It's that time of the year again... Who are your top 10 QBs for 2013?

[Aso]

You people are why Eli's gonna make it into the HOF one day.

 

[Matt]

You people are why Eli's gonna make it into the HOF one day.

No by being a 2 time SB MVP is why Eli's going to make the hall of fame one day

 

[G-men]

Do you even watch football? Eli has been the definition of inconsistent since he entered the league.

OMG 59% completions :runaway: you totaled swayed me.


2009 he had a good season
2010 he threw a league leading 25 INT's just like he threw a league leading 20 INT's in '07

and in 2012 he padded his stats in a meaningless week 17 game against a bad Eagles team. 21 TD's - 15 INT's with under 60% completions

OMG HE'S SO GOOD.

6 TD PASSES IN 10 GAMES... THEN 20 IN THE OTHER 6...

Do people even watch Eli Manning games anymore or do they have amnesia from the rest of his career?

2009 and 2011 are the only consistently good seasons Eli had to where you could fit him into that elite category. Peyton Manning, Drew Brees, etc. have been doing this shit week in and week out and have played more consistently in games for longer than Eli ever has. To have him a spot behind them in some of these rankings is absurd. Why the fuck would Big Ben not be ahead of Eli? Can someone answer that. What makes Eli better than Big Ben in 90% of these rankings?

Inconsistent Eli is a pretty fitting nickname. I'm gonna stick with that.

It's pretty fucking obvious that you don't watch football and look strictly at stats. If you actually watch the Giants play, you would realize that Eli is the reason that offense functions, and the poor record this season is much more to do with the defense than it is on him.

Calling out jms on if he watches Giants games? :rofl:

 

[Aso]

I remember the Giants vs Bucs game quite clearly. Played like dog shit for 3 quarters and then threw for a ton of yards and TD's late in the game in what became a shootout.

Thing is Eli doesn't always end up throwing a bunch of TD's at the end like that which is evident by his 6 TD'S in 10 GAMES.

 

[NAHSTE]

2009 and 2011 are the only consistently good seasons Eli had to where you could fit him into that elite category.

Call me crazy but that's 1.5 more seasons than Kaep has done anything, period.

God this discussion sucks. Log off.

 

[Aso]

Call me crazy but that's 1.5 more seasons than Kaep has done anything, period.

God this discussion sucks. Log off.

Still doesn't explain why Eli is better than Big Ben. He's a QB that actually has consistently great years season in and season out. He's not even on some peoples top 10 let alone behind Inconsistent Eli.

 

[Woy]

Aso's one of the biggest reasons why the NFL section is the way it is today.

 

[Palooza]

I remember the Giants vs Bucs game quite clearly.

So this one time, I watched a game, and the players didn't play good and then they played good and touchdowns and stuff.

 

[Aso]

So this one time, I watched a game, and the players didn't play good and then they played good and touchdowns and stuff.

Yeah thats the only Eli Manning game I've seen in his 9 year career.

 

[Palooza]

Yeah thats the only Eli Manning game I've seen in his 9 year career.

 

[NAHSTE]

Still doesn't explain why Eli is better than Big Ben. He's a QB that actually has consistently great years season in and season out. He's not even on some peoples top 10 let alone behind Inconsistent Eli.

Wait you are quibbling that Eli should be ranked below Roethlisberger in an arbritrary list of quarterbacks based on ...

consistency?

:bosh:

Ugh. These threads really bring out the dumbest arguments.

 

[G-men]

Wait you are quibbling that Eli should be ranked below Roethlisberger in an arbritrary list of quarterbacks based on ...

consistency?

:bosh:

Ugh. These threads really bring out the dumbest arguments.

It's Aso, what did you expect? ESPN once said that Eli was inconsistent and that Kaep was great in his first 10 games, so clearly Aso knows that it is fact now.

 

[ThunderHorse]

It's Aso, what did you expect? ESPN once said that Eli was inconsistent and that Kaep was great in his first 10 games, so clearly Aso knows that it is fact now.

More like someone's homepage is PFF and they choose to believe everything they read from there.

I don't like these little shit throwing contests you interwebz dweebs thrive on so ill leave it at that, but there are statistics and there's what you see with your eyes - those attributes and abilities that are a little harder to conceptualize with words. I think Larry said it best when comparing how theoretically Eli manning would have finished the Super Bowl as compared to CK. he used the term "balls". And Eli has em, that's for sure.

Here's my 8

1-3 in whichever order you choose

P money
Brady
Discount double check

4. Brees
5. Eli manning
6. Big Ben
7. Matt Ryan
8. Joe Flacco

I think a better thread idea would be which sophomore (or second year starter at QB) is most likely to regress this season.

 

[Aso]

Has nothing to do with PFF or ESPN.

I know it won't matter because if I have an opinion in the NFL section it must be from a major sports new outlet. G-men pulling the same shit Steeljake started pulling almost 5 years ago. Typical cliche VSN response. Wouldn't expect much more from the ever so original G-men. Just fitting in with the VSN masses and has never had an original thought in his life. He's the loser in high school who imitates the "cool kids" in hopes that he'll be one of them.

Is anything I posted from either of those websites? If so point it out.

 

[G-men]

Has nothing to do with PFF or ESPN.

I know it won't matter because if I have an opinion in the NFL section it must be from a major sports new outlet. G-men pulling the same shit Steeljake started pulling almost 5 years ago. Typical cliche VSN response. Wouldn't expect much more from the ever so original G-men. Just fitting in with the VSN masses and has never had an original thought in his life. He's the loser in high school who imitates the "cool kids" in hopes that he'll be one of them.

Is anything I posted from either of those websites? If so point it out.

:stonecold:

Getting called a loser in high school by a loser in high school. I don't know how I'm gonna ever recover from such harsh words.

 

[Aso]

:stonecold:

Getting called a loser in high school by a loser in high school. I don't know how I'm gonna ever recover from such harsh words.

Probably by calling someones thoughts unoriginal while posting the same tired typical VSN responses. It's sort of your thing.

Your user description is right, you do post too much.

 

[G-men]

Aso going on the offensive. It's new but I like it. I know he's only had a short stretch of success, but he's young and versatile, so he's definitely already in the top 5.

 

[Houston]

These threads used to be better.

Thinking about it though, it's probably because Schaub was in the discussion.

 

[Rayman]

It's pretty fucking obvious that you don't watch football and look strictly at stats. If you actually watch the Giants play, you would realize that Eli is the reason that offense functions, and the poor record this season is much more to do with the defense than it is on him.

Fuck.
This.
Shit.

 

[AaronS]

Rodgers

Brees
Brady
Peyton

Big Ben
Romo
Eli
Matty Ice
Joe Flacco
Stafford