Top 10 NFL Players of the Decade

[Derrville]

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-countdowns/09000d5d81567593/Top-10-players-of-the-decade

NFL Networks Top 10 players of the decade:

10. Kurt Warner
9. Brett Favre
8. Donovan Mcnabb
7. Tony Gonzalez
6. Jason Taylor
5. Derrick Brooks
4. Ray Lewis
3. Ladanian Tomlinson
2. Peyton Manning
1. Tom Brady


Thoughts? Lists of your own?

BTW Happy New Years/Decade guys.

[St. Francisco]

(This oughta make Nuk happy) I'd have Kurt Warner much higher on that list.

[dMerch]

thats tough but personally i think id have manning befor brady.

[hoodyallen]

I don't really like LT at number 3. In his prime he was one of the best offensive players of all time, but he hasn't won jack shit in his career. The last couple of years he hasn't even played in the playoffs, somehow he always has some small nagging injury that keeps him on the sideline wearing that stupid visor helmet. Again, superb, superb player, but I personally would put Ray Lewis in front of him.

[steeljake]

manning > brady.

[Leftwich]

I can't completely argue with that list.

[Gonzo]

How can you feasibly believe that McNabb had a better decade than Kurt Warner?

Warner : McNabb
3 Super Bowl Trips, 1 Victory : 1 Super Bowl trip, 1 Loss
Arizona Cardinals, St. Louis Rams : A strong Philly Eagles team

I have no idea how you can make this list without Warner in the top 4, 5.

[Gonzo]

On second thought, how can you put and defensive player in front of Warner? Outside of Manning and Brady, there's nobody else on that list that can really alter a team's gameplan like Warner can.

[EmpireWF]

No Strahan?

Unlike McNabb, he actually won a Super Bowl.

[EmpireWF]

There's a number of guys on that list without a ring, not just McNabb. How can Strahan be up there when he hasn't been in the L for 3 years this decade?

B/c for 7 years, he was a top 3 DE, right up there with Jason Taylor

[strahanfan92]

strahan>>jason taylor

[Len B]

Wow I guess DBs don't matter at all...


Champ Bailey, Ed Reed, or Ty Law.. One of them should have been on the list.

lol @ Ty Law

Love the guy but no way/shape/form is he top ten of the decade.

[hoodyallen]

Best playoff DB of the decade.

He's clutch, but he's probably only the 4th or 5th best DB of the decade, and not a top 10 player.

[Derrville]

strahan>>jason taylor

This.

[EmpireWF]

OL get no love. But you are gonna wait awhile when someone names the best players of the decade if you are able to get past the QBs, RBs, WRs and defensive players.