How GameStop Screws You on Video Game Trade-Ins

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Chrispy
    Needs a hobby
    • Dec 2008
    • 11403

    How GameStop Screws You on Video Game Trade-Ins

    In the last GameStop article (read it by clicking here if you're interested), my main focus was on the used game sales at the largest US based video game retailer. I should be clear and state that any scenarios I present while writing this article is an actual scenario I have encountered on a regular basis involving customers, and not just a fabrication. We get a lot of customers dissatisfied with new games, which end up in me explaining why to buy used. I'm willing to make exceptions on new game returns depending on the situation. I think the used game market should hang around as long as it can, and I think you should have the right to do whatever you want with something that you have purchased. However, I have never and will never trade any of my games in. No matter which way you look at it, you shouldn't have to trade in over five popular old games just to buy a new one. I can't justify that in any way, but I also can't speak for everyone. So my only solution to the unfairness of trade prices is for you to just not use the GameStop service. This article will focus more on how GameStop is helping to kill the used-games market; even though that’s the exact opposite result they are seeking.




    I've never really understood people that buy a game new and trade it in for less than what they paid a few weeks later, but it's their money to bounce around. The trade-in system by default has to suck in order to make the used gaming sales work, and as I stated before, the most substantial way for consumers to improve things would be to stop buying poorly made games and for developers to stop making them; but none of that is going to happen anytime soon. Even though I may not support the trade system, I don't think the used market is a bad thing. The biggest benefit to buying used over new is that GameStop has a nice policy, which allows you to return any used game within 7 days if you don't like it. While this might warrant customers to treating the place like somewhat of a rental service, we monitor the receipts and only allow so many used returns per customer if they keep coming back. Now to elaborate on the “$18 in the first week” scenario; that isn't a fabrication at all; I won't spend any time arguing that terrible games should have decent trade in prices, because they shouldn't. There would be no way for this business to work; especially considering that I think most games made these days are not worth their price.




    I definitely think that certain games and annual sports titles warrant lower trade prices. It's another way of displaying the market, which ignorant consumers are constantly sure to well...ignore. Supply and demand, yada yada yada, some of the sales tactics aren't really that necessary. The first Mass Effect sold used for around $14.99 just months ago, but as of right now it is $29.99. The release of Mass Effect 3 has created a demand for those that missed out on the first installment, or want to experience it again. If a game is rarely traded in and popularly purchased, the prices rise. Anyone that knows anything at all about economics and capitalism should not find that surprising in the least. One of my favorite racing games, Need for Speed: Most Wanted, still sells used at $34.99 and it was made in 2005. If I were to detail how many price changes I see regularly on popular old titles and poorly made new titles, a lot of you might be surprised. Honestly, arguing about the prices of trade-ins and used games is like arguing that Madden should be $40-$50 every year since it only sees about 8 months of development time. The only reason it isn't cheaper is because EA knows that consumers will buy it every year, regardless of the price, and GameStop uses a similar tactic with their own sales.

    From the featured PlanetXbox360.com editorial (written by a GS employee): 'I think the used game market should hang around as long as it can, and I think you should have the right to do whatever you want with something that you have purchased. However, I have never and will never trade any of my games in. No matter which way you look at it, you shouldn't have to trade in over five popular old games just to buy a new one. I can't justify that in any way, but I also can't speak for everyone. So my only solution to the unfairness of trade prices is for you to just not use the GameStop service. This article will focus more on how GameStop is helping to kill the used-games market; even though that’s the exact opposite result they are seeking.'
  • Misogi
    :misogi:
    • Oct 2008
    • 2132

    #2
    how gamestop screws me on videogame trades: they don't. because i'd sell them either via amazon or something else.
    * Chrispy logs into KGs account to see what misogi wrote* [05:53 PM]

    Comment

    • IamMedellin
      Everything Burns...
      • Nov 2008
      • 10910

      #3
      GS stopped giving you decent value for games back in 2010?

      Craigslist, CAG,And Amazon




      Comment

      • MrBill
        Billy Brewer Sucks Penis
        • Feb 2009
        • 0

        #4
        GameStop used to be one of my favorite stores but a combination of their used games policies, online passes for my favorite games and Amazon now delivering launch day titles at what is sometimes a significant discount has caused me to rarely step foot in one of their local stores over the past couple of years.

        Comment

        • leaffan
          Colton Orr Fan
          • Feb 2009
          • 11082

          #5
          This is about the 4th or 5th thread about gamestops used games lol

          Leafs offseason training!

          Comment

          • Swarley
            A Special Kind of Cat
            • Jul 2010
            • 11213

            #6
            Originally posted by IamMedellin
            GS stopped giving you decent value for games back in 2010?

            Craigslist, CAG,And Amazon
            Craigslist people are too weird for me.

            Comment

            • Charlie121
              Noob
              • Jul 2012
              • 9

              #7
              Try GameTZ.com. That site has been around for years and the quality of trading/selling/buying used games is the best I've come across.

              Comment

              • jms493
                Junior Member
                • Feb 2009
                • 11248

                #8
                ebay.......about to but some on today.

                Comment

                • wingsfan77
                  Junior Member
                  • Aug 2009
                  • 3000

                  #9
                  I haven't been to GameStop in about a year, I buy everything through either Best Buy or Amazon.

                  Comment

                  • spiker
                    Beast mode
                    • Apr 2011
                    • 1625

                    #10
                    I used to use Gamestaq but it seems the owners have abandoned it all together. It's a shame because they have the best used game site that I've ever seen.

                    Comment

                    • ThomasTomasz
                      • Nov 2024

                      #11
                      If you use gamestop for anything but midnight releases you are doing it wrong.

                      I've also never understood the used gaming market. I've kept every game I've played, and I've come back many times to play older ones. Most of the time it is for the N64, but I've also gone back to play Vice City on my PS2 and I don't see the sense in trading it in, only to go back a couple years later when you want to play it again and purchase it used on Amazon.com.

                      Like the article said, its your money, but it's not something that I do. Granted, it's great for people to get games at a cheaper cost, and I used to have an in where the store manager would call me or shoot me a text right when he got in a brand new game used, so I'll gladly purchase one, just never trade them in.

                      Comment

                      • Maynard
                        stupid ass titles
                        • Feb 2009
                        • 17876

                        #12
                        i dont know why people dont like craigslist. its no different than posting an ad in the newspaper to sell something. i just put my 360 up for sale on there.

                        Comment

                        • OnlyOneBeerLeft
                          Fuck em
                          • Oct 2008
                          • 10430

                          #13
                          OK... now granted I was a lil drunk when I went in today... I will say this... they are crooks, always will be... I have NCAA 13 paid off... I went in today, they have their 50% extra trade in bonus going on... I trade in two games so I can get some extra cash because I dont get paid until tomorrow... Nobody there ever suggested a smarter move then what I did, I realized way after that I could of used the extra 50% trade in, put it towards NCAA and just taken twice as much cash back from my preorder. Nobody there ever suggested that, but at other retailers I have always been told about good deals and whats the best choice, so granted that it was my mistake for not thinking about manipulating the system further I am a little pissed that nobody there was friendly enough to suggest such a thing. Fuck Gamestop, and fuck me for being as dumb as them.

                          Comment

                          • MvP
                            a member of vsn
                            • Oct 2008
                            • 8227

                            #14
                            I got $22 for Twisted Metal using the 50% off a few days ago. Amazon gives you $18 for it. I wasn't mad.

                            Comment

                            Working...