so maybe his deep accuracy should be 98 instead of 97.

When did Manning have Moss?

 

[Aso]

He didn't but Brady did in the 2007 season. -_-

 

[Aso]

So this is the big surprise that was coming out on draft day? It's pretty cool though. I'll have some predictions up later.

http://insideblog.easports.com/arch...ow-about-the-madden-nfl-draft-experience.aspx

 

[ThunderHorse]

I think Brady > Manning.

I just don't think all of Mannings ratings should be 99 besides Throw on the Run. I remember a 1 or 2 times he missed moss deep so maybe his deep accuracy should be 98 instead of 97.

Manning shouldn't have 99 throw accuracy or throw power?

maybe... just maybe you could make a case for the throw power... but I've never, in my entire life, seen Manning under throw ANYONE.

not even 99 awareness?

he is the most accurate quarterback in the league, and obviously is on his own level of knowledge of the game...

good luck trying to pass that one off.

lol

 

[mgoblue2290]

Tim Tebow 99 overall in everything. Also has the special move 'Talking'. In which Tebow talks and his teammates become better because of it.

 

[Aso]

Manning shouldn't have 99 throw accuracy or throw power?

maybe... just maybe you could make a case for the throw power... but I've never, in my entire life, seen Manning under throw ANYONE.

not even 99 awareness?

he is the most accurate quarterback in the league, and obviously is on his own level of knowledge of the game...

good luck trying to pass that one off.

lol

I think he should have 99 awareness and probably 99 deep accuracy as well. I'm not sure about his short or Medium. But he shouldn't be that close to perfect. Especially seeing how he played early last year (even with all the injuries to the other players around him). Also do you forget there are 5 new quarterback ratings?

 

[ThunderHorse]

I think he should have 99 awareness and probably 99 deep accuracy as well. I'm not sure about his short or Medium. But he shouldn't be that close to perfect. Especially seeing how he played early last year (even with all the injuries to the other players around him). Also do you forget there are 5 new quarterback ratings?

Apparently you've never actually watched a Colts game... because that's one of the most retarded things I've ever heard someone say about Peyton Manning... "his short and medium accuracy shouldn't be perfect."

The guy wins the MVP, is arguably the best Pure Quarterback to ever play the game, is notorious for his pin point accuracy and ability to make throws no one else can... but he doesn't deserve a perfect rating?

sorry, but Manning is as close to perfect as it gets... even Jaguar/pat fans will admit that, and they hate Manning with every ounce of their being. (at least the majority of the die hard ones do.)

 

[ThunderHorse]

i gurantee no one will have a 99 rating in none of the categories. 99 means perfect. And even peyton manning doesn't make every perfect throw. 99 will most likely be last years 100. I also will predict that the highest overall you'll see is a 97.

Manning is the most aware quarterback in the League...

100 means perfect, people got pissed when Hester got 100 speed, because it was as if EA was saying he is the fastest player to ever play in the NFL.

Manning's football IQ is far and away from the vast majority of anyone in the NFL, and everyone knows this, compared to everyone else in the League... Manning is the most aware quarterback, while he is also arguably the most aware quarterback to ever play the game.

I'll bend with the idea that no one should have a 99 in any rating but Manning clearly deserves a 99 awareness rating, as he is above ANYONE in that similar aspect. and clearly, is one of if not THE most intelligent quarterbacks to ever walk on a football field.

 

[Archer]

I think he should have 99 awareness and probably 99 deep accuracy as well. I'm not sure about his short or Medium. But he shouldn't be that close to perfect. Especially seeing how he played early last year (even with all the injuries to the other players around him). Also do you forget there are 5 new quarterback ratings?

Are you retarded? Manning was the guy who was injuried early last year , he shouldnt even have been playing on that bad knee , we couldnt even run a simple damn stretch play because of his knee. When he gets to 100% look what happens ....MVP!

 

[ThunderHorse]

Are you retarded? Manning was the guy who was injuried early last year , he shouldnt even have been playing on that bad knee , we couldnt even run a simple damn stretch play because of his knee. When he gets to 100% look what happens ....MVP!

its clear proof he has no idea, because he has never watched a colts game...

Indy obviously had no problems with WR injuries... he just didn't bother to watch a colts game last year.

 

[j.hen]

With the new way the ratings are, I doubt any rookie is even close to a 90 overall.

 

[Aso]

Well i wasn't aware that Manning was that hurt.


"his short and medium accuracy shouldn't be perfect."

Userpikk i never said that. Great job at putting words into my mouth.


I don't think he should have 99's across the board because what that would be saying to me is that he is the best in NFL History. I don't think he is. Thats pretty much saying he has no flaws and he obviously does.


EDIT: Just saying, In Madden '09 Donnie Moore said there were 81 players with the overall of 95+. In Madden '10 right now there is 50.

 

[Buzzman]

Mathrew Stafford

83 OVL
92 Short
87 Medium
83 Long
97 THP