Singletary Names Shaun Hill As Starting QB

[Senser81]

Really? Because I thought Smith's mobility and his results in college pointed to him being more of a game-changer than a game-manager. I haven't heard of many teams drafting 'game-managers' with the first overall pick.

Yeah, I'm sure that wasn't their plan. But thats what happened. Game Manager = QB who can't pass. Smith qualifies on that count, as does Hill.

[Senser81]

How relevant of a stat is int%?

Is it like baseballs version of BA vs LHP with guys on 1st and 2nd who's BA is over .250 in 78 degree weather on Monday nights between the times of 8:03 p.m and 8:28 p.m.?

You basically said that there is no difference between them. The only reason why Smith was even being considered a starter is because of the ridiculous contract he's still signed to.

No, you are not comprehending. I said the difference is that Hill is an ok game manager, while Smith is an awful game manager. But he's still a game manager. He didn't get sacked all that much, and he didn't throw many INTs, but 2 TDs in 7 games is putrid.

I am agreeing with what you are saying for the most part.

[Fox1994]

Yeah, I'm sure that wasn't their plan. But thats what happened. Game Manager = QB who can't pass. Smith qualifies on that count, as does Hill.

Exactly. Hence my previous line "Most game-managers would suck in any other capacity but they know how to play that role perfectly."

Of course, I guess Smith can't even get that right. Which begs the question... "Why is he still on the team?"

[Fox1994]

^Not in general.

Ronnie Brown and Frank Gore are good.

Fabian Washington's decent.

Braylon Edwards is usually pretty good.

Cedric Benson is resurrecting his career.

As is Cadillac.

DeMarcus Ware and Shawn Merriman are beast.

Aaron Rodgers and Jason Campbell are more than above-average QBs.

Antrel Rolle and J.J. Arrington are pretty good.

Justin Miller's a hell of a return man.