Rank the remaining playoff QBs...

[Maynard]

Sanchez is number one. The rest are irrelevant.

were arent talking about the dirty sanchez you perve

[bringbackjimmy]

1.Warner-It's taken time i know, but hard to argue stats. It's going to great watching a Warner/Romo NFC Championship game...

2.Manning-4 mvp's speak for themselves.

3.Romo-Playing the best football of his career and probably the best of any QB remaining in the playoffs.

4.Brees-great QB, but nuk keeps reminding us 1-8 in playoffs..

5.Rivers- before the cowboys game I really liked Rivers, but after seeing that pretty much all he does is throw jump balls to his 6'5"+ WR's and has the look of somebody you just want to punch goes down on my list.

6.Favre- I will forever Hate Brett Favre..I really hope childress thinks Favre was worth the extra 1 win. esp when they lose and the owner picks brett over him..

7.Flacco-may be hurt may be not...

8.Sanchez-all about the win. he beats the bengals and then gets to make fun of carrol.

edit:can see reason.

[Juggernaut]

Sanchez should be #8, dont get me wrong

But if he is less likely to lose the game for the jets than some of the other qbs for their team.

Just my 2 cents.

[bringbackjimmy]

Sanchez should be #8, dont get me wrong

But if he is less likely to lose the game for the jets than some of the other qbs for their team.

Just my 2 cents.

while i would put sanchez 8, but there is something clearly wrong with flacco so i am going to think he is the biggest liability. Flacco is clearly a better QB overall and will be in his career, but when you throw 10 passes it's like your trying to hide something..

[GoChargers]

1) Kurt Warner He belongs at #1. He is almost on the same talent level as Manning and has a far superior playoff record to him. You know he isn't going to lose your team a postseason game.

2) Peyton Manning Both he and Rivers are .500 in the playoffs but obviously Manning has the ring and has had the better career. There isn't much splitting the two when it comes to post season play but I'll give the nod to Manning for now.

3) Philip Rivers He peaks at the right time of season, take away a poor performance in the AFC Championship game against the Patriots 2 years back, he has had a pretty solid postseason career and put the Chargers in position to win (3TD, 1INT last year vs Steelers). Game on the line, time running out, 1 of 3 quarterbacks in the postseason I would trust.

4) Drew Brees Again - talent wise he would probably be ranked #2. His postseason play up to now hasn't been too bad and this is the year he will improve on his record.

5) Brett Favre Great career and a good season. Will be a great matchup between he and Romo and it will come down to who wants it more.

6) Tony Romo Despite being ranked 6, he is still a good quarterback and got over that December/postseason slump this season. A ring would shut all the doubters up and finally end the somewhat irrelevent debate of Eli vs Romo - Romo will be considered the better QB.

7) Joe Flacco The Ravens won't be winning off their passing game. Not this postseason anyway. But hey, 2 playoff wins in 2 NFL seasons isn't bad at all.

8) Mark Sanchez The only QB here without a postseason loss but he is ranked #8? I think we'll see the rookie in him this week. Lets hope so anyway

[GoChargers]

DREW BREES DOES NOT HAVE AN EXTREMELY POOR POSTSEASON CAREER.

And his record is NOT 1-8.

It is 1-2. (One of those being the Chargers vs Jets game, Kaeding misses a 40yarder to win the game)


Vs Jets 31/42, 319yds, 2TD, 1INT.
Vs Eagles 20/32, 243yds, 1TD, 0INT.
Vs Bears 27/49, 354yds, 2TD, 1INT.


Alot of you seem to think he is going to come into this game vs the Cards - fumble the ball 3 times and throw 4 picks.



And bringbackjimmy, I had to groan that post. Romo > Rivers is laughable. What? Because he finally got a postseason victory? Rivers has 3 and he can do more than "throw jump balls to his 6"5 recievers". Give me a break

[Hasselbeck]

1. Manning
2. Brees
3. Warner
4. Rivers
5. Favre
6. Romo
7. Flacco
8. Sanchez
451. Painter

[seaplus]

who the fuck is phillip rivers?

[bringbackjimmy]

DREW BREES DOES NOT HAVE AN EXTREMELY POOR POSTSEASON CAREER.

And his record is NOT 1-8.

It is 1-2. (One of those being the Chargers vs Jets game, Kaeding misses a 40yarder to win the game)


Vs Jets 31/42, 319yds, 2TD, 1INT.
Vs Eagles 20/32, 243yds, 1TD, 0INT.
Vs Bears 27/49, 354yds, 2TD, 1INT.


Alot of you seem to think he is going to come into this game vs the Cards - fumble the ball 3 times and throw 4 picks.



And bringbackjimmy, I had to groan that post. Romo > Rivers is laughable. What? Because he finally got a postseason victory? Rivers has 3 and he can do more than "throw jump balls to his 6"5 recievers". Give me a break

sorry must of misread nuk post.....anyways it's a opionion thread like who do you like better...sorry if i wanted a QB that just threw it up and have his WR make a play i would go with Rivers..if i want a QB that can actually make plays with out relying on the jump ball I'll go with Romo... I don't like Rivers and in my opinion Romo>Rivers sorry...

edit: I watched the Dallas game and all he did was throw jump balls to the sideline...

[bringbackjimmy]

again Flacco is obviously hurt and the coaching staff doesn't have confidense in him or he would have thrown more than 10 passes......

[Tailback U]

again Flacco is obviously hurt and the coaching staff doesn't have confidense in him or he would have thrown more than 10 passes......

he didn't need to throw more than 10 passes. that's why he didn't.

[bringbackjimmy]

Btw I love the fact that people groan my opinion list in a thread that ask to give your opinion. Don't see me groaning every post that has Brett favre who really hasn't done crap in the playoffs since his last sb run besides set int Records #2. People need to get a fucking life and stop harassing me...

On to flacco yeah at the end of the game they didn't need hi
to, but I remember a 3 and like 8 after suggs ff where they ran in what clearly was a passing situAtion.. Ravens can't Trent dilfer teams this yr.

[Bmore]

Btw I love the fact that people groan my opinion list in a thread that ask to give your opinion. Don't see me groaning every post that has Brett favre who really hasn't done crap in the playoffs since his last sb run besides set int Records #2. People need to get a fucking life and stop harassing me...

On to flacco yeah at the end of the game they didn't need hi
to, but I remember a 3 and like 8 after suggs ff where they ran in what clearly was a passing situAtion.. Ravens can't Trent dilfer teams this yr.

Maybe you don't watch the Ravens, but we are known for running the ball in passing situations (we did this even with McNair). It's nothing against Flacco, at the beginning of the season we passed a lot and for 3 games were doing fine, but we hit that losing streak because we weren't running out enough of the clock. Thus we resorted back to old tricks.

If your HB was averaging as many yards as Ray Rice per rush. You would hand the ball off to him in 3rd and 5+. When it was 3rd and long, we passed it. Remember the Mark Clayton first down?

[Liquidrob]

1. Manning
2. Brees
3. Warner
4. Rivers
5. Favre
6. Sanchez
7. Flacco
8. Romo

This will be Kurt's last game, he will pass the torch to Bress and nuk will have a new favorite QB

sidenote: Drew Breeeessssssss

[bringbackjimmy]

1. Manning
2. Brees
3. Warner
4. Rivers
5. Favre
6. Sanchez
7. Flacco
8. Romo

This will be Kurt's last game, he will pass the torch to Bress and nuk will have a new favorite QB

sidenote: Drew Breeeessssssss

people look i am not going to groan his post. even though I clearly disagree with his list... Thank you rob for giving us your opinion in this opinion thread...