Aroldis Chapman needs to be named the closer ASAP. Marshall has fucked up too many times if you ask me. I've been a Marshall hater since day 1 [him closing, that is...he is a great pitcher]. Personally I don't like my closer's primary pitch being a breaking ball. It's too easy for him to hang one in there on accident and give up dick shots. Plus his fastball is only in the low 90s, so when he throws that he gets hit a lot too. Time to switch the roles of Marshall and Chapman IMO.
I have no problem with the idea of removing Marshall from the closer spot, but I wouldn't put Chapman there. Two reasons.
-Chapman is best utilized in his current role. Dusty uses him in all of the high leverage situations...he comes in with men on base, pitches multiple innings in scoreless games, protects one run leads, etc. If he closes, the Reds will be using inferior pitchers in those situations, while Chapman is saved for clean innings, often times with two or three run leads. That's a waste, imo.
-If he is moved to closing, he's staying in the bullpen all year.
I believe the Reds are set up perfectly for a committee, but we all know that will never happen. So realistically, I would prefer Marshall stay in the 9th
for now, but if a move is needed, I would prefer to see Ondrusek or even Arredondo in the 9th instead of Chapman.
The best case scenario for the Reds would be to acquire a proven closer. It's still to early for that because the only team playing for next year at this point is the Twins.