More Drama!!! Nuk's top 10 quarterbacks (If they played for New England, of course.)

[Irish]

Tee Martin could lead NE to many superbowls. too bad those steelers ruined his career.

 

[Archer]

Is Jevan Snead really the top QB prospect next year?

No .... but he will end up coming out horribly overrated

 

[Nukleopatra]

Is Jevan Snead really the top QB prospect next year?

I certainly hope not. Then again, it is the Rams, so who knows.

I admit, though, I was pissed when St. Louis passed on Sanchez.

Damn, I wanted them to take Sanchez (It would have been enough to bring me back to the darkside.)

 

[strahanfan92]

I was Rams fan (since I was 12,) but didn't take too kindly to how they treated Warner, when he was given the boot. I can almost understand replacing him, but the booing of a guy who took you to two superbowls, isn't the way to go. Rams fans don't deserve to see success.

Good thing you weren't a Philly fan. Fuck, even Brad Lidge is getting booed, the only reason they won the series last year is getting booed lol...

 

[kyhadley]

I resent this thread.

 

[Len B]

I can't tell if you're implying that Tom Brady is overrated or not.

Fuck my sarcasm detector today.

 

[Nukleopatra]

I can't tell if you're implying that Tom Brady is overrated or not.

Fuck my sarcasm detector today.

I'm implying that no quarterback on my list would have won a superbowl as the quarterback of New England.

I'm really trying to imply, such an argument is completely ridiculous to begin with. Cincinnati drafted Carson Palmer #1 for a reason, to turn that team around. He simply isn't good enough to do it. A quarterback should be judged on what he does with the team he's playing for, not what he may or may not do on another team, who happens to have a much better guy under center, who just happens to do the job the right way.

This is a mockery of those guy who just can't seem to turn the corner.

Like the sorry sack of shit in my sig.

 

[steeljake]

As of September 16th 2009. This is my list of the 10 best Quarterbacks in the NFL.

This list is my opinion. Mine. The reasoning behind my list making logic is broken down into 3 factors - ''What if,'' ''Make believe,'' and ''Idiocy.'' I'm one of the few people to realize that posting a complete load of nonsense here at VSN, is the way to go.

Some of you will disagree with my list. Some may even laugh at it. Some of you may think that I know nothing about football after reading it, but if these guys played for New England, they would all be top 10 caliber quarterbacks, and here in fantasy land, that's what matters.

Well... here goes nothing.

10. Trent Edwards/Bills - He hasn't had a winning season yet, but stick him in New England, and you'd see a completely different player.

9. Derek Anderson/Browns - This guy is probably one of the most ignorant quarterbacks in the NFL. He has zero self esteem, and about as much talent as myself back when I threw the pigskin around. Then again, stick him in New England, and he'd have 3 rings.

8. Matt Ryan/Falcons - I know what you're thinking.. He's a second year guy, right? Doesn't matter.. Stick him in New England, and he'd have 3 rings by now.

7. Matt Cassel/Chiefs - 2nd year starter, but if he played for New England, they would have won the superbowl last season, for sure.

6. Matt Schaub/Texans - Injury issues plague Schaub, but in New England, that wouldn't matter.

5. Jason Campbell/Redskins - I know he's black, but even New England could make him a winner.

4. Vince Young/Titans - So much potential gone to waste. Has the mental capacity of a 5 year old, but in New England's system, he'd flourish. I won't go as far as saying he'd have 3 rings, though.. 2 max.

3. Jay Cutler/Bears - Terrible leader, plays the game for himself, but luckily in New England, that doesn't come into play. I mean, hell, even Tom Brady won superbowls there.

2. Carson Palmer/Bengals - One of the most underachieving quarterbacks in the NFL. He's currently 0-5 in his last 5 starts. Carson Palmer has had some of the worst performances of all-time, but it's clearly the organizations fault.. Hell, if Cincinnati had held Denver to under 12 points, Carson Palmer would be 1-0 right now. There goes Cincinnati holding him back again.

