What dysfunction are the Cowboys planning?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ThomasTomasz
    • Jan 2025

    What dysfunction are the Cowboys planning?

    Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones and coach Jason Garrett are considering resolving their disagreement over who should be the team's offensive playcaller with a compromise: They're discussing hiring former Detroit Lions offensive coordinator Scott Linehan, according to league sources.

    One source who expects Linehan to be hired speculated he could have the title of passing game coordinator while also being designated the Cowboys' playcaller. If so, Linehan would become the third different offensive playcaller in three seasons in Dallas, following Garrett and current offensive coordinator Bill Callahan.

    In a setup one source described as "strange" and "dysfunctional," Garrett ceded play-calling authority to Callahan a year ago in what appeared to be a change mandated by Jones, who is also the team's general manager.

    At the Senior Bowl this week in Mobile, Ala., Jones said Callahan and defensive coordinator Monte Kiffin would both return following a third consecutive 8-8 season in which the Cowboys failed in Week 17 to win the NFC East. While Garrett also said he expected both coordinators to return, he specifically left open the possibility that roles could be changed.

    Until last season, Garrett had been the only playcaller for quarterback Tony Romo since Garrett -- a former Cowboys backup quarterback -- returned to the organization in 2007 under coach Wade Phillips.

    According to a source, Garrett attempted to hire Norv Turner as his offensive coordinator and playcaller a year ago when Jones expressed dissatisfaction with Garrett's performance in the role. But Jones decided against the move late in the process, apparently believing Turner's offensive philosophy was too similar to that of Garrett. Jones preferred to empower Callahan at the expense of his head coach.

    But during the Cowboys' bye week this season, Garrett moved to ensure he would be directly involved in the play-calling process. He reconfigured game-day coaching responsibilities so that Callahan called the play to Garrett on the sideline -- rather than quarterbacks coach Wade Wilson -- and then Garrett relayed the call to Romo on the field.

    Among the reasons Garrett imposed himself in the communication process was because he wanted to regain a measure of control and felt he didn't have a significant role on game day without being directly involved, according to sources. Garrett had always communicated with Romo and wanted to interact with his quarterback throughout games, as Sean Payton does with Drew Brees in New Orleans and Mike McCarthy with Aaron Rodgers in Green Bay.

    Linehan was fired along with coach Jim Schwartz following a 7-9 season in Detroit. He was the offensive coordinator for the past five seasons, designing game plans and calling the plays for quarterback Matthew Stafford, wide receiver Calvin Johnson and running back Reggie Bush.

    The Lions ranked sixth in total offense last season, third overall in 2012, fifth in '11, 17th in '10 and 26th in '09.

    Linehan was previously coach of the St. Louis Rams, where he went 11-25 from 2006 to '08 before being fired. Linehan has been offensive coordinator with the Miami Dolphins and the Minnesota Vikings.

    Garrett and Linehan have worked together previously. When Linehan was offensive coordinator of the Dolphins, he hired Garrett as his quarterbacks coach, at least partly on the recommendation of three-time Super Bowl-winning quarterback Troy Aikman. Linehan later described Garrett as one of the smartest people he's ever met.

    A college quarterback at Idaho, Linehan went to training camp with the Cowboys in 1987 as an undrafted rookie before being released.

    Linehan and Cowboys executives did not immediately return phone messages for comment.

    http://espn.go.com/dallas/nfl/story/...han-playcaller
    Dumb idea, and I have no idea why Jones wants to continue keeping Garrett. If they do this, it's going to be like the Browns where they are going to scrape the bottom for coaching candidates when they decide to move on from Garrett.

    The Redskins did this at the end of the Zorn era with hiring Sherman Lewis. It didn't end up well and I don't think this ends up well.
  • spursup
    Noob
    • Dec 2013
    • 505

    #2
    Everything the Cowboys have done since around 2005 has been a complete farce. I have a feeling that won't change now.

    Comment

    • KINGOFOOTBALL
      Junior Member
      • Feb 2009
      • 10343

      #3
      Utter retardedness. Love that neither moron knew how to call run plays.
      Garrett is a total football dumbass and a coward. As Bradshaw said on FOX he's a yes man who should have never been a head coach.
      Cowboys will continue to have the talent to draw ratings and sales but god awful coaching so JJ can feel in charge. It's the secret recipe Jones has found. That whole "really wants to win more than. Anyone" Schtick is completely transparent. $$$$ , drama and attention are the new super bowls for Jerry.
      Best reason to have a license.

