NFC East: Quarterback Rankings

[Rayman]

I laugh at homers, You also forgot to put if Romo did not throw an interception into double coverage while he had a wide open man in the endzone at the end of a playoff game.

I forgot it's homerism to defend a guy with his track record in 3 years of starting when everyone says he's inferior to a guy with a 55% completion rate and a 76.1 rating over his career simply because he has one Super Bowl ring despite never doing anything before or since.

 

[Senser81]

I don't know what the criteria is for ranking the QBs. If we are ranking the guys at the present time, then you can throw past accomplishments and hardware out the window. I think Romo is clearly the most accurate of the 4 QBs. Manning forces too many passes when he doesn't really need to, and quite honestly I have no idea how McNabb's stats end up being decent, because he reminds me of Kordell Stewart most of the time.

 

[mobbdeep1122]

McNabb
Romo
Manning
Campbell

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

I don't know what the criteria is for ranking the QBs. If we are ranking the guys at the present time, then you can throw past accomplishments and hardware out the window. I think Romo is clearly the most accurate of the 4 QBs. Manning forces too many passes when he doesn't really need to, and quite honestly I have no idea how McNabb's stats end up being decent, because he reminds me of Kordell Stewart most of the time.

Hater.

 

[chubbz]

I'm a diehard Eagle fan. This is the list

1. Eli Manning
2.Donny Mac
3. Homo
4. Jason Campbell.

If you think otherwise, you must be a moron.

u really cant posibly be a die hard eagles fan because if u were u would kno that mcnabb is at least two times better than and other qb in our division. unless ur one of the dumb ones who hates him and thinks that the team can win more without him....which it seems like u r.

 

[chubbz]

1.Mcnabbynew-194tds-90ints-10 post season wins
2.Homo-84tds-46ints-0 post season wins
3.Sheli Manning-98td-74ints(omfg)-4 post season wins
4.jason "big lip" campbell(is he really even in this conversation?)-35tds-23ints-0 post season wins

i had to put homo ahead of manning because of the freakin inteceptions! did anyone know that hes thrown that many???? i was going to put him ahead of homo because of the bs superbowl that everyone keeps talkin bout, but when i say his qb rating i nearly threw up (literally). its close between them tho. i hate them bot tho

 

[Hasselbeck]

McNabb
Eli
Romo
Campbell

 

[chubbz]

I don't know what the criteria is for ranking the QBs. If we are ranking the guys at the present time, then you can throw past accomplishments and hardware out the window. I think Romo is clearly the most accurate of the 4 QBs. Manning forces too many passes when he doesn't really need to, and quite honestly I have no idea how McNabb's stats end up being decent, because he reminds me of Kordell Stewart most of the time.

dont tell anyone but, romo averages a pick or two a game.....:whisper:

 

[Senser81]

dont tell anyone but, romo averages a pick or two a game.....:whisper:

LOL at a pick or two a game, as if there is no difference between throwing 16 INTs and 32 INTs.

 

[Hasselbeck]

LOL at a pick or two a game, as if there is no difference between throwing 16 INTs and 32 INTs.

I believe that's the difference between Romo and Kitna.

I.E. Rayman better hope Romo doesn't have a serious injury again.. like a pinky or something.

 

[chubbz]

LOL at a pick or two a game, as if there is no difference between throwing 16 INTs and 32 INTs.

OK THEN he averages 1.58 pick(s) a game. is that better?:flowers:

 

[Senser81]

OK THEN he averages 1.58 pick(s) a game. is that better?:flowers:

Yes. :applause:

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

How does Donovan McNabb remind you of Kordell Stewart "most of the time?"...does McNabb have an odd scar that just shows up on his face from time to time. Or, is McNabb actually a homo most of the time.

 

[Saluki]

McNabb is clearly the best QB in the NFC East, then Eli and Romo are interchangeable to me, i think both are overrated. People say Eli was only bad last year cuz Plax was gone? Brees lost Colston and threw for 5000 yards, if your a good enough QB u can make your WRs work. Romo, well he's been a choke artist and an average QB so far, so 2 and 3 can go back and fourth to me. Campbell is clearly the worst QB in the division, if he doesn't preform this season his career is over.

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

McNabb is clearly the best QB in the NFC East, then Eli and Romo are interchangeable to me, i think both are overrated. People say Eli was only bad last year cuz Plax was gone? Brees lost Colston and threw for 5000 yards, if your a good enough QB u can make your WRs work. Romo, well he's been a choke artist and an average QB so far, so 2 and 3 can go back and fourth to me. Campbell is clearly the worst QB in the division, if he doesn't preform this season his career is over.

Eli Manning = Super Bowl ring
Drew Brees = ???

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

To me a super bowl ring doesnt necessarily mean that one qb is better than another. Dan Marino is better than Eli Manning and he didnt win a super bowl. So my point is Mcnabb is better than Eli whether he won a super bowl or not.

I think they are about even at this point in their careers.

Eli's on the way up. D-Mac is on the way down.

McNabb's better has been better then Eli's better thus far.

But, I think quite highly of McNabb.

 

[Hogle]

Eli Manning = pick throwing machine
Drew Brees = a couple yards off of an all time record

fixed

 

[Senser81]

How does Donovan McNabb remind you of Kordell Stewart "most of the time?"...does McNabb have an odd scar that just shows up on his face from time to time. Or, is McNabb actually a homo most of the time.

Inconsistent and short-arms his passes. I've seen games where McNabb makes 3 perfect passes in a row, then the next 10 passes bounce 5 yards in front of his receiver.

 

[chubbz]

Inconsistent and short-arms his passes. I've seen games where McNabb makes 3 perfect passes in a row, then the next 10 passes bounce 5 yards in front of his receiver.

cant u say the same about romo? except his stretch of bad throws are usually overthrown deep balls. i just really wanna see what romo does without t.o. we have already seen what eli does without plax. this season should really tell who the second best nfc east qb is. since we already kno who the best is

 

[Senser81]

cant u say the same about romo? except his stretch of bad throws are usually overthrown deep balls.

Romo is also inconsistent, but he's different. Usually you can tell right away whether Romo will be having a good game or a bad game. McNabb is harder to get a read on.