Best Division in MLB?

[Rylo]

I think I might have to go with NL East for the simple fact that each year the teams compete till the last damn play of the last game of the season. For example, Marlins knocking out the Mets 2 years in a row! :D

[kyhadley]

AL East

Agreed, you have the potential 3 best teams in the majors in one division. And no i'm not counting the jays killgod.

[Kuzzy Powers]

AL East no question.

[Rylo]

I didn't necessarily mean talent and win percentage wise btw.

[kyhadley]

I didn't necessarily mean talent and win percentage wise btw.

Ah I see what you meant, just hardest to win. I'd still have to go with the AL East cause you have the big 3, and then the Jays and Orioles are doing better than predicted so far

[chazmaniandevil]

AL East and NL East, both have 3 teams that can win it with another sleeper

[Jax]

I think I might have to go with NL East for the simple fact that each year the teams compete till the last damn play of the last game of the season. For example, Marlins knocking out the Mets 2 years in a row! :D

Uncalled for :headbang:

[Irish]

AL east

i think if you took all the allstars or just best players from from teams in each division and had them play each other, the AL east would have to mess up a lot to lose to any division.

more talent and better teams in the AL East

[EmpireWF]

It hurts to say it but AL East. #1 team there will need at least 95 games to take the division, can't say that for any other division.

[Leftwich]

AL East without question. We have the team with the most world series wins.

[OKCL]

Angels make the AL West so tough.

[Youk]

AL East.

Though the AL and NL Central are both fun because none of the teams are great, so everyone can win. NL West too.

[spidey12293]

LMAO. What does World Series wins mean when they haven't won one for how many years? The NL East has the Phillies who are defending World Series Champs, I wasn't going to bring that in to my argument but I will now. I'll continue to say NL East with the AL East a close second.

the NL east has the Nationals.

[Leftwich]

LMAO. What does World Series wins mean when they haven't won one for how many years? The NL East has the Phillies who are defending World Series Champs, I wasn't going to bring that in to my argument but I will now. I'll continue to say NL East with the AL East a close second.

Oh noes! From 1903 to 2008 it looks like the AL East has had more teams in the world series and more wins than any other division:

Yankees: 39 Appearances and 26 Wins
Red Sox: 11 Appearances and 7 Wins
Orioles: 7 Appearances and 3 Wins
Blue Jays: 2 Appearances and 2 Wins
Rays: 1 Appearance 0 Wins

I don't know it looks like the AL East has a lot of championships but the NL East has the defending one. I guess the Phillies 2 titles and 6 appearances trumps the 38 titles the AL east has. Well played....

[Primetime]

AL East and NL East are best in there respective leagues. AL East has more talent but NL East did beat there best last year. NL East is 4 teams deep as well.