Dear EA

[Realist]

I think you should rent it and give it a try.
Play default all-star level.
It's a fun game.
Is it better than 2k10? Maybe, maybe not, but it's not the crap game maybe here paint it to be.

I have live and 2k and prefer 2k. I got live when it came out and only played it twice. Just recently got 2k and enjoy it a lot more

[MrBill]

Another example is fight for the fumble. You've got a guy that clearly falls on the ball and next thing you know your having to smash random buttons to determine what you already saw happen on the screen. How did they think this was remotely like football? How was this even thought of as a good idea?

Fight for the fumble is the gayest feature that EA has ever put in the game of Madden...and that is saying something. Half of the bitches on here won't admit it but they went out and bought a turbo controller to use when that "mash the button" shit comes on the screen.

[Tengo Juego]

Fight for the fumble is the gayest feature that EA has ever put in the game of Madden...and that is saying something. Half of the bitches on here won't admit it but they went out and bought a turbo controller to use when that "mash the button" shit comes on the screen.

The mini-game/QTE is pretty dumb, but the event is definitely not.

[mcstl25]

Just my opinion, but it seems like the popular thing to do is bash madden. The game definitely isn't perfect, but Madden 2010 is leaps and bounds better than any next gen version. EA needs to step it up next year and implement a better online franchise, but the game play is pretty decent this year.

[Archer]

Just my opinion, but it seems like the popular thing to do is bash madden. The game definitely isn't perfect, but Madden 2010 is leaps and bounds better than any next gen version. EA needs to step it up next year and implement a better online franchise, but the game play is pretty decent this year.

Well

08 on 360 = Terrible

09 on 360/PS3 = Pretty bad

10 on 360/PS3 = ???

It's not like they could go anywhere but up. I'm sticking with what I said after a week of madden 10

Madden 10 is the same as Madden 09 + PROTAK and decent Man Coverage

[Realist]

Just my opinion, but it seems like the popular thing to do is bash madden. The game definitely isn't perfect, but Madden 2010 is leaps and bounds better than any next gen version. EA needs to step it up next year and implement a better online franchise, but the game play is pretty decent this year.

I agree. If you find people who play the game sim, it's a pretty decent game. Now it's not perfect but people want to find the smallest things to not play. Just play the game for what it is and stop looking for perfection because it will never happen.

[JTRaines92]

whats your point? i could do that with any sport game

mlb the show 10 is the same as 09 + real time
fifa 10 is the same as 09 + improved 360 control

etc.

Man don't ever compare The Show to Madden. Also, The Show did improve since 09.

[MrBill]

Just my opinion, but it seems like the popular thing to do is bash madden. The game definitely isn't perfect, but Madden 2010 is leaps and bounds better than any next gen version. EA needs to step it up next year and implement a better online franchise, but the game play is pretty decent this year.

I'm not going to disagree that a lot of people want to bash EA but they do not help their case by putting in stupid features like "Fight for the Fumble" or "Pro-Tak" and not giving people the option to turn them off. They also overtweaked the AI on All-Madden making everybody got to All-Pro to get realistic NFL game stats.

If they would just give us some relief on the above issues and expand the online franchise mode to include true league support (which was broken but in Madden '09) with expanded commissioner powers (ability to enter a score for a game that was disconnected or defaulted), then I would be fine with Madden '11 based on the gameplay we have in the '10 version.

[Archer]

whats your point? i could do that with any sport game

mlb the show 10 is the same as 09 + real time
fifa 10 is the same as 09 + improved 360 control

etc.

Sorry. I thought they might try and improve from a bad game... you know, attempt do make it good? adding one or two features to a good game makes sense. Adding one or two while fixing very little on a bad game is annoying. It's like opening a christmas present to find it's the same shitty gift you got last year.


SIDENOTE: They main feature they added actually made the game worse because it was added so poorly

[Golden Taters]

whats your point? i could do that with any sport game

mlb the show 10 is the same as 09 + real time
fifa 10 is the same as 09 + improved 360 control

etc.

Man don't ever compare The Show to Madden. Also, The Show did improve since 09.