Great story about Ted Thompson and Aaron Rodgers

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Colonel Angus
    No longer a noob
    • Jan 2010
    • 1935

    Great story about Ted Thompson and Aaron Rodgers

    I really liked this article.


    Dallas, Texas - Milwaukee native Gil Brandt, the former vice president of player personnel for the Dallas Cowboys, retains his formidable storytelling skills.

    Brandt, who worked for the Cowboys from 1960 to ’88, shared some anecdotes about two of the most prominent members of the Packers’ organization, general manager Ted Thompson and quarterback Aaron Rodgers.

    Brandt, 77, is a graduate of the University of Wisconsin. He now provides content for NFL.com and is a commentator on Sirius NFL Radio.

    Brandt said he has known Thompson since he was a player at SMU.

    “He hired Mike McCarthy,” Brandt said during an interview at the Super Bowl XLV Media Center. “I told Ted, ‘I really thought you could have made a better choice than that.’ I really wasn’t sold on McCarthy. I went to camp up there for three days. About the second day I was there and I told him, ‘You know what? You made the right choice.’ ”

    Brandt, said Thompson has been doing a “phenomenal” job with the Packers.

    “Ted is not the kind of guy who is going to sit down at the bar and talk to a lot of people and tell them a lot of stories,” Brandt said. “But you look at this team. There have only been only three other teams since 2000 that have had 15 or more guys on injured reserve. The other three teams won six or fewer games. They have done a fantastic job.”

    Brandt praised Thompson for having the “fortitude” to “get rid of” Brett Favre and “hang his hat on” Rodgers.

    Brandt recalls the time of the 2005 draft, when Rodgers dropped on the board and was chosen 24th by Green Bay.

    Brandt said he witnessed the workouts by Alex Smith and Rodgers, which took place a day apart of one another before the ’05 draft. Brandt said Smith worked out on a Wednesday and Rodgers on Thursday.

    “In the workout, if you asked who is the best to come in and play right now, Smith looked more ready to play right now,” Brandt said.

    Both Smith and Rodgers were brought to the draft in New York.

    “On Friday afternoon, Greg Aiello called me and said, ‘Look it, Rodgers is falling. We that know through 20 nobody is going to take him.’ So I said I’d talk to him. That night, I took him out to dinner at Carmine’s. Before I took him out to dinner, I made a call to (Packers director of college scouting) John Dorsey in Green Bay. I said, ‘John, you are going to get Rodgers. Be ready.’ He said, ‘We’re ready. If he’s there, we are going to take him.’ ”

    After dinner, Brandt told Rodgers he was going to fall in the draft.

    “I said if you don’t want to come, because he was there by himself, and he said no I’ll face it. The bad thing that happened was that ESPN put the cameras on him, put the cameras on him, put the cameras on him. It’s tough for a guy to react to that.”

    Brandt said scouts don’t know how hard a player will work to become better after he is drafted.

    “He not only made himself better on the field because of his work ethic, but the guy had a great rapport with all these young players,” Brandt said about Rodgers.
  • strahanfan92
    Meat
    • Aug 2009
    • 5456

    #2
    Weren't all you Packers fans hating Ted Thompson a couple months ago?

    Comment

    • Primetime
      Thank You Prince
      • Nov 2008
      • 17526

      #3
      Originally posted by strahanfan92
      Weren't all you Packers fans hating Ted Thompson a couple months ago?
      Generally, people who absolutely loved Brett Favre were very emotional when Ted ran him out of town. People were upset when he didn't get Moss for super cheap and they were also a little upset when he didn't make a move to get a RB when he had a chance early in the season. Had we not made the playoffs, a lot of blame would have gone on TT. Basically, some GB people just don't trust him 100%, nor McCarthy. Because of that, the smallest things tilt fans opinions on them.

      Comment

      • Colonel Angus
        No longer a noob
        • Jan 2010
        • 1935

        #4
        I was kinda irked by his decision not to trade for Lynch, but I've always backed TT. I mean look at his drafts..

        Comment

        • Spidey
          Junior Member
          • Feb 2009
          • 923

          #5
          Generally I have backed TT. The only two time I recall being upset with him was the past couple years where our OL was abysmal. They still have work to do there but that situation has turned around. I was fuming about not getting Lynch this season as well. It all worked out. I hate, and probably always will, that we don't have a good running game. I think its the lineman/grind it out mentality I was brought up on. I can't let go of it.

          Not sure if Lynch would have made difference or not but I thought he would have. Starks has filled in decently though.

          Other than that, I haven't had many issues with TT. And I was definitely one that stood firmly behind him when trading Favre and moving on to Rodgers.

          Comment

          • MrBill
            Billy Brewer Sucks Penis
            • Feb 2009
            • 0

            #6
            I've never been a big fan of Thompson but if the Packers can win the Super Bowl this Sunday, he will have earned a lot of latitude in the future from me. Let's not forget that the Packers barely squeaked into the playoffs and that if they had not made it this year, folks would have been calling for Thompson and McCarthy's heads for reasons like the horrible state of the OL and poor play calling.

            There's no need to rehash the poor handling of the Favre situation. I'll always believe that bringing back Favre for one more year would have carried the Packers back to the playoffs instead of going 6-10 and Rodgers would have lived with it.

            Comment

            • Senser81
              VSN Poster of the Year
              • Feb 2009
              • 12804

              #7
              Originally posted by MrBill
              I've never been a big fan of Thompson but if the Packers can win the Super Bowl this Sunday, he will have earned a lot of latitude in the future from me. Let's not forget that the Packers barely squeaked into the playoffs and that if they had not made it this year, folks would have been calling for Thompson and McCarthy's heads for reasons like the horrible state of the OL and poor play calling.
              LOL at people calling for Thompson's head. If anything, the Packers continued success despite injuries showcased Thompson's skill at acquiring players who could be plugged in immediately. One of the greatest GM-ing jobs in history.

