Even More Ranking Madness (P4P)

[SHOGUN]

Neither Edgar or Evans would make my Top 10.

[Warner2BruceTD]

Neither Edgar or Evans would make my Top 10.

Alright, so two guys. I still don't see how horrendous and biased this list is.

I'd like to see you guys post yours.

And no Edgar? He owned Penn twice and never loses. You guys love Penn.

[Steel Mamba]

Biased is not having Edgar in your top 10.

[Liquidrob]

Listen fuckface, I didn't realise it was a p4p thread. And you know that.

Anyway, if you twats made a list, it wouldn't be drastically different than what they have. Quit your bitching.

:smile:

My list would be much different, I weigh skillset more than most, Steel Mamba does also, thats what P4P is for

I'll update mine

[SHOGUN]

Alright, so two guys. I still don't see how horrendous and biased this list is.

I'd like to see you guys post yours.

And no Edgar? He owned Penn twice and never loses. You guys love Penn.

Biased is not having Edgar in your top 10.

No. I just don't think beating BJ Penn twice is enough to make a case for Top 10 P4P, let alone Top 5. It may work for LW rankings, but not pound-for-pound.

1. St. Pierre
2. Emelianenko
3. Rua
4. Silva
5. Shields
6. Machida
7. Aldo
8. Aoki
9. Melendez
10. Fujii

[Liquidrob]

My number 10 spot is up for grabs, but I picked the HW with the baddest skillset around, it was Jake but he looked like hell back at 170, he might be the only fighter who's striking hasnt gotten worse over time, even Aoki has won fights by keeping it standing, I don't think Jake can do that

Mousasi is super skilled, just want to see it against Feijao or someone like that, not the last 2 guys he fought

Fitch can't finish...ever

Cain is the Mexican Fedor, couple more good fights and he will be right in the mix

1. Georges St. Pierre
2. Anderson Silva
3. Fedor Emelianenko
4. Shogun Rua
5. Gilbert Melendez
6. Jose Aldo
7. Eddie Alvarez
8. Marlon Sandro
9. Frankie Edgar
10. Alistair Overeem

Honorable Mentions: Jake Shields, Nick Diaz, Jon Fitch, Gegard Mousasi, Cain Velasquez

[Kuzzy Powers]

Jeez, its not that bad. You guys are to critical.

If you're not critical of Jon Fitch over Fedor I dont know what there is to be critical about.