NFL players vote on most overrated

[Senser81]

LOL at Tebow being the most overrated player...he doesn't even start, so how highly could he possibly be rated?

[BigBucs]

Nobody rates Tebow as a great player so him winning this poll is certainly a result of players being jealous. The correct answer would be a Cowboy. Them bums are mediocre year in and year out yet they are treated as if they are superbowl contenders season after season.

[Senser81]

Where was Josh Freeman on this list?

[FirstTimer]

I get all that.. But all things being equal I'd rather see him trotting onto the field than I Caleb Hanie.

At least he presents some semblance of hope that things are going to turn around. I would have bet if he is the Jags backup last week instead of Chad Henne they hold onto that lead and win the game.

I just don't see a ton of second string QBs around the league have proven themselves to be demonstrably better quarterbacks than Tebow. Better throwers maybe, but not better QBs.

Caleb Hanie shouldn't be on an NFL roster either. Just sayin'

[Glenbino]

Caleb Hanie shouldn't be on an NFL roster either. Just sayin'

Who takes his place though? People act like there are a ton of NFL caliber QBs just floating around out there looking for work when it's certainly not the case.

[ram29jackson]

I think an argument could be made to state that Tebow isn't good enough to be on any NFL roster.

you're wrong,.. he can play more than one position. He is over rated as a QB.

your logic could be used for 15 of the back up QB's

[FirstTimer]

Who takes his place though? People act like there are a ton of NFL caliber QBs just floating around out there looking for work when it's certainly not the case.

Nathan Enderle.

[shag773]

I would think michael vick would top a list like this. The last two preseasons he's been the focus of a team that was picked to win a super bowl, and has failed to live up to the hype. Its not 100% his fault, but we all know QBs get too much credit when the team does well and too much blame when it doesn't.

As far as Tebow, I think the good press he gets for being a great team leader and a character guy is leveled off by the questions of accuracy and running a coventional nfl offense. He's not overrated.

[Houston]

Shocking...

This poll reeks of jealousy.

I think it's part jealousy and part them being dumb.

[BigBucs]

Where was Josh Freeman on this list?

List reads "Overrated" not underrated.