1. Drew Brees/Saints - 1 playoff victory in 7 seasons... 1-22 record as the saints starter when trailing after the 3rd quarter, even worse than Tony Romo who sits at 5-9. Yes, he did throw 7 interceptions in 3 highly important games last season, with the division and playoffs on the line. It's not like Matt Ryan was able to lead Atlanta to the playoffs, who was considered the worst team in the NFL. If you put Drew Brees in New England, he'd clearly be the #1 quarterback in the NFL, and would probably have 3 superbowl rings right now.

I'm almost sad Ryan Leaf quit so soon.. He could have kept going, because if he had played for New England, he'd have 3 superbowl rings right now. Where's Tim Couch?

Let the hating begin.

gold jerry, pure gold...

 

[DoubleDeuce]

Like the sorry sack of shit in my sig.

But your sig is outdated.

 

[Nukleopatra]

You jump to conclusions too quickly, I never said Warner wasn't good. I said he was too high at number 5. I think he gets too much credit, but that doesn't mean he sucks. It has been shown that he was not an NFL caliber starter without Larry Fitzgerald and Anquan Bolidin, fairly convincingly the NFLs best 1 and 2 wideouts these past couple years, or Isaac Bruce and Torry Holt arguably the best of the early part of this decade. I think its a fairly convincing argument against Leinart, btw, that he had a tough time given his targets, and its obvious that Warner is better than him. Don't put words in my mouth please.

I wasn't referring to you.

I meant the whole ''WR makes the quarterback'' theory in general, which some people still use. It's about as played out and ridiculous as the ''put this guy here or there, and he'd win.'' Scott Covington, Matt Leinart, and Jamie Martin didn't look so hot with those targets.

Arizona lives or dies by how Warner plays... and right now, Kurt Warner is playing like shit.

 

[Shayn•Da•Pain]

I wasn't referring to you.

I meant the whole ''WR makes the quarterback'' theory in general, which some people still use. It's about as played out and ridiculous as the ''put this guy here or there, and he'd win.'' Scott Covington, Matt Leinart, and Jamie Martin didn't look so hot with those targets.

Arizona lives or dies by how Warner plays... and right now, Kurt Warner is playing like shit.

I thought they were out coached. :laugh: I keed I keed...

Seriously though, what the hell was up with Fitz? It took him half the night to get open. Who was it Spencer that was covering him? Good job.

That underneath shit was working nicely though, and that D did a great job of shutting down Gore for the most part, not counting the two TD's he had, he wasn't very good. In fact the niners played like utter horseshit. I was shocked AZ couldn't get into the endzone in the 4th quarter.

 

[KINGOFOOTBALL]

9. Derek Anderson/Browns - This guy is probably one of the most ignorant quarterbacks in the NFL. He has zero self esteem, and about as much talent as myself back when I threw the pigskin around. Then again, stick him in New England, and he'd have 3 rings.

8. Matt Ryan/Falcons - I know what you're thinking.. He's a second year guy, right? Doesn't matter.. Stick him in New England, and he'd have 3 rings by now.

hahahahahaah

 

[Len B]

I'm implying that no quarterback on my list would have won a superbowl as the quarterback of New England.

I'm really trying to imply, such an argument is completely ridiculous to begin with. Cincinnati drafted Carson Palmer #1 for a reason, to turn that team around. He simply isn't good enough to do it. A quarterback should be judged on what he does with the team he's playing for, not what he may or may not do on another team, who happens to have a much better guy under center, who just happens to do the job the right way.

This is a mockery of those guy who just can't seem to turn the corner.

Like the sorry sack of shit in my sig.

Did Carson Palmer not turn the Bengals around before the injuries hit? They were pathetic, then suddenly catapulted to 11-5 and had a legit shot of beating the Steelers. Then, the team died as the coaching staff failed miserably without Palmer healthy.

 

[Nukleopatra]

Did Carson Palmer not turn the Bengals around before the injuries hit? They were pathetic, then suddenly catapulted to 11-5 and had a legit shot of beating the Steelers. Then, the team died as the coaching staff failed miserably without Palmer healthy.

He was healthy at the beginning of 2008, when he went 0-4.

He's healthy now, and about to go 0-6. Ryan Fitzpatrick even managed to win 4 games with that team.. I wonder if Palmer will even match that this year.

So, basically, because he got injured years ago, we're supposed to give him a break?

When do we get over that injury, and start expecting something again?