Who Did it Better?

[Villain]

Post two versions of the same song. Argue about which version you like better.

I like Trent Reznor's version better.

[MVPete]

Trent Reznor does everything better.

[Houston]

Will never forgive Elton John for butchering this.

[ram29jackson]

[Villain]

Johnny Cash.

[Villain]

Rise Against version is better.

[ram29jackson]

[Aso]

I like A Perfect Circle's version better.

[Golden Taters]

Johnny Cash.

Seconded.

or

[Tailback U]

So far I got:

Cash > Reznor

Cash > SD

Journey > Rise Against

LZ > APC

Guess I'm more into the originals than covers but I've gone back and forth between these two for years. Love both, just depends on what I'm doing and how I'm feeling.

[MvP]

Hurt is strange. I enjoy listening to the NIN version more, but I think Cash's is way more powerful. In regards to A Perfect Circle, the best cover on that album was Imagine. I like it more than Lennon's. The rest I haven't really checked out.

[MvP]

[MvP]

[Primetime]

[GangstaE]