Guardiola to Bayern Munich

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Rudi
    #CyCueto
    • Nov 2008
    • 9905

    Guardiola to Bayern Munich

    Guardiola has agreed a three-year deal at Bayern Munich that will begin this summer. It has been made official.
    He takes over in July.
  • 1ke
    D.I.L.L.I.G.A.F
    • Mar 2009
    • 6641

    #2
    This is crazy too. Says he wants to coach in England, then three days later says ok to Munchen. Good for him though. Top 5 club in the world. Everyone will be eager to see.......can he do it without Messi the god.

    Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2

    Comment

    • mgoblue2290
      Posts too much
      • Feb 2009
      • 7174

      #3
      Weak. You've already proved you can win with talent, try to build something up.

      Comment

      • calgaryballer
        Tiote!
        • Mar 2009
        • 4620

        #4
        Originally posted by mgoblue2290
        Weak. You've already proved you can win with talent, try to build something up.
        Why?

        I don't begrudge Phil Jackson for never going to coach the Clippers. If you're a good coach, and teams want you, why wouldn't you go somewhere that you have a great chance to win? Where would you have preferred him to go, so that he can 'prove' he is a good coach?

        Comment

        • BigHouseUSA
          Late to the party.
          • Jun 2009
          • 4907

          #5
          He took Barca to a completely different level, anyway. I don't see what else he has to prove. They had finished a considerable distance behind Madrid and Valencia the year before Pep took over. He got them playing better than anyone, and got the best out of Messi, Xavi and Iniesta.

          He's only 41, I doubt this will be his last job.
          Originally posted by mgoblue2290
          If you want to win, put Drew in.

          Comment

          • calgaryballer
            Tiote!
            • Mar 2009
            • 4620

            #6
            I think Bayern is the closest to Barcelona that you can get while still retaining a real chance to win the Champions League. Ajax and some other Dutch teams have a youth focus, but they aren't going anywhere any time soon. Bayern has a focus on developing their own and supplementing them with the best that Germany has to offer. It's a great fit IMO

            Comment

            • mgoblue2290
              Posts too much
              • Feb 2009
              • 7174

              #7
              Originally posted by calgaryballer
              Why?

              I don't begrudge Phil Jackson for never going to coach the Clippers. If you're a good coach, and teams want you, why wouldn't you go somewhere that you have a great chance to win? Where would you have preferred him to go, so that he can 'prove' he is a good coach?
              Bighouse's post actually sums it up pretty well. He's already proved he can do great things with very talented players. Why not take some club in a lower level league, or even a bottom tier first division team and see if he can't build them up. Even a side like Ajax, that you mentioned, a good team from mid level league. See if you can get them to compete year in and year out with the big boys. Its a different type of challenge.

              I'm probably letting too much of my own way of thinking get in the way here. My reasoning is really just what I would do if I were him. I just don't get the thrill of taking over a top 5 team. They are already expected to be in the thick of it for the Champions League every year if not winning it.

              Comment

              • Bigpapa42
                Junior Member
                • Feb 2009
                • 3185

                #8
                How often do big name, successful managers go to smaller clubs? Does anyone legitimately think Mourinho will end up at Aston Villa or Palermo if he leaves Real Madrid? Or if Mancini leaves City, he would end up at Sampdoria or Siena? World class managers, proven at the highest levels with trophy hauls, rarely end up at smaller clubs. Not impossible, but uncommon.

                A club like Ajax would be a poor fit for a manager like Guardiola. They have a very set vision for the club - tactically and in-regard to personnel. Although the Ajax youth system bears some similarities to the Barcelona cantina system, there are also some differences. Not to mention that Ajax is, fundamentally, a selling club. Most smaller clubs are, at the end of they day. But at Ajax, its basically become part of the identity.

                Comment

                • Anthony
                  In Brendan we trust.
                  • Jun 2009
                  • 5201

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Bigpapa42
                  Or if Mancini leaves City, he would end up at Sampdoria or Siena? World class managers, proven at the highest levels with trophy hauls, rarely end up at smaller clubs. Not impossible, but uncommon.
                  I get your point, and I totally agree. But this bit actually intrigued me for personal reasons, Sampdoria chased Rafa for a bit and of course Mancini had a long and successful career at Sampdoria. I wouldn't mind seeing Mancini at Sampdoria. I for some reason, despite not being a full fledged supporter, always find myself checking up on Sampdoria.

                  Comment

                  • calgaryballer
                    Tiote!
                    • Mar 2009
                    • 4620

                    #10
                    That was a while ago, not when they were fresh from a relegation. The Genoa/Samp derby was one of the best in the world for a while, then both had to sell and have fallen on hard times.

                    Comment

                    • Anthony
                      In Brendan we trust.
                      • Jun 2009
                      • 5201

                      #11
                      Originally posted by calgaryballer
                      That was a while ago, not when they were fresh from a relegation. The Genoa/Samp derby was one of the best in the world for a while, then both had to sell and have fallen on hard times.
                      Umm. Rafa was in talks with Sampdoria in June which is also when Sampdoria earned promotion . So I'm not exactly sure what you're getting at.

                      Edit- Are you're saying Sampdoria are going to relegated and so Mancini wouldn't go there? If that's the case of course he wouldn't. My original statement was me just be romantic about the game. I don't think in a million years he'd ever manage Sampdoria, but I think it would make for a great story.

                      Comment

                      Working...