If You Had To Take One

[AJay]

Sabby Piscatelli.

No in all seriousness, it depends on the guys who are around them. I think both fit their teams perfectly but if I were to have to take one to start a team around then I'd have to go with Troy.

[Magnetic Spectrum]

reed hands down,the man is a ball hawk and has a nose for the endzone

[steeljake]

anthony smith.

[Leftwich]

Reed is more than just a safety. I think, IMO, that Troy is a linebacker gifted with speed and pass recognition well enough to play safety.

Reed is an absolute beast against the pass and can shut down his entire side of the field. He can also return the ball like no other.

[Kia Kaha]

^ no but he topic says who would you rather have, not who is the better saftie doesnt it????

[inthecards21]

REEEEEEEEDDD!!!!!

Easy, the gut scores points, plays on special teams and gets tons of picks, the guy forces fumbles with big hits and is always around the ball, i know troy has better tackling but id take a ball hawk as your linebackers should make the tackles

although troy is a close second due to his ability to be everywhere

he had 1 FF this season. but you guys know who im going to say. plus could ed reed do this?

[Vinsane]

I'd go with Ed Reed for my bitter hate of MLB's coming from USC.

[DaBlakeness]

ed reed

[Magnetic Spectrum]

yea troy is sick,but you know your sick when you break your own records

[DSpydr84]

^^ i saw that and just laughed.

I would rather have Dawkins.


But Idk tho its a toss up. Reed is a great cover guy, ballhawk like crazy. But Troy is just a beast vs the run and can cover pretty well.

My friend is an Eagles fan, and he had to work during the Minnesota game so I was texting him updates, and I have not seen a player play with such emotion and passion than I did number 20. I used to think Dawkins was just a good safety, but after really watching him play, it is really amazing some of the plays he makes and the job he does for his defense.

As for the question, I haven't gotten a chance to watch a lot of either player, but Ed Reed always impressed me with his range. He gets interceptions all over the field.

[steeljake]

dawkins is a beast, he is basically ray lewis but a safety instead.

[Wildcard]

I'm surprised no one gave me shit for picking Roy Williams.

Anyways.... well there is no Anyways.

I hate Polamalu with a passion.

I hate Ed Reed.

If I really really really had to pick one?

Ed Reed.

[ultfrisbee]

How can you hate a football player "with a passion" ?

[steeljake]

how can you have a name like ultrfrisbee?

i was pretty sure the roy williams thing was a joke.

[Len B]

how can you have a name like ultrfrisbee?

i was pretty sure the roy williams thing was a joke.

Don't be jealous of his name.

Ed Reed.