NFC East: Quarterback Rankings

[Boucher]

Oh gawd, the grammar popo is hear





:star:

[Derrville]

Looks about right

[Rayman]

no

:youmad:

[Wildcard]

Romo
McNabb
Campbell
Kitna
Kolb
Brennan
Eli Manning

[Rayman]

not at all Ray...but postseason

ELI=====

McNabb=====

Romo====

Jason Campbell ONLY THING HE EVER WON



but come on seriously you cant say the only quarterback in the division to win a super bowl is the 3rd best in his division

And other than that one year, has he done jack shit, postseason, or otherwise?

That's why you can't get mad when I call it a fluke.

[Boucher]

And other than that one year, has he done jack shit, postseason, or otherwise?

That's why you can't get mad when I call it a fluke.

Hes done more than homo

[Point Blank]

1. Eli
2. McNabb
3. Romo
4. Campbell

[Rayman]

Hes done more than homo

Good for him.

If anyone of these things don't happen, Eli Manning wouldn't even play for the Giants anymore.

-Patrick Crayton drops a wide open pass on 3rd down

-DeMarcus Ware is called for a phony offsides

-The Dallas offensive line (and running game) dissolves in the second half

-Romo called for a bogus intentional grounding

-That drive before the end of the 2nd qtr



But somehow, Romo gets blamed for all of that, and as such is inferior to Eli.

[Dan The Man]

And other than that one year, has he done jack shit, postseason, or otherwise?

That's why you can't get mad when I call it a fluke.

LOL, he had easily the best year of his career last year.

Try Again

[Rayman]

LOL, he had easily the best year of his career last year.

Try Again

Yea, before his security blanket got suspended for pulling a Cheddar Bob. Not the same when you don't have that 6-4 guy to constantly bail out your sloppy back-foot passes.

Meanwhile, that fluke is the only time he's beaten Romo head-to-head.

Maybe you oughta try again.

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

1a. Eli Manning
1b. Donovan McNabb
3. Tony Romo
4. Jason Campbell.

[Miami Flash15]

Looks good to me.

[Dan The Man]

Also, Romo had all his receivers plus Roy Williams who I had to hear about from Cowboy fans when that trade was made last year and had 2 chances to get his team to the playoffs.

He decided to throw punts to Ed Reed and then hand the Eagles the ball at will.

What's his excuse?

[Dan The Man]

Eli Manning threw more INTs than TDs in the playoffs when he won the SB. He's either #2 or #3, and considering the running game behind him and the defense, he's #2.

What?

[Rayman]

Also, Romo had all his receivers plus Roy Williams who I had to hear about from Cowboy fans when that trade was made last year and had 2 chances to get his team to the playoffs.

He decided to throw punts to Ed Reed and then hand the Eagles the ball at will.

What's his excuse?

I said it from the second the trade went down. Anyone who expected much impact from Roy Williams last season was a moron. That's to say nothing of the foot injury he dealt with that slowed him even further down.

That said, I expect big things from him this year.

As far as Ed Reed, Romo still brought the team back TWICE in the 4th quarter only to let his D fail him again. Revisionist history must be fun for Romo bashers.

I bet it's also Romo's fault that the team didn't get off the bus in Philly as well.

And he's STILL better than Eli