I've played only vs. so far. Probably about 10+ games or so online and offline vs. friends.
Online the game plays very smooth. I did have the game lock up on the menu screen 3 times right before the game was loading.
Overall I like the game. Without going into too much strategy, man defense is beastly in this game. People have been saying its because zone is broke, but it really isn't that bad. I know people get critical of the blocking in the game, and zone busts and how some plays and things don't work. But sometimes in real football games you have busted plays or assignments so I don't mind it that much.
I have seen an absurdly amount of Tennessee Volunteer users. Out of the 10 plus games, more than half of my opponents have been the Vols??? I guess people are loving that Bray to Rogers.
Catch animations are well done and not overdone. Passing is nice on the game. You have to be patient with running and not use turbo until you have to and be patient through the holes in the run game per usual.
I've been playing with the season ticket, and the graphics on the Ps3 are pretty jaggy on the edges of models and letters. Pretty weird. Don't know if it's because it's not the full retail version, but pretty bizarre. Doesn't bother me any, but it is noticeable.