Offensive RoY so far

[July 4 1776]

easy bro, let him play out the season. ben when undefeated his rookie year in the regular season. he had the same advantage that ryan has with a beastly running game, but they arent in the same league just yet.

I disagree, Ben didnt step into a 3-13 team with a rookie coach. He stepped into a super bowl caliber team with Bill Cowher as coach and Steel Curtain like defense. Not the same situation at all. But Ben is good, I like Matts start just a little better, but mainly because of the fact that he's not just managing games but actually winning some.

[Magnetic Spectrum]

yea,matt ryan will not win it unless the falcons g .500 on the whole season

[Saluki]

Matt Forte or Matt Ryan. Forte, though his rushing stats haven't always been top 5, is top 10 in yards from scrimmage behind 6 pro-bowl players and the bears offense runs through him.
Ryan has rejuvenated the Falcons franchise and has helped them become a contender instead of using this as a rebuilding season.

[Saluki]

Wonder if Ryans is the real deal though. Lets not forget the eerily similar rookie season of Rick Mirer

[j.hen]

If the refs would of made the right call and gave the Falcons the ball back with two minutes to go down 14-20, theres no doubt in my mind that Matt Ryan leads the Falcons down the field and scores to go up a point. After the final seconds of that Falcons/Bears game anything seems possible with Matt Ryan managing the game, down a score with minutes (or seconds) left.

I've seen throws every game that Ryan will make that look impossible (The first TD pass to Roddy White yesterday for example, look for it on NFL.com that was an impossible window Matt Ryan had but he made it look easy)

Matt Ryan should win this award, as well as ROTY.

[Magnetic Spectrum]

I not ready to crown anybody,i remember similar talks about Edwards who has disappeared,but Calvin Johnson has look very good.

[DSpydr84]

I not ready to crown anybody,i remember similar talks about Edwards who has disappeared,but Calvin Johnson has look very good.

The player must be a rookie to win rookie of the year.

[Leftwich]

Its open right now unlike before I'm not gonna make up my mind until at least 3/4 of the season is over.

[Magnetic Spectrum]

The player must be a rookie to win rookie of the year.

i know this............

I'm talking about Matt Ryan consistency,and comparing it to other young players consistency.

if i had to pick a rookie it would be Chis Johnson titans,Desean Jackson eagles,or Avery for the rams