I thought STARMAN was just a beast. Not a guy that will eat up a stat sheet, but the few times I watched Starman this year, he stood out. That St. Louis game earlier in the year, he was the guy I thought he'd be coming out of college. Also, first game of the year against Seattle, just a guy that already got the NFL game.
After him, the few times I saw the Jets...Sheldon Richardson was an animal. Late in the year against the Dolphins and Ravens, one of the best ten 34 ends I watched in the NFL this year (Watt, Calais, Wilkerson, Fletcher Cox, Williams from Buffalo, Cameron Jordan who was a revelation this year...and then Richardson, I s'pose). He is so much better in the pro game than he was in college, and he was a big time college player at Mizzou.
I guess I'd go with Alonso next because he was all over the place.
Round it out with Trufant and Mathieu? Random honorable mention to Nickell Robey, who in the one time I noticed him he was all over against Miami late int he season.