Final Madden Roster Update

[Aso]

Peyton actually looked great right away, but I see your point about most rookie QBs struggling, because its true. Flacco had a great rookie season, has a bright future ahead of him, and an 84 sounds fine for him right now.

I think 84 is fine as well.


Just saying peyton had 28 interceptions and his team won only 3 games. He didn't look great right away.

[Aso]

^ It was 41-0 SHUTOUT!!!

[Aso]

He played bad in the playoffs still though.

[Saluki]

Please proceed to hop off Flaccos jock. The facts when you looks at it is this. He had an average season where all he was asked to do was manage the game and not turn the ball over, he did a good enough job for them to make the playoffs, Collins did the same thing Flacco did, with more effecincy. Doesn't mean he's good just cuz he was under center on a winning team.

[Archer]

I've said it before and I'll say it again, Peyton has yet to look good in the playoffs.

Difference is , flacco was playing NOT to lose his team the game (Limit Mistakes) , peyton was always there to win the game for his team.

Ugh....and im pretty sure deserved or not , he was the superbowl mvp.

And yes for someone who said it above , Peyton was terrible first season , but right from the get go he showed signs of being a quick learner. Even with his bad stats they knew after a season or 2 he was gonna be good.

[kmanharris]

Okay I've heard the arguements about Flacco not showing up in the biggest games. But a soon to be Hall OF Famer usually doesnt have good stats is Big Ben. His stats sucked in the 1st superbowl but was it a question of him not being a good qb. Heck he had the worst superbowl rating ever and that's against the great Seahawk defense(lol).

Who does Flacco have to throw the ball to. Five foot 10 inch guys without speed. Flacco played som e very good teams too. The Superbowl champs 3 times, Cowboys, Giants, Colts, Tenn(2), Philly, Skins, and fins.

For a rookie Qb that didnt even play Division I football that's damn impressive. For any idiot that doesnt look at the big picture at that well I just cant help you see. And learning a big boy playbook from a Division II playbook. Heck Brett Farve couldnt do that and he's a Hall Of Famer. U guys should be ashamed of yourselves.

Is he going to retire sometime soon?

Just because Flacco came from DII doesn't mean shit. He was taken with the 18th overall pick so obviously somebody thought he was good. Why does it matter if he played DII or if it was DI? Is he not an NFL quarterback? Do defenses go out and say "oh he played DII, hes not going to be good."?

[Aso]

Did you actually watch the playoff games. The D was dominant in the post-season. His Defense won him that superbowl. Yes they played bad in the regular season but in the post-season the defense won them a superbowl.

[Houston]

I remember that. The Colts D started to step up, that's the only reason they even made it to the superbowl.

[Aso]

So

[Houston]

you cant win if you dont score

Same goes for your opponent.


And your offense doesn't have to score if your D can.

[Archer]

This is retarded

Without Peyton we wudnt have been in the FUCKING playoffs.....

In the playoffs the d stepped up and won us the sb no doubt

But they wudnt have been there if not for Peyton.

And btw , Superbowl MVP..clearly his stats wernt that bad if he got MVP

[Aso]

Well i agree but i know ppl are gonna laugh but dominic rhodes should've won Superbowl MVP. Peyton won it because he's the quarterback.

Rhodes - 21 carries for 113 yards and 1 touchdown
Manning - 25/38, 247 yards, 1 td, 1 int.


EDIT: In the playoffs that year manning threw 3 tds to 7 ints. Terrible.

[Archer]

Well i agree but i know ppl are gonna laugh but dominic rhodes should've won Superbowl MVP. Peyton won it because he's the quarterback.

Rhodes - 21 carries for 113 yards and 1 touchdown
Manning - 25/38, 247 yards, 1 td, 1 int.

Lol i always call rhodes the mvp cause he was. He also caught some passes. But them stats for Manning are hardly "game costing" stats. Its not like he was carried in the sb.

In the wildcard divis and con champ maybe. But its a team sport. Manning carried the D all regular season.

[Archer]

fixed.

Hayden or Sanders should of been MVP in my mind.

But who got mvp??? not cudda wudda shudda , who got it?

[Archer]

B/c I remember when the Colts ran into the Ravens. The CColts D was lights out on the Ravens but so was the Ravens as the only points that the Colts scored came off of 5 field goals(15-3)!

15-6