Which Line Would You Rather Have?

[Primetime]

.306/.361/.510 26HR, 93RBI (147 Games)
.241/.270/.372 15HR, 56RBI (149 Games)
.310/.372/.540 28HR, 96RBI (128 Games)(AAA)

Total: .857/1.003/1.422 69HR, 245RBI (424 Games)

vs

.299/.415/.566 38HR, 120RBI (162 Games)
.252/.271/.381 13HR, 68RBI (152 Games)
.223/.280/.346 13HR, 67RBI (155 Games)

Total: .774/.966/1.293 64HR, 255RBI (469 Games)

[Slateman]

Second. More runs = more gooder

Also, I could care less how well someone does in Triple A.

[FedEx227]

Hard to say with the inclusion of the AAA numbers. I like #1 better overall, but I don't like that we're counting his AAA stats with his MLB stats which is not fair at all.

[Primetime]

Hard to say with the inclusion of the AAA numbers. I like #1 better overall, but I don't like that we're counting his AAA stats with his MLB stats which is not fair at all.

If it was just 3 MLB players....it wouldn't be much of a question.

[chazmaniandevil]

wait, are these 6 different players? or 2 players with stats from 3 years? now I'm confused

[chazmaniandevil]

if 6 players, give me the second

[NAHSTE]

Total: .774/.966/1.293 64HR, 255RBI (469 Games)

Did you really just add up a triple slash line?

[FedEx227]

wait, are these 6 different players? or 2 players with stats from 3 years? now I'm confused

Agreed. I'm royally confused now.

[FedEx227]

Total: .774/.966/1.293 64HR, 255RBI (469 Games)

Did you really just add up a triple slash line?

Also very annoying.

[NAHSTE]

I would take Barry Bonds slash line if we're adding them all up. He'd have an OPS of like 20,000

[Primetime]

It's 6 different players. Fuck you and your triple slash line remarks.

[FedEx227]

So it's 6 different players and we have to chose collections of those 6 players, even though one is a AAA player?

[Primetime]

So it's 6 different players and we have to chose collections of those 6 players, even though one is a AAA player?

First set of 3 or second set of 3.

[FedEx227]

[NAHSTE]

Um, the first group of three has a higher slugging and more balance between them. If this is some fantasy thing then take the first three players.