Most Over/Underrated Player On Your Team

[Big C-Dub]

Team: Giants
Overrated: Randy Winn
Underrated: Pablo Sandoval

[chazmaniandevil]

Team: Giants
Overrated: Randy Winn
Underrated: Pablo Sandoval

its about damn time we had another giants fan, and how could you put randy winn up there instead of fred lewis

[Big C-Dub]

its about damn time we had another giants fan, and how could you put randy winn up there instead of fred lewis

good point, Schierholtz can take either one of their spots

[chazmaniandevil]

good point, Schierholtz can take either one of their spots

ya i like how winn is versatile in the fact that he can play all 3 outfield postitions

but id rather see bowker/rowand/schierholtz, but to be honest bowker isnt quite ready for a full time job, maybe next year

[Big C-Dub]

ya i like how winn is versatile in the fact that he can play all 3 outfield postitions

but id rather see bowker/rowand/schierholtz, but to be honest bowker isnt quite ready for a full time job, maybe next year

they need to put Bowker in the lineup as much as possible, they should put him at 1st in road games cuz Ishikawa is non-existent on the road

[chazmaniandevil]

they need to put Bowker in the lineup as much as possible, they should put him at 1st in road games cuz Ishikawa is non-existent on the road

i still dont think the benefits on offense would outweigh the defecit on defense if this move is made, btw you live in san jose?

[Big C-Dub]

i still dont think the benefits on offense would outweigh the defecit on defense if this move is made, btw you live in san jose?

yup, south side. And I know Ishikawa is a stud on the field but is Bowker a really bad on defense?

[chazmaniandevil]

yup, south side. And I know Ishikawa is a stud on the field but is Bowker a really bad on defense?

at 1st, yes

they were trying him out there in AAA but it was a disaster, just like last year

are you in high school by chance? (i go to high school in sj)

[Big C-Dub]

at 1st, yes

they were trying him out there in AAA but it was a disaster, just like last year

are you in high school by chance? (i go to high school in sj)

nah, I graduated in 2002

[chazmaniandevil]

nah, I graduated in 2002

lol aight, just checking, i go to bellarmine

[Big C-Dub]

lol aight, just checking, i go to bellarmine

cool, I went to Valley Christian

[DDRGuido]

Indians

Overrated: Swisher

Underrated: Brantley