Most Overrated and Underated Player

[Primetime]

Overrated: Mike Bibby, Luol Deng, Andrew Bynum, Raymond Felton, Andre Iguodola, Rashard Lewis
Underrated: Spencer Hawes, George Hill, Chuck Hayes

[A Tasty Burgerr]

Great list except I think everyone knows Luol Deng sucks by now ;)

For me underrated is Ramon Sessions, Ronnie Brewer, John Salmons, Louis Williams, and Marvin Williams off the top of my head.

overrated: Jose Calderon, Yi Jianlian, and Carlos Boozer basically because they're all terrible defenders.

[Primetime]

I find Felton overrated because D.J. Augustin is going to take his job soon. I don't know if it is just D.J. playing well or Raymond being overrated. We'll find out soon.

[corbin]

Overrated: Mike Bibby, Luol Deng, Andrew Bynum, Raymond Felton, Andre Iguodola, Rashard Lewis
Underrated: Spencer Hawes, George Hill, Chuck Hayes

I am glad you said George Hil, he is a solid player. I agree with Rashard, Iguodala, and Bibby being overrated.

[Lupe]

Overrated: Jermaine O'Neal - Carmelo Anthony - Elton Brand - Zach Randolph - Adam Morrison
Underrated: Joe Johnson - Caron Butler - Antawn Jamison - Antonio Mcdyess - Lamarcus Aldridge - Mike Miller - Marc Gasol - David West - David Lee - Trevor Ariza - Aaron Brooks - Leon Powe - Big Z - Kurt Thomas - Hakim Warrick - Danny Granger

[Maestro]

Overrated: Jermaine O'Neal - Carmelo Anthony - Elton Brand - Zach Randolph - Adam Morrison
Underrated: Joe Johnson - Caron Butler - Antawn Jamison - Antonio Mcdyess - Lamarcus Aldridge - Mike Miller - Marc Gasol - David West - David Lee - Trevor Ariza - Aaron Brooks - Leon Powe - Big Z - Kurt Thomas - Hakim Warrick - Danny Granger

Melo-Not overrated at all,he has had great seasons since he has been in the league.

Morrison-This was said before,"you have to be rated,to be overrated.

Johnson and Butler-Have proven themselves as great players.Maybe a few years ago,even as early as last year for Johnson,but now has shown that they are legitimate offensive threats.

Thomas-Is not that good at all,only a solid backup.

[Lupe]

you must not watch Kurt Thomas when he's on the floor. He's a decent mid-range shooter one of the most underated big man defenders in the league and is a great rebounder. He's very underated and by you saying that about him proves my point

[Point Blank]

Overrated: Elton Brand
Underrated: Joe Johnson

[Kuzzy Powers]

Great list except I think everyone knows Luol Deng sucks by now ;)

For me underrated is Ramon Sessions, Ronnie Brewer, John Salmons, Louis Williams, and Marvin Williams off the top of my head.

overrated: Jose Calderon, Yi Jianlian, and Carlos Boozer basically because they're all terrible defenders.

Jose Calderon? Sorry.. I thought that was pretty amusing. You ever watch NBATV or any American bball coverage? Jose gets no respect. No way dude is overrated.

[dboy_dc]

...Overrated As Hell

OJ Mayo

LMAO

Naw just bullshitting

[Gonzo]

Overrated: Jermaine O'Neal, Allen Iverson

Underrated: Danny Granger

[Maestro]

you must not watch Kurt Thomas when he's on the floor. He's a decent mid-range shooter one of the most underated big man defenders in the league and is a great rebounder. He's very underated and by you saying that about him proves my point

I dont think it proves the point at all.I never said that he was bad,he isnt that good of a defender,an average rebounder for a big man,but he can shoot the mid range well.

[Maestro]

Butler isnt THAT underrated anymore, hes not a superstar though. Hes not consistent enough. Like last night for example, he only scored 5 agaisnt Detroit. He took some horrible shots and really didnt looked like he belonged out there. Theres just too many games where he needs to be big, but ends up playing pretty bad.

He is consistent,i dont think he is a superstar,he is more of a complementary star.I dont think that he can carry a team,he needs another star to feed off of.

[A Tasty Burgerr]

Marcus Haislip is underrated

[Maestro]

Marcus Haislip is underrated

Please tell me you arnet talking about the former Milwaukee Bucks player.