NFC East: Quarterback Rankings

[Boucher]

Oh gawd, the grammar popo is hear





:star:

 

[Derrville]

Looks about right

 

[Rayman]

no

:youmad:

 

[Wildcard]

Romo
McNabb
Campbell
Kitna
Kolb
Brennan
Eli Manning

 

[Rayman]

not at all Ray...but postseason

ELI=====

McNabb=====

Romo====

Jason Campbell ONLY THING HE EVER WON

but come on seriously you cant say the only quarterback in the division to win a super bowl is the 3rd best in his division

And other than that one year, has he done jack shit, postseason, or otherwise?

That's why you can't get mad when I call it a fluke.

 

[Boucher]

And other than that one year, has he done jack shit, postseason, or otherwise?

That's why you can't get mad when I call it a fluke.

Hes done more than homo

 

[Point Blank]

1. Eli
2. McNabb
3. Romo
4. Campbell

 

[Rayman]

Hes done more than homo

Good for him.

If anyone of these things don't happen, Eli Manning wouldn't even play for the Giants anymore.

-Patrick Crayton drops a wide open pass on 3rd down

-DeMarcus Ware is called for a phony offsides

-The Dallas offensive line (and running game) dissolves in the second half

-Romo called for a bogus intentional grounding

-That drive before the end of the 2nd qtr



But somehow, Romo gets blamed for all of that, and as such is inferior to Eli.

:gtfo:

 

[Dan The Man]

And other than that one year, has he done jack shit, postseason, or otherwise?

That's why you can't get mad when I call it a fluke.

LOL, he had easily the best year of his career last year.

Try Again

 

[Rayman]

LOL, he had easily the best year of his career last year.

Try Again

Yea, before his security blanket got suspended for pulling a Cheddar Bob. Not the same when you don't have that 6-4 guy to constantly bail out your sloppy back-foot passes.

Meanwhile, that fluke is the only time he's beaten Romo head-to-head.

Maybe you oughta try again.

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

1a. Eli Manning
1b. Donovan McNabb
3. Tony Romo
4. Jason Campbell.

 

[Miami Flash15]

Looks good to me.

 

[Dan The Man]

Also, Romo had all his receivers plus Roy Williams who I had to hear about from Cowboy fans when that trade was made last year and had 2 chances to get his team to the playoffs.

He decided to throw punts to Ed Reed and then hand the Eagles the ball at will.

What's his excuse?

 

[Dan The Man]

Eli Manning threw more INTs than TDs in the playoffs when he won the SB. He's either #2 or #3, and considering the running game behind him and the defense, he's #2.

What?

 

[Rayman]

Also, Romo had all his receivers plus Roy Williams who I had to hear about from Cowboy fans when that trade was made last year and had 2 chances to get his team to the playoffs.

He decided to throw punts to Ed Reed and then hand the Eagles the ball at will.

What's his excuse?

I said it from the second the trade went down. Anyone who expected much impact from Roy Williams last season was a moron. That's to say nothing of the foot injury he dealt with that slowed him even further down.

That said, I expect big things from him this year.

As far as Ed Reed, Romo still brought the team back TWICE in the 4th quarter only to let his D fail him again. Revisionist history must be fun for Romo bashers.

I bet it's also Romo's fault that the team didn't get off the bus in Philly as well.

And he's STILL better than Eli

 

[Rayman]

fluke or not he still has a super bowl n an mvp

So does Trent Dilfer.

He must shit on Dan Marino.

The idiots that call Romo a choker honestly believe he'll never win a playoff game after only 3 years.

Hilarious.

 

[dell71]

Eli Manning threw most INTs in the playoffs of all the QBs that year when he won the SB. He's either #2 or #3, and considering the running game behind him and the defense, he's #2.

WRONG!!!

His stats for that postseason:

Wildcard game @ Tampa Bay: 20/27- 185 yds- 2 td- 0 int

Divisional game @ Dallas: 12/18- 163 yds- 2 td- 0 int

NFC Championship game @ Green Bay: 21/40- 251 yds- 0 td- 0 int

SB vs. New England: 19/34- 255- 2 td- 1 int

By my count that's one interception over an entire postseason. Please have at least some idea what you're talking about when you try to discredit someone.

You must've been thinking of his brother Peyton who threw a bunch of picks the year he won the SB.

 

[Maestro]

Good for him.

If anyone of these things don't happen, Eli Manning wouldn't even play for the Giants anymore.

-Patrick Crayton drops a wide open pass on 3rd down

-DeMarcus Ware is called for a phony offsides

-The Dallas offensive line (and running game) dissolves in the second half

-Romo called for a bogus intentional grounding

-That drive before the end of the 2nd qtr



But somehow, Romo gets blamed for all of that, and as such is inferior to Eli.

:gtfo:

I laugh at homers, You also forgot to put if Romo did not throw an interception into double coverage while he had a wide open man in the endzone at the end of a playoff game.

 

[Archer]

once again they fuck the skins!

Campbell is the fourth best qb in the division , no fucking going on

 

[Anthony]

McNabb
Eli
Romo
Campbell


P.S. I don't dislike Romo, but I strongly dislike their fans. Why are they always in denial?

Hardware > No Hardware

End of story.