Originally posted by mbuser
Ben Wallace Hints At Retirement
Collapse
X
-
-
Actually it does. Wallace was barely a shadow of what he seemed to be with the Pistons. It's obvious Wallace as a player was overrated when he was in Detroit because of who he was surrounded by.
Take Wallace away from the Pistons and he wasn't even sniffing All-NBA first teams of the All Star team. That tells you a lot about how his perception as a great defender in Detroit wasn't all it was cracked up to be.
I never said Wallace was a scrub so settle down. He just wasn't as good as he appeared to be when he was in Detroit.
I was talking in general for best post defenders I have seen in the last decade or so. Rodman>>>Wallace obviously. If anything Rodmans career shows how a true great post defender's career should go. No matter what team Rodman was on he was a great defender and rebounder. Didn't matter. Same with KG, etc. Take Wallace away from the Pistons and he does nothing. Again, Wallace was not as good as advertised with the Pistons.
Prince and Billups>>Wallace defensivly on those teams.
What did you expect Wallace to do when he went from a great defensive system (THAT HE ANCHORED) to a team that played no Defense and was full of young talent that hadnt even learned how to play defense in the NBA yet? I guess a meager "2nd round all-defensive team" isnt enough for someone like you. I guess the NBA giving the guy 4 DPOY and 4 all-defensive 1st team awards has zero merit. I mean.. the whole NBA had to be wrong and you right. It only makes sense.
The guy was a beast of a defender in Detroit. He never lived up to whatever expectations you had for him in Chicago. You saying Billups and Prince > him doesnt make it so. Wallace PROVING himself with tons of awards and accolades, aswell as the respect of the NBA is much more solid evidence of how good Wallace is, sorry.
And pretty much what you're saying is any good defensive player playing in a defensive system is overrated? What about Bruce Bowen and Tim Duncan? The Spurs are a great defensive system, does that make Duncan an overrated defender? Definitely not.Comment
-
Ok except Dennis Rodman is completely irrelevant. I said you could only put Wallace behind 2 players during his playing time at most, and you mentioned Dennis Rodman. Lol @ "im just mentioning Rodman cause hes the best ive seen". No, you mentioned Rodman because you thought he applied and had to back peddle when he didnt. Sorry.
You say facts and numbers prove Wallace wasn't overrated as a Piston. Yet you have yet to show any. I showed you facts and numbers that prove he was overrated. Care to share yours?
The guy was a 4 time DPOY and 4 Time All NBA first team. That's what the Bulls pad for, so no a meager 2nd NBA defensive team is not enough. Wallace dropped off with the Bulls. He made a habit of getting beat around during games and had big issues in the locker room. This has all been documented. How can people not look back and say, "You know, maybe Wallace himself wasn't as good as we thought and he was more a product of the system than an individually great player." The point, that you miss over and over, is that: People thought they had it right at the time but in retrospect were proved wrong in regards to Wallace's percieved greatness.
Jesus.
Kind of tough to judge since Duncan didn't go onto another team outside the system and not do a thing....Apples and OrangesComment
-
Originally posted by mbuserbut since you think he didn't deserve the awards anyway, what's your point?
Originally posted by mbuserand to clarify, you are saying that being named to the 2nd all-def team is "doing nothing"?
Originally posted by mbuseryou may want to familiarize yourself with the concept of players declining as they age. in wallace's case, the fact that he was 6'9" 240 then compounded matters because his being undersized at center then began to actually matter. that doesn't mean he was overrated when he played for detroit -- far from it
Originally posted by mbuserdo per-48 minute averages do anything for you?Comment
-
Yes, you were back-peddling. I wouldnt expect someone so hard-headed to be able to admit that tho. There was no other reason to mention Rodman in reply to my comment.. I said 2 guys were ahead of Wallace TOPS, you added Rodman. He didnt apply.. you back-peddled. Thats how it went.
I dont need to post stats, Buser did that for me. They obviously flew right over your head, not that that surprises me.
What point am I missing? It seems to me that you're completely missing the fact that Wallace was a great defender. So whatever im missing it fails in comparison to what you are missing. Maybe if Wallace won DPOY once you could say "meh it was a fluke, he was overrated". But 3 times? And 3 times all-NBA defensive team? Please.
And what @ being known for defense.. when has Chicago ever been known for his defense? The team had the likes of Ben Gordon, Kirk Hinrich, and Luol Deng.. that was the young core. Outside of Nocioni and MAYBE a young Chandler who was a big defender on that team before PJ Brown arrived the next year? Come on now..Comment
-
And BTW, this whole notion of Wallace falling off as soon as he got into a Bulls uniform as false aswell. Wallace was simply on a steady decline and the Bulls overpaid for him. Infact, everyone was saying AT THE TIME that the Bulls were over-paying for him.
