Hakeem Nicks Vs. Percy Harvin Vs. Kenny Britt

[hoodyallen]

1. Which receiver would you rather have now?

2. Which receiver has the highest ceiling?

3. Which receiver is most likely to reach their ceiling?

[SHOGUN]

1. Percy Harvin
2. Kenny Britt
3. Hakeem Nicks

[red33]

britt is gonna be the best then harvin then nicks

[CrimsonGhost56]

ill take hakeem the dream. most yards, 4th in catches, 2nd in TD's, most receptions of 20+ and 40+ yards among rookie receivers while missing 4 games

[bcransom]

Nicks is obviously the more complete player. Harvin has the highlight reel skill set, Nicks has the "long, consistent career in the NFL" skill set.

[hoodyallen]

1. Nicks
2. Harvin
3. Nicks


Hakeem is definitely the most consistent of the trio. He's got a nice combination of size, speed, and hands, and is even an above average blocker. He's a very complete WR, even as a rookie. I think Harvin as the highest ceiling because he's so versatile and explosive, and can make you miss so easily. There are definitely concerns with his durability though and that could hinder his progress.

[Shwayzed]

1) Nicks/Britt.

2) Harvin. Potential to be dangerous.

3) Nicks.

[DoubleDeuce]

Nicks is gonna be a do-work player that doesn't get his name called as much as the others. Harvin's a human highlight reel. Britt's gonna be a many time pro-bowler.

[OnlyOneBeerLeft]

1. Nicks
2. Harvin
3. Nicks


Hakeem is definitely the most consistent of the trio. He's got a nice combination of size, speed, and hands, and is even an above average blocker. He's a very complete WR, even as a rookie. I think Harvin as the highest ceiling because he's so versatile and explosive, and can make you miss so easily. There are definitely concerns with his durability though and that could hinder his progress.

Nicks is my favorite of them, but his hands are not great, he makes ridiculous catches yes, but not so much in traffic and he is always trying to focus on making a highlight play and loses concecntration on easy catches.

Britt has the same speed, a bit taller, "tougher" in my eyes. Now the QB situation makes the difference in all of it, Nicks has the most consistent of them and the best future lined up to have a decent QB.

[Juggernaut]

KB all the way

Rutgers reppin ftw

[hoodyallen]

Nicks is my favorite of them, but his hands are not great, he makes ridiculous catches yes, but not so much in traffic and he is always trying to focus on making a highlight play and loses concecntration on easy catches.

Britt has the same speed, a bit taller, "tougher" in my eyes. Now the QB situation makes the difference in all of it, Nicks has the most consistent of them and the best future lined up to have a decent QB.

Nicks definitely has solid hands. He'll drop an easy one here and there, but he always seems to come up with huge catches. If you look at the stats, he catches 65 percent of balls thrown at him, which is pretty dang solid. I agree with you on Britt, he's bigger tougher and brings a bit more to the table, he just doesn't make as many "wow" plays, and has Vince Young as his QB.

[Tailback U]

Nicks because he has the best QB among the 3 of them for the next 10 years.

[Archer]

No Collie? Fuck this poll

But seriously since white slot wrs don't count ;)

1.Harvin
2.Nicks (Should probably have the same QB passing to him for a LONNGGGG time)
3.Nicks

[steeljake]

collie is DQ'ed cuz peyton manning could make limas sweed into a viable wide out.

nicks has the big play ability, but like OOBL said his hands in traffic and on routine catches is bad. i would go harvin, britt then nicks. but to be honest the homer in me says mike wallace is better than them all.

[MrBill]

1. Nicks - Best opportunity to be a consistently productive at the WR position
2. Harvin - Human highlight reel and probably the most talented but has durability issues
3. Britt - Has all of the tools to be a solid possession receiver and a nice career