[Countdown] Top 25 Players in the NFL

[Goober]

I answered your question a long time ago at the beginning of the thread. They were ranked on how good of players they are, i.e. at what level they play the game, and admitted that it is extremely difficult to judge and that there would be some inaccuracies.

You, predictably, came in here, dropped a recycled insult that someone like you literally already used in this thread, groaned a couple posts, and have contributed nothing.

your logic is obviously terrible, if you consider Calvin Johnson and Carson Palmer top 10 at their respective positions. Watch a few games before you start making half assed rankings.

[bcransom]

your logic is obviously terrible, if you consider Calvin Johnson and Carson Palmer top 10 at their respective positions. Watch a few games before you start making half assed rankings.

Calvin Johnson put up 1331 yards with Dante Culpepper, Drew Stanton, and God knows who else throwing him the football. Did he have a little bit of a sophomore slump? Yes.

Palmer was in there for lack of a better option, I copied and pasted a list I made months ago to save time and made 7-10 tweaks.


Any actual arguments against the list or are you going to keep avoiding the question and making yourself look even more pathetic?

[Goober]

Calvin Johnson put up 1331 yards with Dante Culpepper, Drew Stanton, and God knows who else throwing him the football. Did he have a little bit of a sophomore slump? Yes.

Palmer was in there for lack of a better option, I copied and pasted a list I made months ago to save time and made 7-10 tweaks.


Any actual arguments against the list or are you going to keep avoiding the question and making yourself look even more pathetic?

Sophomore slump? It's good to see you haven't done any research. 2009 was Johnson's third year in the league, and his sophomore season was by far his best. It's hard to take anything serious when you can't even get simple facts like that right. Add to it, that several players have consistently performed at higher levels then Johnson since he was in the league, such as Marshall, Wayne, White etc. the list goes on and on. It isn't hard to outperform someone who has averaged 64 catches, 1024 yards, and 7 touchdowns each year in the NFL. Good but definitely not great numbers.

Why exactly did you pick Johnson? Are you taking advice from Matt Millen or what?

[MVP1991]

Jake Long>>>Ryan Clady

That is all.

[Bmore]

lol Batcave

[SethMode]

LOL at being groaned by Bmore and OOBL when bcransom HIMSELF won't groan me. Jesus Christ you two are faggots. So bc and I disagree on some selections, he's a big boy. I don't think he needs some defense committee.

All of that said, I disagree with most of your list, but hey, as I said before, I'm guessing part of the reason you DID a list was to stir debate so there you go. More power to ya.

[Bmore]

LOL at being groaned by Bmore and OOBL when bcransom HIMSELF won't groan me. Jesus Christ you two are faggots. So bc and I disagree on some selections, he's a big boy. I don't think he needs some defense committee.

All of that said, I disagree with most of your list, but hey, as I said before, I'm guessing part of the reason you DID a list was to stir debate so there you go. More power to ya.

I groaned you because you called me a fuckin' cunt you dipshit.

Wow you are pretty fuckin' stupid.

[Goober]

I groaned you because you called me a fuckin' cunt you dipshit.

Wow you are pretty fuckin' stupid.

fuckin' cunt.

[SethMode]

I groaned you because you called me a fuckin' cunt you dipshit.

Wow you are pretty fuckin' stupid.

You're a Ravens fan, what do you want from me? Stop being a cunt.

[Rayman]

smh @ Harrison over Ware

[SethMode]

smh @ Harrison over Ware

IMO Harrison is a more complete LB. But obviously our respective bias' are going to have us on opposite sides of that debate. :inlove:

[Rayman]

IMO Harrison is a more complete LB. But obviously our respective bias' are going to have us on opposite sides of that debate. :inlove:

Eh, I think Ware's as good a run-stopper as anyone else at WOLB in a 3-4. Don't know where this stigma that he's not a complete player comes from. He's strong, fundamentally sound, and takes good angles.

Credit for that has to go to Parcells' staff for stressing to him how important it was to be not be a one trick pony. Wade built on that and turned him into the pass rushing terror of the league.

Mind you, he started last season with a fracture in his foot and ended it with the foot still messed up, a broken wrist, and a neck sprain.

But yeah, between me and you, it's all bias