Donovan McNabb says he is a HOF'er. Agree?

[NAHSTE]

Dave once said he was, so there's your answer. Of course not.

[Warner2BruceTD]

Expert analysis on The Worldwide Leader today....(this is the actual discourse that took place)

Guys, is Donovan McNabb a hall of famer?

I don't know, when it comes to this, i'm staying out of it! (chuckled, shook his head)

I'll leave that up to the voters!

Alright, the panel has spoken. Thanks for watching NFL Live.

[Guest]

Kelly: 35,467 yards, 237 TD passes, 84.4 QB rating, four consecutive SB appearances (160 games)

McNabb: 37,099 yards, 234 TD passes, 85.5 QB rating, one SB appearance (167 games)

McNabb's Eagles only made it to the Super Bowl once, while Kelly's made it four straight times. Both didn't win. Their stats are similar, but McNabb's numbers came from a pass-happy offense in a time that favored the passer. I think McNabb could get in with time, but it isn't going to be anything immediate.

Bottom line: McNabb is saying this to keep his name in the mind of everyone, just like the RGIII and Redskins comments. He still wants to play and doesn't want people to forget it.

[Warner2BruceTD]

Kelly put up similar numbers to the other top QB's in his era.

McNabb played half of his career in conditions where the defense was not allowed to breath on WR's, and had numbers well below the elite QB's of his era (particularly completion percentage and QB Rating).

McNabb is a geek for making that stat comparison.

FWIW, i'm not completely sold on Kelly being in the HOF. But i'm not offended by it. I'd be offended by McNabb. I never thought for him as a hall of famer. He fails the eye test and the hard stat test.

[killgod]