MLB Chise Trade Talks

[Lanteri]

Damn, Peavy, that's a tough call. If I wanted Peavy...

Jeremy Sowers
Asdrubal Cabrera

or...

Jeremy Sowers
Ben Francisco

That would be what I'd offer, probably not enough for that arm, try to substitute Sowers with Carmona, if you wanted some one from the Indians that is.

And in both cases you'd be ripping the Padres off big time.

 

[chazmaniandevil]

Anyone I can substitute for Vitters? I don't really have a problem giving up Guzman and Marshall.

i doubt it, the reason the padres didnt trade him is cuz they wanted those 3 players specifically, if you want to win the WS, id do it

 

[chazmaniandevil]

Can someone give me some ideas on what I can get for Jake Peavy?

I'm wanting prospects. A young starting pitcher, maybe a third baseman, maybe a second baseman, maybe an outfielder?

Doesn't really matter, just put some package deals I could do.

sean marshall, angel guzman, and josh vitters from the cubs, do it like in june or something

this is what they were looking for in real life

 

[Vinsane]

And in both cases you'd be ripping the Padres off big time.

That's why I said it's probably not enough for that arm, I'd throw in another player but I don't know who. Hafner? Shoppach? Not a whole lot of names that stand out on the roster. Sizemore if the Tribe wanted to commit season suicide.

 

[The Messenger]

I'm the Padres though so if the trade seems good to me, it wouldn't really be ripping them off.

I didn't like the Cubs trade, so that's why I'm exploring other options.

Do you think the Padres would trade Peavy and Chris Young together?

 

[Lanteri]

Looking to make a pretty big move in my Twins franchise. Particularly for a young SS. I'm considering a couple different scenarios:

First one:

SS- Trevor Plouffe, 23 years old, A potential, hitting .337 2 HR 9 RBI in AAA
LF- Luke Hughes, 25 years old, A potential, hitting .246 2 HR 8 RBI in AAA
RF- Denard Span, 25 years old, currently hitting .326 3 HR 12 RBI for my Twins

for

SS- Hanley Ramirez

Second One:

SS - Trevor Plouffe
CF- Carlos Gomez
SP- Anthony Swarzak

for

SS- J.J. Hardy, CF Tony Gwynn Jr, C Mike Rivera

Third

SS- Plouffe, SP- Swarzak, OF - Delmon young

for

SS- Jose Reyes

Thoughts?

 

[Mit]

Looking to make a pretty big move in my Twins franchise. Particularly for a young SS. I'm considering a couple different scenarios:

First one:

SS- Trevor Plouffe, 23 years old, A potential, hitting .337 2 HR 9 RBI in AAA
LF- Luke Hughes, 25 years old, A potential, hitting .246 2 HR 8 RBI in AAA
RF- Denard Span, 25 years old, currently hitting .326 3 HR 12 RBI for my Twins

for

SS- Hanley Ramirez

Second One:

SS - Trevor Plouffe
CF- Carlos Gomez
SP- Anthony Swarzak

for

SS- J.J. Hardy, CF Tony Gwynn Jr, C Mike Rivera

Third

SS- Plouffe, SP- Swarzak, OF - Delmon young

for

SS- Jose Reyes

Thoughts?

I'll tell you right now Reyes and Hanley will not move. They are franchise players. The most reasonable is the middle one, but I'm still not sure the Brewers would trade Hardy. Have you looked at Reid Brignac, Maicer Izturis, Alcides Escobar or Yunel Escobar?

 

[Lanteri]

I'll tell you right now Reyes and Hanley will not move. They are franchise players. The most reasonable is the middle one, but I'm still not sure the Brewers would trade Hardy. Have you looked at Reid Brignac, Maicer Izturis, Alcides Escobar or Yunel Escobar?

I'd agree with you on Reyes.

Hanley, I'm not so sure about. The Marlins have been known to ransom off their "franchise players" see: Miguel Cabrera. But you're probably right.

The other guys..none really interest me. I'm looking for someone that's going to be a game changer, so that leaves out Brignac and Izturis. Alcides isn't ML ready either so that leaves him out also.

