[360] IGN comedy

[Maynard]

they released there list of top 360 games....2010 version.

here is whats is comedy. there is only 2 new games on the top 10 list...RDR and ME2

Last year ME was #1, this year its #7. Last year COD4 was better than FO3, this year its not. GTA4 was better last year than this year....u get the picture

2009 top 10
#10 Gears of War
#9 Braid
#8 BioShock
#7 The Orange Box
#6 Halo 3
#5 Grand Theft Auto IV
#4 Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
#3 Fallout 3
#2 Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
#1 Mass Effect

2010 top 10
#10 Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
#9 Grand Theft Auto IV
#8 BioShock
#7 Mass Effect
#6 The Orange Box
#5 Halo 3
#4 Red Dead Redemption
#3 Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
#2 Fallout 3
#1 Mass Effect 2

im sure the rest of the list is fucked up too but i didnt feel like clicking each link to give them more ad clicks.

 

[jms493]

No Madden Brah??? Lame lists.

 

[MvP]

RDR was not that good.

 

[IamMedellin]

were the same people who did the 2009 list, responsible for the 2010 list?

 

[Maynard]

RDR was not that good.

no it wasnt....and it just occurred to me that when i just looked at the rest of their list, dragon age wasnt even in the top 25....WTF? that game was epic

 

[DomePatrol]

Its IGN. You cant honestly be surprised by this.

 

[killgod]

I thought RDR was meh too.

They did get #1 right IMO.

 

[Houston]

Mass Effect is the best game on the current generation.

 

[Buzzman]

Mass Effect 2 is the greatest game, RDR was amazing, idk what the hell you guys played, but what they achieved in that game makes a lot of other great games seem mediocre.

 

[Twigg4075]

8 out of 10 are multiplatform. Just sayin'. I'm curious to see the PS3 list. I just checked and they are only up to 16. Someone also pointed out that the 360's #3 (CoD4) is #17 on the PS3 list. LOL.

I'm not a fan of IGN by any means but kudos to them for actually linking you to the old list. They could've just pretended it never happened.

Also, LOL at anyone that thinks RDR isn't amazing. You're entitled to your opinion but I just can't see how anyone wasn't amazed by that game.

 

[Fappin Raptor]

Was GTA IV that great? If it really was I shouldn't have sold it.

 

[Buzzman]

GTA IV was sweet, but people love to complain.

 

[MvP]

RDR was great but not even close to being the 4th best game I've played on 360. And the game didn't impress me at all, I was actually pretty bored throughout most of the campaign.

 

[Twigg4075]

Where does Alan Wake rate on this list?

 

[dope]

is this like a top games available on the 360, no matter release date? if so it would explain why some games change rank. some games drop due to to new releases and old games continue to get played so they get bumped up due to longevity.

 

[Twigg4075]

is this like a top games available on the 360, no matter release date? if so it would explain why some games change rank. some games drop due to to new releases and old games continue to get played so they get bumped up due to longevity.

Yes it is.

 

[Maynard]

thats true dope, but my thing is that only 2 new games were added to the top 10 since the last years list. But for some reason a game like ME at #1, was bumped to #7

i mean, its IGN and a BS list that nobody would care about, really. i figured it would make for good discussion to see how whacked their lists are.

And i agree about RDR. i thought it was a extremely deep game and it was good and worth the money. But the story missions were not to captivating at all

 

[SethMode]

This list is bananas. For some reason, four of the games ME was considered better than last year, it is now worse than? How does that happen in a year? How does a game like Halo 3 jump games like GTA4 and ME just all of the sudden? Elder Scrolls just plummets to the bottom? I just don't get the rational, unless it's two different groups of people.

Even then, I have to agree about RDR. I really, really, enjoyed it. But it was nowhere near the 4th best 360 or even PS3 game I've played in both systems life cycle. I'd put it in the top 20 I'd say, and maybe even close to 10. But 4? No.

 

[Twigg4075]

I see Shatter got #11 on the PS3 list. Nice. That game is so awesome and so under rated.

 

[Buzzman]

this is why Mass Effect 2 came out and showed you how much better it was the the original, so when you go back and play the first its not as good. GTA dropped down because Red Dead did the same thing to it.