New York Jets - Starting Defense 2011

[Shayn•Da•Pain]

You adjusted your ratings already? Some of your ratings still seem rather inflated.

Particularly Harris, I mean let's be real. Giving him a solid A is like trying to sell me that Harris is on elite level. I just don't think he's there. A- maybe, B+ more acceptable.

Which leads me to Bart Scott and Calvin Pace. Harris should have a higher rating, agreed, so maybe downgrade them to B- each.

I'd bump Lowery to a B- and drop DeVito to a C.

Just my thoughts, take it with a grain of salt, but that's just how I see it.

[Scikotic]

You adjusted your ratings already? Some of your ratings still seem rather inflated.

Particularly Harris, I mean let's be real. Giving him a solid A is like trying to sell me that Harris is on elite level. I just don't think he's there. A- maybe, B+ more acceptable.

Which leads me to Bart Scott and Calvin Pace. Harris should have a higher rating, agreed, so maybe downgrade them to B- each.

I'd bump Lowery to a B- and drop DeVito to a C.

Just my thoughts, take it with a grain of salt, but that's just how I see it.

Looking back, I thought I was generous on a few guys.

David Harris is a player you just wont understand unless you follow him every game of the year. Perhaps he could fall into the A- range depending on how you value his skill sets, but I think he is one of the better MLBs in the game today.

Scott's floor should be at a B. Pace, maybe a B-. Lowery could be bumped, but he misses assignments too often. His ballhawk ability should not overshadow his inability to play consistently at FS. Devito at a C, maybe a year or 2 ago? The Jets don't dominate against the run for nothing. He's a very big reason...

It's all subjective.