 

[Rylo]

Hanley will never move.

 

[Vinsane]

I agree with Vikes, The only option I see is the second one.

 

[Rylo]

I wish I could trade Nate McClouth to the Marlins, but there is no way they would do that for anyone. Would they?

I would send them Uggla and someone else i dunno if theyd do it though lol

 

[FirstTimer]

Looking to make a pretty big move in my Twins franchise. Particularly for a young SS. I'm considering a couple different scenarios:

First one:

SS- Trevor Plouffe, 23 years old, A potential, hitting .337 2 HR 9 RBI in AAA
LF- Luke Hughes, 25 years old, A potential, hitting .246 2 HR 8 RBI in AAA
RF- Denard Span, 25 years old, currently hitting .326 3 HR 12 RBI for my Twins

for

SS- Hanley Ramirez

Second One:

SS - Trevor Plouffe
CF- Carlos Gomez
SP- Anthony Swarzak

for

SS- J.J. Hardy, CF Tony Gwynn Jr, C Mike Rivera

Third

SS- Plouffe, SP- Swarzak, OF - Delmon young

for

SS- Jose Reyes

Thoughts?

\
If you weren't the Twins I'd say package a deal for Alexi Ramriez of the White Sox.

 

[FirstTimer]

Dammit, can somebody tell me who I could trade Maholm for.

What are you looking for? Needs?

 

[goDawgs1433]

Escobar is crazy good for me in my Braves chise, just went 2-4, 2 doubles and made some silly defensive gems.

Yunel Escobar is the fucking man

 

[T.Dot]

Looking to make a pretty big move in my Twins franchise. Particularly for a young SS. I'm considering a couple different scenarios:

First one:

SS- Trevor Plouffe, 23 years old, A potential, hitting .337 2 HR 9 RBI in AAA
LF- Luke Hughes, 25 years old, A potential, hitting .246 2 HR 8 RBI in AAA
RF- Denard Span, 25 years old, currently hitting .326 3 HR 12 RBI for my Twins

for

SS- Hanley Ramirez

Second One:

SS - Trevor Plouffe
CF- Carlos Gomez
SP- Anthony Swarzak

for

SS- J.J. Hardy, CF Tony Gwynn Jr, C Mike Rivera

Third

SS- Plouffe, SP- Swarzak, OF - Delmon young

for

SS- Jose Reyes

Thoughts?

If you want to make it realistic trade Plouffe, Hughes and Swarzak for a veteran shortstop and a minor leaguer.

 

[Vinsane]

Would me trying to get Josh Barfield be a good idea?

I can tell you that you'll need to offer up a LF/RF as far as the Indians ranked these are their real "question marks" at least that's what the AI says. I'd offer up that, a SP if they're struggling, or a RP.

 

[Vinsane]

AA/AAA Prospect SP

 

[Vinsane]

3B Mark Reynolds (ARI) | 1B Travis Hafner (CLE)

This would get rid of Hafner who I'm not too thrilled with. Mark Reynolds comes in with 9 home runs, will be the featured DH, and will sub out with DeRosa/Garko for their 1B/3B duties. Also Kelly Shoppach is coming back in a couple weeks to take starts from Victor who will move to DH when not catching.

 

[Vinsane]

Cudi...over 800 players in the Major Leagues. Don't have us find your trade, look at the trading block, the rumor mill. Get some ideas and then ask us, Maholm for such and such.

 

[FirstTimer]

I am trying to trade Paul Maholm OR Jack Wilson.

I am looking for in order of importance:
1. SP

2. SS

3. OF

The White Sox waived Jerry Owens in real life so you could get him for nothing. The Cubs are deep in CF. You could get Joey Gathright for cheap.

A LOT of teams would be interested in a young lefty pitcher like Maholm. Same with Wilson having high interest. Why are you wanting to get rid of them? They seem like a great part of the Pirates young core.


Any particular type of player you are looking for? Trying to get into your mindset of who/what you want and what type of guy you are lookign for and that will help with trades.