Dave sees Bill Simmons' top-32 QBs and raises him with his top-32 QBs (NFL)

[WalkMan]

Jason Campbell is too low...at least the top 20.

[dave]

Jason Campbell is too low...at least the top 20.

No bias there. :D

[nflman2033]

Perhaps. But I cant force him to trust the guy. I gotta go with what happened. If Marty didnt trust him who am I to question that caliber of coach who sees him practice every day.

or maybe Marty is a nutbag.

[mcstl25]

Jason Campbell is too low...at least the top 20.

I was thinking he was too high. Bottom 5 QB, IMO. He always had a decent team around him, but could never deliver. In 2007, when Campbell was injured for the last four games of the year, Todd freaking Collins stepped in to win four straight to lead the skins to the playoffs.

[dave]

I was thinking he was too high. Bottom 5 QB, IMO. He always had a decent team around him, but could never deliver. In 2007, when Campbell was injured for the last four games of the year, Todd freaking Collins stepped in to win four straight to lead the skins to the playoffs.

The Skins have never had the O-Line or receivers.
IMO, Campbell got way too much blame for a team that was fundamentally flawed.
When your O-Line sucks, you're in big trouble as a young kid.
Campbell's situation was only slightly better than David Carr's and he came out in one piece.

I honestly believe he surprises a lot of people this year.

[BigBucs]

Sanchez and Stafford looked fuckin Awesome this week.

/sarcasm

[NAHSTE]

Stafford was 11 for 15 before he got hurt though.

[dave]

I'm not judging either guy on one game.
I didn't get to watch much of the Jets' game tonight because I was at work, but what I saw, Sanchez looked intimidated and indecisive.
I also didn't like the interaction between him and Schottenheimer at the end of the game.

[BigBucs]

Stafford was 11 for 15 before he got hurt though.

For a whopping 83 yards and 0 TD passes.

[NAHSTE]

For a whopping 83 yards and 0 TD passes.

In one half. Meanwhile Sanchez posted 60 in a whole game.

[Woy]

I'm not judging either guy on one game.
I didn't get to watch much of the Jets' game tonight because I was at work, but what I saw, Sanchez looked intimidated and indecisive.
I also didn't like the interaction between him and Schottenheimer at the end of the game.

I'm still dying over here that you have Sanchez over VY. And that you predicted Oakland to win the AFC West.

[Primetime]

Soulja Woy.....Tell 'Em

[dave]

I'm still dying over here that you have Sanchez over VY. And that you predicted Oakland to win the AFC West.

Week 1 doesn't forecast an entire season.

[Primetime]

Can't believe you're still not convinced VY is better than Sanchez. Even more unbelievable that you think Oakland will be anything but a 5 win team this year.

[Woy]

Week 1 doesn't forecast an entire season.

Someone hasn't watched VY since week 8 of last season. He's miles better than Sanchez.

And someone also didn't watch the TEN/OAK game. That Raiders offensive line could be the worst in the league. Jason Campbell might die this season with the lack of protection he'll get.