ESPN Pound-for-Pound Rankings

[Fox1994]

http://sports.espn.go.com/extra/mma/columns/story?id=5464034

1 - Anderson Silva (27-4)
2 - GSP (20-2)
3 - Jose Aldo (17-1)
4 - Frankie Edgar (12-1)
5 - BJ Penn (15-6-1)
6 - Jon Fitch (23-3, 1 NC)
7 - Mauricio Rua (19-4)
8 - Jake Shields (25-4-1)
9 - Lyoto Machida (14-1)
10 - Rashad Evans (15-1-1)

Thoughts?

 

[stevsta]

they got #1 right

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

Looks like sherdogs. Amazing!

 

[CrimsonGhost56]

no one outside the Zuffa banner and thats the way we like it around these parts

 

[EmpireWF]

The only non-Zuffa guys you can consider for the PFP top 10 are Fedor and Nick Diaz. I'd say even Gilbert would be a reach at this point.

Fedor should still be up there. Everyone gets caught (even master Silva did).

 

[Liquidrob]

Zombie list

Fedor, Diaz, Melendez, Sandro, etc...

We need a revolution in the rankings

Also lol @ Gil being a stretch

 

[EmpireWF]

Melendez is there based on the wins against Thomson & Kawajiri. Although Aoki was a top LW at that time, he was never a top P4P fighter.

Fedor, Diaz, Melendez, Sandro, etc...

who else rob? enlighten everyone

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

Sandro?

How about Hector Lombard? Knocking out cans left and right.

 

[Liquidrob]

Eddie Alvarez?

Funny Mousasi gets dropped with a 5 round decision loss, but Machida gets blsted in a round and stays on

 

[EmpireWF]

Eddie Alvarez?

Funny Mousasi gets dropped with a 5 round decision loss, but Machida gets blsted in a round and stays on

You look at it like that, but Mousasi was dominated for 5 rounds, Machida was caught. Could go either way. I think Mousasi is in the 10-15 range after the loss.

The Aoki loss hurts Alvarez. Even with wins over Hansen, Crusher and Kikuno, nobody else is launching Eddie into top 10 PFP talk.

I will say Edgar at #4 PFP is a fucking joke.


FWIW, my pfp list:

1. Anderson
2. GSP
3. Aldo
4. Shogun
5. Fedor
6. Penn
7. Edgar
8. Machida
9. Diaz
10. Shields

 

[Liquidrob]

It's not just wins, skill set has to come into play, this is not divisional rankings

 

[EmpireWF]

It's not just wins, skill set has to come into play, this is not divisional rankings

theoretically, you'd like a nice balance

however if it was just perceived skills, lombard could lay claim to a top 10 spot, same with florian, mo, maynard, etc.


besides, this is all abstract anyway

 

[Liquidrob]

Mousasi won 1 maybe 2 rounds, didn't lose all 5

Funny Machida got 'caught' but Alvarez's loss to Aoki hurts

 

[EmpireWF]

Dont remember exactly which rounds (I assume Mousasi took the first), but I do remember in the championship rounds, Mo maintaining top position for most of it.

Okay about getting caught, it works both ways.

Since May 2008 (Ill count the Hansen win):

Alvarez is 7-1, the one loss to Aoki, wins over Hansen, Crusher, Imada, Kikuno, Neer, Reynolds and Loughran

Machida is 4-1, the one loss to Shogun, wins over Shogun, Rashad, Thiago Silva and Tito

are we going to argue whose wins are "better?"

Plus, there is no discernible way to argue whose skills are "better"

fuck it, my top 10 is right. you're wrong! :smug:

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

Mousasi has a lot to prove at the top level after that ugly loss. Machida has much better wins.

 

[Kuzzy Powers]

Lol @ the overrating of Frankie Edgar.