Who are some QBs you want to become starters?

[Golden Taters]

Goblinslayer?

[biggamejrs]

um, no. Just stop, please.

[Woy]

Vince Young over Peyton Manning...































...on the AFC Pro Bowl team.

[Point Blank]

Barney

[Justo]

John Parker Wilson over Matt Ryan because he has such nice light brown hair

[riley420]

Tim Tebow over Peyton Manning.

[Justo]

John Parker Wilson sucks, man

so does just about every other QB you said in the original post

[JTRaines92]

Lol I seen people's names under you post and I was thinking WTF. I then found out that groans are back.

[Warner2BruceTD]

I want

Rhett Bomar to take over for the Giants. Never liked Eli and saw Bomar when he was at Oklahoma and he was good at throwing the ball.

David Carr obviously to start over Alex Smith. Big fan of Carr.

Colt Brennan to start over Jason Campbell in Oakland. He's my favorite NFL player.

Charlie Whitehurst to start over Matt Hasselbeck.

Chase Daniel to start over Drew Brees.

Luke McCown to start over David Garrard.

Kerry Collins to start over Vince Young.

Mike Kafka to start over Kevin Kolb.

[Aso]

Graham Harrell to start over Aaron Rodgers!!!!!11 He's such a fuckin bum!!!! It's his fault they didn't beat the Cardinals! If Harrell was in they would've won the Superbowl!!!!!!!

[Goober]

Tim Tebow will start at QB at some point this season for the Broncos, and he'll be the teams opening day starter in 2011. Fact. Super Bowl MVP in 2012. Fact.

I'd like to see Jimmy Clausen start this year, just to see him suck it up.

[G-men]

Not really. The only ones who are stretches are Chase Daniel and Luke McCown. Everyone else I listed can be great if given a chance

David Carr was given a chance for five years. he was far from great.

[Aso]

Graham Harrell > Aaron Rodgers

[St. Francisco]

I'm going to murder you in your sleep.

[Fappin Raptor]

How was David Carr given a chance? He played on horrible teams with no running game (Dominick Davis' 1000 yard season was a fluke), below average o-lines and only one real offensive weapon (Gaffney never reached his potential with the Texans).
Not to mention he was in a division with the Colts and Titans.

Carr did what he could with what he had.

I knew he was in trouble once I saw Houston play their first game against Dallas on primetime in 2002. I've never seen a team that looked so close to being an NCAA team in the NFL. Expansion or not, the management never gave him what he needed to succeed.

And look at Matt Schaub. He has BETTER teams than Carr ever had and he still can't take them anywhere, and you don't see him getting the boot. :guns:

Would you say this about Joey Harrington as well? Same situation for Joey.