      Comment

      • spursup
        Noob
        • Dec 2013
        • 505

        #4
        Originally posted by KINGOFOOTBALL
        Utter retardedness. Love that neither moron knew how to call run plays.
        Garrett is a total football dumbass and a coward. As Bradshaw said on FOX he's a yes man who should have never been a head coach.
        Cowboys will continue to have the talent to draw ratings and sales but god awful coaching so JJ can feel in charge. It's the secret recipe Jones has found. That whole "really wants to win more than. Anyone" Schtick is completely transparent. $$$$ , drama and attention are the new super bowls for Jerry.
        They should have got rid of Garrett after that interim season when Phillips got fired. It's decisions like keeping him that are the reason the Cowboys haven't won a ring since Jones bought the team.

        Comment

        • Primetime
          Thank You Prince
          • Nov 2008
          • 17526

          #5
          Originally posted by baseballchampion
          They should have got rid of Garrett after that interim season when Phillips got fired. It's decisions like keeping him that are the reason the Cowboys haven't won a ring since Jones bought the team.
          Uh, they've won three since he bought the team.

          Comment

          • spursup
            Noob
            • Dec 2013
            • 505

            #6
            Originally posted by Primetime
            Uh, they've won three since he bought the team.
            Got my dates wrong. Thanks for clearing that up.

            Still though, they haven't won in a while because of Jones. He can't seem to bring in players or coaches that can win.

            Comment

            • NAHSTE
              Probably owns the site
              • Feb 2009
              • 22233

              #7
              Dual coordinators NEVER works out. Absolutely doomed to fail from the beginning.

              Comment

              • KINGOFOOTBALL
                Junior Member
                • Feb 2009
                • 10343

                #8
                Originally posted by baseballchampion
                They should have got rid of Garrett after that interim season when Phillips got fired. It's decisions like keeping him that are the reason the Cowboys haven't won a ring since Jones bought the team.
                Hiring Jimmy Johnson was the best mistake he ever made. 3 SB and the last great Dynasty out of it. But 20 plus years of trying to win things "his way" and failing miserably haven't taught him a thing. Parcells was a smart and successful hire but its clear now it was only for a new stadium deal not for the care of winning. Jerry wants to win not only with a pupper head coach but "his" home grown puppet head coach.
                Best reason to have a license.

                Comment

                • PP
                  Senior Member
                  • Feb 2010
                  • 4994

                  #9
                  More like why sign the kicker to that extension?

                  Comment

                  • ThomasTomasz
                    • Jan 2025

                    #10
                    Originally posted by NAHSTE
                    Dual coordinators NEVER works out. Absolutely doomed to fail from the beginning.
                    When the Redskins tried it, I wondered why we didn't just go ahead and fire Zorn in the middle of the season. Turns out that is exactly what Snyder wanted to do, but Shanahan told him he wouldn't take the job under those circumstances. So he hired another guy to call plays for half a year. Dumb.

                    Comment

                    • ThomasTomasz
                      • Jan 2025

                      #11
                      So Linehan is official as the passing game coordinator and the offensive play caller. Callahan does not call plays, but is still offensive line coach and offensive coordinator.

                      Rod Marinelli was promoted to defensive coordinator, and I guess Monte Kiffin is still on staff but was demoted to an advisory position.

                      I can get with the Marinelli promotion. Still confused over the Linehan one, it's not going to work. Even worse, Linehan gave Garrett his first job as an NFL coach, so who knows what the hell is going to be called with three men involved with the offense.

                      Comment

                      • KINGOFOOTBALL
                        Junior Member
                        • Feb 2009
                        • 10343

                        #12
                        Originally posted by ThomasTomasz
                        So Linehan is official as the passing game coordinator and the offensive play caller. Callahan does not call plays, but is still offensive line coach and offensive coordinator.

                        Rod Marinelli was promoted to defensive coordinator, and I guess Monte Kiffin is still on staff but was demoted to an advisory position.

                        I can get with the Marinelli promotion. Still confused over the Linehan one, it's not going to work. Even worse, Linehan gave Garrett his first job as an NFL coach, so who knows what the hell is going to be called with three men involved with the offense.
                        My guess.... a pass play.
                        Best reason to have a license.

                        Comment

                        • steeljake
                          6 rings...
                          • Oct 2008
                          • 8752

                          #13
                          The definition of insanity is repeatedly doing the same thing and expecting different results.


                          23:33 OnlyOneBeerLeft: jake nobody listens to you aint you supposed to die from cancer or somethin soon?

                          Comment

                          • MrBill
                            Billy Brewer Sucks Penis
                            • Feb 2009
                            • 0

                            #14
                            Originally posted by steeljake
                            The definition of insanity is repeatedly doing the same thing and expecting different results.
                            True. Where the hell have you been man? Haven't seen you around here in ages.

                            Comment

                            • steeljake
                              6 rings...
                              • Oct 2008
                              • 8752

                              #15
                              Originally posted by MrBill
                              True. Where the hell have you been man? Haven't seen you around here in ages.
                              I went outside...


                              23:33 OnlyOneBeerLeft: jake nobody listens to you aint you supposed to die from cancer or somethin soon?

                              Comment

                              Working...