Most Over/Underrated Player On Your Team

[Miggy]

Tigers

Overrated: Brandon Inge (Mother fucker sucks)

Underrated: Miguel Cabrera (no ASG.... come on!)

 

[chazmaniandevil]

Overrated - Randy Johnson
Underrated - Pablo Sandoval

 

[chazmaniandevil]

Rays

Overated: Scott Kazmir
Underated: Willie Aybar

i guess zobrist is kinda in the limelight now huh?

 

[chazmaniandevil]

Anybody who doesn't know who he is by now shouldn't be in the MLB section.

eh, i can see how some people wouldnt know who he is, but i agree, hes that good

 

[chazmaniandevil]

Fuentes isn't that overrated, he's leading the MLB in saves

you should never judge a pitcher by wins or saves

 

[chazmaniandevil]

Overrated: Jim Thome

Underrated: A.J. Pierzynski (He's not really underrated, but I think he's one of the top catchers in the league.

fuck aj pierzynski

 

[mfbmike]

underrated: Curtis Granderson

:tiptoe:

 

[chazmaniandevil]

underrated: Curtis Granderson

:tiptoe:

i thought you would have said inge or edwin jackson, to me theyre much less known then granderson

or hessman by your chise =D

 

[mfbmike]

true. Edwin Jackson has come out of nowhere this year. Dude's got some nasty stuff.

 

[The Messenger]

Overrated: No one
Underrated: Posada, Teixeira, Cano, Jeter, A-Rod, Swisher, Melky, Damon, Matsui, Brett the Jett, Burnett, C.C., Pettitte, Chamberlain, Rivera, Veras, Bruney... there's more, but I don't have time to list them all.

 

[T.Dot]

Overrated: Vernon Wells
Alex Rios

Underrated: Adam Lind
Ricky Romero

 

[corbin]

Overrated: Stephen Drew

Trust me I would put more on overrated but at this point I think everyone knows, Chris Young, Eric Byrnes, Chris Snyder, and Connor Jackson suck.

Underrated: Mark Reynolds(arguably the biggest snub not named Pablo), Gerardo Parra(not sure how he wasn't starting at the beginning of the season), Clay Zavada(Got some of the best stuff on the team and should be the closer when Qualls loses the job)

 

[Buzzman]

AJ Persucksi cant throw a runner out for his life.

Tigers

Overrated- Josh Anderson and Curtis Granderson

Josh Anderson is fast, but thats all he is. He is a horrible base runner and can rarley hit anything out of the infield.

Granderson- Hes only overrated cause hes a lead off hitter. He gets on base on average once a game and bats .250. He strikesout twice a game.

Underrated - Armando Gallaraga and Placido polanco

Polanoc offense may be down this year but hes still got 40 RBIs and plays great defense and Gallaraga has been well the last month and is a solid #4.

 

[Obst]

Overrated: Brad Lidge

Underrated: JC Romero and Chan Ho Park

 

[Rudi]

Overrated: Bronson Arroyo
Underrated: Joey Votto and Daniel Ray Herrera

 

[BigHouseUSA]

Tigers

Overrated: Inge, also. He's great defensively, but his hitting is terrible. Luckily he's having an okay year at the plate.

Underrated: Polanco. Could've been Granderson but since he was just in the All-Star game, I'll go with Polanco, he's clutch.

 

[Anthony]

Over: Brian Bruney
Under: Brett Gardner

 

[Anthony]

Overrated: Mike Lowell...the classic player the fans refuse to let go of, so now that it's getting time to get rid of him..his value is low.

Underrated: David Ortiz this year...since June 1st the guy is batting like .300 with 12 homers. He even had a 1.062 OPS for the month of June. Not really too shabby for a guy having a awful season.

try again

 

[chazmaniandevil]

i agree with heel imo.

david ortiz is having a rebound and nobody's talking about it, wouldnt be as good of a story

 

[corbin]

I'll give Boston a crack

Overrated : Mike Lowell, J.D. Drew

Underrated : Ramon Ramirez, Manny Delcarmen, Kevin Youkilis

Ramon and Manny - have been getting underrated throughout the first half. These are two big reasons as to why the Red Sox have the most feared bull-pen in the league

Kevin Youkilis - I have always liked the way this guys plays. You rarely hear anything about this guy and he just continues to put up great numbers.