no more...

[Derrville]

I dislike Rodgers and still do but he put on a clinic last night... dammmmmn.

Man deserves his props.

[citizenerased]

LOL at Nuk

Nuk hasn't posted in 2 months.

Your still talking about him.

You lose. Again.

[steeljake]

keeping Rodgers out of top 5 QB lists..


fucking nuk

hmm... top 5?

1/2 manning/brady (either or)
3. brees
4. rivers
5. ben

who does rodgers bump?

[strahanfan92]

Rivers.

[steeljake]

Rivers.

that would be an interesting debate... and i think i might agree with you. however, if you bump rivers does that make rodgers 4 and ben 5?

[Woy]

that would be an interesting debate... and i think i might agree with you. however, if you bump rivers does that make rodgers 4 and ben 5?

Depends on how the rest of their seasons play out. If Rodgers goes on and wins the SB, it's a no-brainer IMO, especially with the amount of injuries that Packers team has. If the Steelers go and win it (*shudders*), then Ben obviously retains the spot.

[Liquidrob]

Always route for Rodgers

Love that when he does well that there are 'packer fans' that get sad and wish it was still Favre as the QB

[shag773]

As I see it:

1. Brady
2. P.Manning
3. Brees
4. Ben
5. Rodgers

[shag773]

Depends on how the rest of their seasons play out. If Rodgers goes on and wins the SB, it's a no-brainer IMO, especially with the amount of injuries that Packers team has. If the Steelers go and win it (*shudders*), then Ben obviously retains the spot.

If Ben wins his 3rd SB, is it crazy to argue that he potentially leap frogs Brees and maybe Manning? Not saying I agree with it, just playing devil's advocate..

[Woy]

If Ben wins his 3rd SB, is it crazy to argue that he potentially leap frogs Brees and maybe Manning? Not saying I agree with it, just playing devil's advocate..

I don't think he jumps Manning or Brady cause they're on a completely different tier IMO, but I could see the argument for placing him third, ahead of Brees.

[bucky]

Always route for Rodgers

Love that when he does well that there are 'packer fans' that get sad and wish it was still Favre as the QB

Those aren't Packer Fans, those are Favre Fans.

[bucky]

Whether the TEAM wins or not, if Rodgers keeps playing the way he has been, then I would put him above both Rivers, Ben and Brees. So far in his career, if the TEAM loses, it's not because of Rodgers.

IF he keeps playing at the level he has been, THEN I put him 3rd, behind Manning and Brady.

So, I'll wait for now, and see how things play out.

[Colonel Angus]

Can't put Rodgers ahead of any of those QB's with rings until he gets one in a few weeks.

[Warner2BruceTD]

This site is the largest group of fair weather m'fers I've ever seen. A guy wins, he's a god. If he loses, he's a bum. If Rogers has a bad game next week, it'll be Rlolgers from most of you dopes, and he will be turned on like Andre ripping off Hogan's gold cross to set up WrestleMania III.

All of you suck.

[Liquidrob]

Those aren't Packer Fans, those are Favre Fans.

thats why 'packer fans' was in quotes