2002: 15.4 rebounds, 1.4 steals, 3.2 blocks
2003: 12.4 rebounds, 1.8 Steals, 3.0 blocks
2004: 12.2 rebounds, 1.4 steals, 2.4 blocks
2005: 11.3 rebounds, 1.8 steals, 2.2 blocks
2006: 10.6 rebounds, 1.7 steals, 2.0 blocks
2007: 8.8 rebounds, 1..4 steals, 1.6 blocks
Dude was just on a steady decline.. but in his peak years, the guy was the ELITE of defensive post-players in the NBA. Noone was better, period. He has never had the most physical talent but is a hard worker and just swatted balls at the rim at will. He didnt get to enjoy a long hey-day, his decline was steady, he ran into injuries.. and now hes pretty much only good for trying to contain a man in the post. I just dont see how this guy was overrated.. he played on a great team, of course thats going to help, as it would help ANY player in NBA history. He declined hard but was a great defensive player at a time.Comment
-
I didn't read. I just skimmed that section. Saw two names adn assumed incorrectly that you were discussiong recent great post defenders. I was incorrect in that assumption. Big fucking deal.
LOL at saying I didn't know Rodman was a shell when Wallace broke in.
DID YOU KNOW HE PLAYED IN ORLANDO TOO? OMGZ! You never mentioned that. I'll just assume you didn't know it.
Dumb ass.
I've explained twice now what happened. Are you too high to understand this?
The one I've been pointing out for pages. Go back and re-read.
And what @ being known for defense.. when has Chicago ever been known for his defense? The team had the likes of Ben Gordon, Kirk Hinrich, and Luol Deng.. that was the young core. Outside of Nocioni and MAYBE a young Chandler who was a big defender on that team before PJ Brown arrived the next year? Come on now..
What the hell are you saying the Bulls weren't known for focusing on D under Skiles?Comment
-
Originally posted by mbuserIs this a real question or are you just trying to seem dense? The Bulls were signing the player that won those awards and would live up to winning them. He didn't. Thus he would be overrated.
so since the bulls overpaid him, he was overrated in detroit?
Wallace, if he made 3 cents a game in Chicago would have been overrated in Detroit because of his complete lack of production compared to the past...............including the immedeltly preceding season.
Originally posted by mbuserYes...when in the context of talking about signing a guy who was the 4 time DPOTY, and All Star, and An NBA 1st team defender....yes. A 2nd Team All NBA defense is doing nothing and not doing what you were brought into do.
see, that's where you are going to lose most people. if you thought he was going to win multiple DPOYs with the bulls then you needed A REALITY CHECK THEN and continue to need on NOW
Originally posted by mbuserThe drop off started AS SOON AS HE PUT ON A BULLS UNIFORM. It's not as if he had some good seasons then aged and dropped off. He dropped off starting with his first season not playing for the Pistons.
actually it started WHILE HE WAS IN DETROIT. his numbers and -- stay with me -- his subsequent impact on the court declined between his first DPOY award and his last (but that's more of a commentary on how FUCKING AWESOME he was in his prime than anything). his numbers actually declined more in his last two seasons in detroit than they did in his last season in detroit and his first in chicago. FEEL FREE TO LOOK THAT UP
In Chicago he made a shitty cheap shoe, bitched about a headband, and suspened Joakim Noah. Declining =/= drop off.
And BTW, this whole notion of Wallace falling off as soon as he got into a Bulls uniform as false aswell. Wallace was simply on a steady decline and the Bulls overpaid for him. Infact, everyone was saying AT THE TIME that the Bulls were over-paying for him.
2002: 15.4 rebounds, 1.4 steals, 3.2 blocks
2003: 12.4 rebounds, 1.8 Steals, 3.0 blocks
2004: 12.2 rebounds, 1.4 steals, 2.4 blocks
2005: 11.3 rebounds, 1.8 steals, 2.2 blocks
2006: 10.6 rebounds, 1.7 steals, 2.0 blocks
2007: 8.8 rebounds, 1..4 steals, 1.6 blocks
Dude was just on a steady decline.. but in his peak years, the guy was the ELITE of defensive post-players in the NBA. Noone was better, period. He has never had the most physical talent but is a hard worker and just swatted balls at the rim at will. He didnt get to enjoy a long hey-day, his decline was steady, he ran into injuries.. and now hes pretty much only good for trying to contain a man in the post. I just dont see how this guy was overrated.. he played on a great team, of course thats going to help, as it would help ANY player in NBA history. He declined hard but was a great defensive player at a time.
2006(Last season in Detroit): NBA Defensive Player of Year, All NBA First Team Defense, NBA All Star, 2nd Team All NBA
2007: (In Chicago): 2nd team All NBA Defense(2007)
2008: None.
That's it.
