Top 10 Super Bowl Quarterbacks

[packersfan4eva]

I'm a Bills fan. What can I say?

Besides you weren't born when they went to all those Super Bowls so your opinion is invalid

I know.

Props to him for getting to four straight, but he should have won at least ONE. Even in a best-case scenario, he's 1-3 in the game. And 2 touchdowns, 7 picks, and an injury say otherwise.

[strahanfan92]

Namath is the most overrated QB of all time. He didn't even account for a TD in SB III.

Thank you. I watched this game last week and he did absolutely nothing. He almost threw a pick 6 near the end of the half to get the Colts back in the game, but the Colt DB dropped it.

[ram29jackson]

Thank you. I watched this game last week and he did absolutely nothing. He almost threw a pick 6 near the end of the half to get the Colts back in the game, but the Colt DB dropped it.

I think that shows how much tougher and better both leagues were at the time.

to say he did nothing is kind of ridiculous from an arm chair stand point.

You do realize ,both him and the Jets had an entire league on their shoulders.
Waiting, watching,wanting,needing, hoping-

Don Maynard even said- he was less a womanizer than thought of and more of a QB than people realized.

how great is he ? I dont know ?

but he lead one of the more important victories in football history that helped shape the league.

[G-men]

Kurt Warner IMO is the best Super Bowl QB of all time. this should be about how they performed in the Super Bowl and not the team as a whole. Warner put his team in the position to win every SB he was a part of, and his only real blunder in any of those games was the pick six to James Harrison. and IIRC he has the three highest single game passing totals in SB history.

[strahanfan92]

Kurt Warner IMO is the best Super Bowl QB of all time. this should be about how they performed in the Super Bowl and not the team as a whole. Warner put his team in the position to win every SB he was a part of, and his only real blunder in any of those games was the pick six to James Harrison. and IIRC he has the three highest single game passing totals in SB history.

[Tengo Juego]

This. Rodgers could win 5 straight Super Bowls and I would still put Montana at the #1 spot.

Did you read what you said? If Rodgers wins 5 straight, fuck yes he takes that spot. Is you crazy?!

[Champ]

Simms completed 25 of 28 passes and threw 3 TDs in his only Super Bowl. Not even including that 2 of his incompletions were drops.

Eli was the only quarterback in the super bowl when his team needed a touchdown to win in the last 2 minutes to complete a TD. He defeated arguably the best team of all time. A team in modern day free agency era that almost accomplished 19-0.

[FirstTimer]

Simms completed 25 of 28 passes and threw 3 TDs in his only Super Bowl. Not even including that 2 of his incompletions were drops.

Eli was the only quarterback in the super bowl when his team needed a touchdown to win in the last 2 minutes to complete a TD. He defeated arguably the best team of all time. A team in modern day free agency era that almost accomplished 19-0.

Wrong.

The Steelers were down 3 when Big Ben hit Holmes with the game winning TD. Thus a TD was needed to win the game.

[Champ]

Wrong.

The Steelers were down 3 when Big Ben hit Holmes with the game winning FG. Thus a TD was needed to win the game.

Then I must have misread the article. I think it may have been a 2008 article.

[G-men]

Wrong.

The Steelers were down 3 when Big Ben hit Holmes with the game winning FG. Thus a TD was needed to win the game.

true but didnt they get the ball with about 2:30 to go?

[strahanfan92]

Yeah but they still scored with 40 seconds left..?

[G-men]

Yeah but they still scored with 40 seconds left..?

so did the Giants...not sure what youre getting at with that.

[FirstTimer]

true but didnt they get the ball with about 2:30 to go?

So did the Giants.

[PEYMAN18]

No.

Bradshaw only had one really stellar SB performance. The rest he threw the ball less than 20 times or threw more INT's than TD's. I'd rank Bradshaw in the Top 10 all time because of the volume of SB wins but he's not impressive enough to warrant #2 SB QB of all time.

Namath is the most overrated QB of all time. He didn't even account for a TD in SB III.

Bradshaw - 4-0, 112.8 QB Rating, 9 Touchdowns, 4 Int's, 932 Yards on 49 Completions
Brady - 3-1, 95.1 QB Rating 7 Touchdowns, 1 Int, 1001 Yards on 100 Completions

?

Bradshaw only threw more INT's then TD's in the Superbowl once.

[steeljake]

Simms completed 25 of 28 passes and threw 3 TDs in his only Super Bowl. Not even including that 2 of his incompletions were drops.

Eli was the only quarterback in the super bowl when his team needed a touchdown to win in the last 2 minutes to complete a TD. He defeated arguably the best team of all time. A team in modern day free agency era that almost accomplished 19-0.

didn't joe montana break the bungles heart with a last second td in like '88?