              Comment

              • MrBill
                Billy Brewer Sucks Penis
                • Feb 2009
                • 0

                #8
                Originally posted by Senser81
                LOL at people calling for Thompson's head. If anything, the Packers continued success despite injuries showcased Thompson's skill at acquiring players who could be plugged in immediately. One of the greatest GM-ing jobs in history.
                The league doesn't give out hardware for being a great GM and if the Packers had not made the playoffs this year lots of people would have pointed to the Packers barely being above .500 in the past 3 years with no playoff wins as being TT's fault.

                Comment

                • shag773
                  Senior Member
                  • Jul 2009
                  • 2721

                  #9
                  Originally posted by MrBill
                  The league doesn't give out hardware for being a great GM and if the Packers had not made the playoffs this year lots of people would have pointed to the Packers barely being above .500 in the past 3 years with no playoff wins as being TT's fault.
                  Yes they do, it's called the NFL Executive of the Year. They give out a trophy and everything. :ooops:

                  Comment

                  • packersfan4eva
                    Ryan Luxem
                    • Dec 2008
                    • 9052

                    #10
                    The only time I said, "What the fuck, Ted Thompson," was when we drafted Jordy Nelson. I did not think it was a good move at the time. Now? I don't really know. He's been good sometimes and bad other times.

                    Originally posted by Miggyfan99
                    I would get fucked in the ass for WS tickets too... only if Miguel was playing though

                    Comment

                    • MrBill
                      Billy Brewer Sucks Penis
                      • Feb 2009
                      • 0

                      #11
                      Originally posted by shag773
                      Yes they do, it's called the NFL Executive of the Year. They give out a trophy and everything. :ooops:
                      I doubt many people can tell you a single GM that has won that award in the past few years. On the other hand, just about anybody can tell you the winners of the past 5 Super Bowls.

                      Comment

                      • Senser81
                        VSN Poster of the Year
                        • Feb 2009
                        • 12804

                        #12
                        Originally posted by MrBill
                        The league doesn't give out hardware for being a great GM and if the Packers had not made the playoffs this year lots of people would have pointed to the Packers barely being above .500 in the past 3 years with no playoff wins as being TT's fault.
                        Thats one of the most retarded things I've ever heard. First, its untrue. After all the injuries GB had, if they had gone 10-6 and still missed the playoffs, I doubt anyone would have been calling for Thompson's head. Again, the Packers depth and overall talent were easily seen this year.

                        Second, your hypothetical is ridiculous. The Packers are in the Super Bowl, and you are saying "what if they missed the playoffs this year? Then people would be saying they missed the playoffs this year...made the playoffs last year...and went 6-10 the year before."

                        How about this...what if the Patriots didn't win a game this year? Then people would have pointed to the Patriots going 0-16 this year.

                        Comment

                        • Rayman
                          Spic 'n Spanish
                          • Feb 2009
                          • 4626

                          #13
                          Originally posted by shag773
                          Yes they do, it's called the NFL Executive of the Year. They give out a trophy and everything. :ooops:
                          Not only that, Thompson himself won it in 2008.


                          Originally posted by MrBill
                          I doubt many people can tell you a single GM that has won that award in the past few years. On the other hand, just about anybody can tell you the winners of the past 5 Super Bowls.
                          I'm sure this guy hasn't won any of late.



                          So, yeah, count your blessings.



                          Comment

                          • Blade
                            Walking SAM site
                            • Feb 2009
                            • 3739

                            #14
                            The writing quality of that article is maybe Junior year HS level. The research isn't anything new and the build up in the first paragraph was totaly screwed up by the 4th paragraph when the article became a underwhelming piece filled with 2-3 sentence paragraphs.

                            Comment

                            • MrBill
                              Billy Brewer Sucks Penis
                              • Feb 2009
                              • 0

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Senser81
                              Thats one of the most retarded things I've ever heard. First, its untrue. After all the injuries GB had, if they had gone 10-6 and still missed the playoffs, I doubt anyone would have been calling for Thompson's head. Again, the Packers depth and overall talent were easily seen this year.
                              I think that is a bit overstated considering the vast catalog of retarded statements available on VSN. For the Packers to have missed the playoffs without help from other teams, they would have had to have lost only one of their final games and would have finished 9-7. Had they finished 9-7 and missed the playoffs you would be delusional not to think Packers fans would be calling for someones head with 3 years of no playoff wins.

                              Originally posted by Senser81
                              Second, your hypothetical is ridiculous. The Packers are in the Super Bowl, and you are saying "what if they missed the playoffs this year? Then people would be saying they missed the playoffs this year...made the playoffs last year...and went 6-10 the year before."
                              It's not that ridiculous at all. As recently as Christmas, the Packers were 8-6 and outside the playoffs looking in. They had to win their final 2 games and get some help to make it in. Had they not made it, Packers fans would not have given a damn about anything other than a 26-22 record over the past 3 years with no playoff wins.

                              It's a short walk from the penthouse to the outhouse and had the outcome of either of the last two games of the season been different, Thompson would have likely had to fire McCarthy at the very least to save his own skin.

                              Originally posted by Senser81
                              How about this...what if the Patriots didn't win a game this year? Then people would have pointed to the Patriots going 0-16 this year.
                              A hypothetical involving the outcome of one game is plausible. For an entire season is ridonkulous.

                              Thankfully for all Packers fans they are in the Super Bowl and the entire fan base can join together move forward into the new era with a win on Sunday. Had they missed the playoffs or gotten beat by the Eagles in the wild card round that would not be the case.

                              Comment

                              Working...