LOL at Wallace "declining" slowly in Detroit. He fell off the map as soon as he left that system. Coincidence?Comment
-
Acutally, moron, Buser posted stats from the very first fucking post, if you didnt have your head in your ass you wouldnt seen that. But again, I wouldnt expect any better from you.
Lets start from the back-end.. Hinrich is an average defender. The Bulls have never been known for D and never will be a defensive team. Scott Skiles could preach them to do whatever he wants, but the Bulls were never a great defensive team. A young Duhon and Noci dont equal good defense.
He didnt immediately drop off. He was on steady decline. You want to make it seem like it was an immediate drop off because it supports your argument, however, you fail at doing this because the numbers I posted clearly show a steady decline. Maybe you were the only person in the world that didnt realize this. If so, thats your own fault.
Whether or not you consider him great is your opinion, but the opinion of respected NBA writers and players > yours, IMO.
Again, you're not going to admit you back peddled because you're too hard headed to do so. When Wallace got to Detroit Rodman was already out of the league. Wallace obviously wasnt recognized for much of anything while getting fringe minutes in Washington and Orlando. And you still have nothing to dispute the fact that you can only say 2 legitimately put 2 post defenders from Wallace's hey-day up there WITH Wallace, those being KG and Duncan. So this all concludes to you failing at pointing out anything through this whole thread.
Wallace was a great defender in his prime. End of story.Comment
-
You can't be serious.
Wallace, if he made 3 cents a game in Chicago would have been overrated in Detroit because of his complete lack of production compared to the past...............including the immedeltly preceding season.
I never said he should have won multiple DPOTY awards in Chicago. The point is he wasn't even in the discussion and nevers showed anything close to what he was in Detroit while in Chicago.......
I already did. And his drop off started in Chicago. He was making All Star teams and defensive first teams in Detroit the season before he went to the Bulls.
In Chicago he made a shitty cheap shoe, bitched about a headband, and suspened Joakim Noah. Declining =/= drop off.
Again, see above.
2006(Last season in Detroit): NBA Defensive Player of Year, All NBA First Team Defense, NBA All Star, 2nd Team All NBA
2007: (In Chicago): 2nd team All NBA Defense(2007)
2008: None.
That's it.
LOL at Wallace "declining" slowly in Detroit. He fell off the map as soon as he left that system. Coincidence?Comment
-
Originally posted by mbuseri say we give it a few more posts and then bail if we still haven't made progress. we've come this far...Comment
-
Originally posted by mbuseryou are truly something... first you say he didn't deserve any of his awards because he was the product of his system. then you use them as "proof" for his drop-off once the stats show that there wasn't much drop-off.
I said his accolades in Detroit were overrated in retrospect because of the system he played in and his complete lack of production thereafter.
Originally posted by mbuserbtw, does 6th in the voting count for being "in the discussion" for DPOY?
2006 awards=2005-2006 season.
Look at what he did in his last year in Detroit.
Look at what he did immedietly afterwards.
Notice the drop off the face off the earth and not some "slow decline"?Comment
-
I never said he didn't deserve any of his awards. Find me that quote.
I said his accolades in Detroit were overrated in retrospect because of the system he played in and his complete lack of production thereafter.
No.
It's still a decline. I don't give a fuck by how much.
2006 awards=2005-2006 season.
Look at what he did in his last year in Detroit.
Look at what he did immedietly afterwards.
Notice the drop off the face off the earth and not some "slow decline"?Comment
-
This shit is absolutely ridiculous anyways. The mere fact that you're calling a 4 time DPOY award winner, a 4 time 1st-team all-defensive player, a 1 time all-defensive 2nd team player (WITH THE FUCKING BULLS NO LESS) overrated is ridiculous. Beyond everything else.. the mere fact that the NBA and everyone recognized this guy as a great defender and you're not just shows how foolishly hard-headed you are.Comment
-
Look at the god damn numbers you fool. The decline from his last year in Detroit and his first year in Chicago arent dramatic, but they do fall in with the STEADY DECLINE we've been trying to tell you about for the last hour! Its the drop in his 2nd year in Chicago that is actually more dramatic than anything else.
If they "aren't that dramatic" then why the complete fall off the map awards wise? Oh yeah, maybe because Wallace finally got exposed in Chicago for what he truly was. A good defender that was unfoundedly labeled as "great" while playing with the Pistons and by definition an overrated product of the system.
Gee...
This shit is absolutely ridiculous anyways. The mere fact that you're calling a 4 time DPOY award winner, a 4 time 1st-team all-defensive player, a 1 time all-defensive 2nd team player (WITH THE FUCKING BULLS NO LESS) overrated is ridiculous. Beyond everything else.. the mere fact that the NBA and everyone recognized this guy as a great defender and you're not just shows how foolishly hard-headed you are.
/sarcasm.Comment
Comment