Overrated = Bronson Arroyo
Underrated = Joey Votto
Arroyo is serverly overrated by Reds fans, I haven't liked him since his first year in Cincy, he has continued to have horrible starts but wins games on being the lucky benefit of run support, by far this guy is the worst Starting pitcher the Reds have, yet I continue to hear him and Harang refered two as the top two starters in the rotation, just becuase they are the highest paid doesn't make them the best.
Votto is not underrated by Reds fans, he is Underrated by everyone else, this guy is a beast this guy puts up the numbers Adam Dunn was suposed to, he has only had one full year in the majors, and this year he missed nearly a month so he still won't have a full year, look for him to have a huge year next year if he stays healthy. The big problem is that playing 1st base he will never see an Allstar game with the likes of Ryan Howard, Prince Fielder and that guy St Louis all being NL 1B's