Your Top 10 P4P MMA Fighters Thread

[Irish]

Fedor doesn't even belong in the top 5 after that loss.

Silva and GSP are interchangeable at 1 and 2. Then it is abit of a cluster. But Fedor isn't in the conversation for 3. He hasn't fought anyone good, and he still lost. He isn't even the best in his weight class. Wait...right now he's not even the best in his weight class in Strikeforce.

Let's just crown guys who lose and rate them the best. Please someone who actually watches these fights on PPV, do a top 10 list.

:fedor:

[Fox1994]

Too much of a cluster for me to try and do a complete top 10.

But...

1. Anderson - No one can touch him. No middleweights, probably no light-heavys.
2. GSP - Avenged his only loss. I don't think he'll have another one.
3. Fedor - He's the reason for the limited discussion of cross-promotion. Because if UFC is the premiere promotion, they should have the premiere heavyweights. Only two losses over a ten year career.
4. Shogun - I still think Lyoto is one of the best, and he beat him handily.

I wanna put Aldo up there, but idk enough about him... I wanna put Penn up there, but there's really not much of a good reason.

[Liquidrob]

1. Fedor Emelianenko
2. Georges St. Pierre
3. Anderson Silva
4. Shogun Rua
5. Gilbert Melendez
6. Jose Aldo
7. Jake Shields
8. BJ Penn
9. Eddie Alvarez
10. Frankie Edgar

Updated

1. Georges St. Pierre
2. Anderson Silva
3. Fedor Emelianenko
4. Shogun Rua
5. Gilbert Melendez
6. Jose Aldo
7. Jake Shields
8. BJ Penn
9. Eddie Alvarez
10. Marlon Sandro

Honorable Mentions: Nick Diaz, Frankie Edgar, Alistair Overeem, Jon Fitch, Lyoto Machida